← Irodov Series·Problem 1.200prayogashaala.com
Irodov, Problem 1.200

A planet of mass M moves along a circle around the Sun with velocity v = 34.9 km/s (relative to the heliocentric reference frame). Find the period of revolution of this planet around the Sun.

Orbital speed v (Play scans 10 to 70 km/s) 34.9 km/s
The answer in one line

The period is T = 2πγMs/v³, where Ms is the mass of the Sun and γ is the gravitational constant. The mass M of the planet does not appear. With the numbers on screen, the radius of the orbit is r = AU and the period is T = s, which is days.

Problem statement

Problem 1.200. A planet of mass M moves along a circle around the Sun with velocity v = 34.9 km/s (relative to the heliocentric reference frame). Find the period of revolution of this planet around the Sun.

Interpretation. The planet goes round the Sun on a circle at a steady speed of 34.9 km/s. The speed is measured from a frame fixed to the Sun, which is what "heliocentric" means. The period is the time the planet needs for one full lap. The mass M is only a symbol: the problem gives no number for it, and the answer will show that it is not needed.

We assume the Sun is so much heavier than the planet that the Sun stays at the centre of the circle. This means the planet circles a fixed point.

We assume γ = 6.67 × 10−11 N m²/kg² and Ms = 1.97 × 1030 kg, because the problem gives neither. Both are values from the usual tables. The mass of the Sun is a slider.

We assume M = 4.87 × 1024 kg for the picture, only so that the pull on the planet can be written as a number. The answer does not depend on it, and it is a slider so you can check that.

Symbols: v is the speed of the planet, r is the radius of its circle, T is the period, ω = v/r is the angular speed, and AU is the astronomical unit, the distance from the Earth to the Sun, 1.496 × 1011 m.

The big idea in plain words

A planet that moves on a circle is always turning. Something must pull it toward the middle all the time, or it would fly off in a straight line. For a planet, that pull is the gravity of the Sun. So the pull of the Sun has to be exactly the size that a circle of that radius needs. That one sentence fixes the radius of the circle. Once the radius and the speed are known, the period is the length of the circle divided by the speed.

Look at the picture: the orange arrow is the pull the Sun really gives, and the violet arrow is the pull a circle of that radius needs. They have the same length. If the radius were different, one arrow would be longer than the other, and the planet would not stay on the circle.

Interactive derivation

The solution in each frame

Heliocentric frame

This is the frame the problem uses. The Sun is at rest at the centre. The only force on the planet is the pull of the Sun, and it points to the centre. The solution below is done in this frame.

Frame moving round with the planet

This frame turns, so it is not an inertial frame, but it gives the same radius. In it the planet is at rest. The pull of the Sun is balanced by the push outward called the centrifugal force, Mv²/r. Setting the two equal gives the same equation as in the heliocentric frame.

The solution step by step

Step 1, the force. The planet moves on a circle of radius r at speed v, so its acceleration points to the centre and has size v²/r. By Newton's second law the force toward the centre is Mv²/r. The only force is the gravity of the Sun, γMMs/r², so

γ M Ms / r² = M v² / r

Step 2, the radius. The mass M of the planet is on both sides, so it cancels. Multiply both sides by r² and divide by v²:

r = γ Ms / v²

Step 3, the period. In one period the planet goes once round the circle, a distance 2πr, at speed v:

T = 2πr / v

Step 4, put them together. Put r from step 2 into step 3:

T = 2π γ Ms / v³

Step 5, the numbers. Change the speed to metres per second first: v = 34.9 km/s = 3.49 × 104 m/s. For your sliders: r = γMs/v² = m, which is AU, and then T = 2πr/v = s. Dividing by 86 400 s in a day gives days.

Numerical check

The page puts the planet at distance r with speed v and lets the pull of the Sun act on it step by step, 4000 small steps per expected lap, and measures when it comes back to its starting point. This takes no formula for the period. The step-by-step lap time is days, against days from the formula, a difference of percent. Kepler's third law, T = 2π√(r³/(γMs)), gives days.

Five methods

1. Force method

This is the method used above: Newton's second law with the pull of the Sun as the only force. It is the fastest, because M cancels at once.

2. Energy method

Energy alone cannot pick out a circle, but it confirms the answer. With r = γMs/v², the kinetic energy ½Mv² is exactly half the size of the potential energy γMMs/r, with the opposite sign. This one-to-two split is the mark of a circular orbit.

3. Graph method

Draw the pull of the Sun per kilogram, γMs/r², and the pull a circle needs per kilogram, v²/r, against r. The first falls as 1/r², the second as 1/r. They cross at one radius only, r = γMs/v². The left graph on the picture shows this crossing.

4. Calculus method

Not needed. The speed is steady and the path is a circle, so algebra solves the problem and no integral is required.

5. Check method

Units: γMs/v³ is (N m²/kg²)(kg)/(m/s)³, which simplifies to seconds. Limits: a faster planet has a smaller circle and a much shorter period, because T goes as 1/v³. Real world: Venus moves at about 35 km/s and takes about 225 days, so the answer fits a planet like Venus.

Fastest: the force method. Most reliable: the step-by-step orbit check, because it does not use the formula.

What each slider changes

ControlChanges the answer?What it changes
Orbital speed vYes, strongly (T goes as 1/v³)r, T, ω, the pull per kg, the orbit circle, the arrows, the lap time on the screen and all three graph dots
Mass of the Sun MsYes (r and T grow in proportion to Ms)r, T, the orbit circle, the green pull curve, the speed curve and the period curve
Mass of the planet MNoOnly the pull F on the planet, the size of the planet dot and the arrows' numbers. M cancels in the equation, so r and T stay the same.
Picture speedNoOnly how fast the planet moves on the screen, in days per second
Target period (given-answer mode)Sets the answerSolves v = (2πγMs/T)1/3, then everything follows from v
Zoom, Auto-fitNoPixels per astronomical unit in the picture only

Parameters

QuantitySymbolValue used
Speed of the planetv km/s
Mass of the SunMs × 1030 kg
Mass of the planetM × 1024 kg
Gravitational constantγ6.67 × 10−11 N m²/kg²
Radius of the orbitr m ( AU)
PeriodT s ( days)

Exam traps

  • Putting the mass M of the planet into the answer. It cancels, so the period is the same for a small planet and a heavy one.
  • Forgetting to change km/s to m/s. Using 34.9 instead of 34 900 makes the answer wrong by a factor of 109.
  • Writing T = 2πγMs/v instead of v³. The cube comes from r = γMs/v² and then T = 2πr/v.
  • Using the Sun's surface instead of its centre for r. The distance is measured from the centre of the Sun.
  • Leaving the answer in seconds when days are asked for, or the other way round. One day is 86 400 s.
  • Mixing up the period (one lap) with the year. The year is the period of the Earth only.