← Irodov Series·Problem 1.201prayogashaala.com
Irodov, Problem 1.201

The Jupiter's period of revolution around the Sun is 12 times that of the Earth. Assuming the planetary orbits to be circular, find: (a) how many times the distance between Jupiter and the Sun exceeds that between the Earth and the Sun; (b) the velocity and the acceleration of Jupiter in the heliocentric reference frame.

Period ratio n = Jupiter's period ÷ Earth's period (Play scans 2 to 30) n = 12
The answer in one line

(a) Jupiter's distance from the Sun is n2/3 times the Earth's distance, which is times for n = . (b) Jupiter's speed is v = 2πR/T = km/s and its acceleration is a = v²/R = m/s², pointing to the Sun.

Problem statement

Problem 1.201. The Jupiter's period of revolution around the Sun is 12 times that of the Earth. Assuming the planetary orbits to be circular, find: (a) how many times the distance between Jupiter and the Sun exceeds that between the Earth and the Sun; (b) the velocity and the acceleration of Jupiter in the heliocentric reference frame.

Interpretation. Jupiter and the Earth both go round the Sun on circles, and Jupiter needs 12 times as long for one lap. Part (a) asks for the ratio of the two circle radii. Part (b) asks for Jupiter's speed and acceleration, measured from a frame fixed to the Sun. For part (b) a number is needed, so the Earth's orbit has to be known.

We assume the Earth's distance from the Sun is RE = 1.496 × 1011 m (1 AU) and the Earth's period is TE = 365.25 days, because part (b) needs them and the problem gives neither. Both are sliders.

We assume the Sun is so heavy that it stays at the centre, and each planet feels only the pull of the Sun. This means the pull of the other planets is ignored.

Symbols: n = TJ/TE is the ratio of the periods (the problem gives n = 12), R is a distance from the Sun, T is a period, v is a speed, a is an acceleration, γ is the gravitational constant and Ms is the mass of the Sun.

The big idea in plain words

The Sun's pull is what keeps each planet on its circle. A planet far away feels a weaker pull, so it needs less sideways speed to stay on its circle, and it also has a longer path to cover. Both effects make its lap longer. This is why the period is tied to the distance. If you know how the two periods compare, you can find how the two distances compare, without knowing the mass of the Sun or γ.

The picture shows both planets going round at the right relative rates. Count the laps: while Jupiter makes one lap, the Earth makes 12.

Interactive derivation

The solution in each frame

Heliocentric frame

This is the frame the problem asks for. The Sun is at rest at the centre. The only force on each planet is the pull of the Sun, and it points to the centre. The solution is done in this frame.

Frame fixed to the Earth

This frame does not apply. The Earth goes round the Sun, so a frame fixed to it turns and is not an inertial frame. It would hide the simple circle that Jupiter makes round the Sun, so it does not help.

The solution step by step

Step 1, the force for any planet. A planet of mass m at distance R moves on a circle with period T, so its speed is v = 2πR/T and its acceleration is v²/R = 4π²R/T². The Sun's pull is the only force:

γ m Ms / R² = m · 4π²R / T²

Step 2, Kepler's third law. The mass m cancels. Multiply by R² and divide by 4π² to get T² on one side:

T² = (4π² / γMs) R³

The part in the brackets is the same for every planet, because every planet feels the same Sun. So T² divided by R³ is the same for the Earth and for Jupiter.

Step 3, part (a), the distance ratio. Write the law for Jupiter and for the Earth and divide:

(TJ / TE)² = (RJ / RE)³, so RJ / RE = (TJ/TE)2/3 = n2/3

For n = 12 this is 122/3 = 5.24. For your sliders n = , so RJ/RE = , and RJ = m.

Step 4, part (b), the speed. One lap is 2πRJ and it takes TJ = nTE:

vJ = 2π RJ / TJ = 2π RE n2/3 / (n TE) = vE / n1/3

The Earth's speed is vE = 2πRE/TE = km/s, so vJ = km/s.

Step 5, part (b), the acceleration. It points to the Sun and has size v²/R:

aJ = vJ² / RJ = 4π² RJ / TJ² = aE / n4/3

The Earth's acceleration is aE = m/s², so aJ = m/s², which is mm/s².

Numerical check

The page puts Jupiter at distance RJ and lets the pull of the Sun act on it step by step, 4000 small steps per expected lap. The pull is set from the Earth: γMs = 4π²RE³/TE². The step-by-step lap time is Earth years against n = from the problem. The speed from that orbit is km/s against km/s from the formula, and the acceleration is m/s² against m/s².

Five methods

1. Force method

This is the method above: the Sun's pull equals mass times centripetal acceleration. It leads to Kepler's third law and then to every answer.

2. Energy method

Energy does not give the radius of a circle by itself, but it confirms the result: on a circle the kinetic energy is half the size of the potential energy, so a farther planet has less kinetic energy per kilogram, v²/2 = γMs/(2R), which falls as 1/R. That agrees with vJ = vE/n1/3, because R grows as n2/3.

3. Graph method

The three graphs under the picture show RJ/RE, vJ and aJ against n. The distance rises like n2/3, the speed falls like n−1/3 and the acceleration falls much faster, like n−4/3. The dot sits at n = 12.

4. Calculus method

Not needed. The speed is steady and the path is a circle, so algebra solves it.

5. Check method

Units: v is a length over a time, and a is a length over a time squared. Limits: for n = 1 the formulas give the Earth's own values, 29.8 km/s and 5.9 mm/s². Real world: Jupiter really is at about 5.2 AU and moves at about 13 km/s, so the answer fits.

Fastest: Kepler's third law as a ratio. Most reliable: the step-by-step orbit check.

What each slider changes

ControlChanges the answer?What it changes
Period ratio nYesThe distance ratio, RJ, vJ, aJ, Jupiter's orbit circle, its arrows, its lap time on the screen, all bars and all three graph dots
Earth's distance REYes for (b), not for (a)RJ, both orbit circles, the speeds and accelerations. The ratio RJ/RE stays n2/3.
Earth's period TEYes for (b), not for (a)The speeds and accelerations of both planets and the lap times. The ratio RJ/RE stays n2/3.
Picture speedNoOnly how fast the planets move on the screen, in Earth years per second
Target distance ratio (given-answer mode)Sets the answerSolves n = (RJ/RE)3/2
Zoom, Auto-fitNoPixels per astronomical unit in the picture only

Parameters

QuantitySymbolValue used
Period ration = TJ/TE
Earth's distance from the SunRE m ( AU)
Earth's periodTE days
Jupiter's distance from the SunRJ m ( AU)
Jupiter's speedvJ km/s
Jupiter's accelerationaJ m/s²

Exam traps

  • Using RJ/RE = 12 or 121/2. The law is T² proportional to R³, so the distance ratio is 122/3.
  • Thinking a farther planet moves faster. It moves slower: v goes as 1/√R.
  • Giving the speed in m/s without checking the size. The answer is 13 km/s, not 13 m/s.
  • Forgetting that the acceleration points to the Sun. It is not along the velocity.
  • Mixing years and seconds. One year is about 3.156 × 107 s.
  • Using the mass of Jupiter in the answer. It cancels in the equation.