A planet of mass M moves around the Sun along an ellipse so that its minimum distance from the Sun is equal to r and the maximum distance to R. Making use of Kepler's laws, find its period of revolution around the Sun.
T = 2π √(a³ / γMs) with a = (r + R)/2, which is T = π √((r + R)³ / (2γMs)). For r = AU and R = AU this is days ( years). The mass M of the planet is not in the answer.
Problem statement
Problem 1.202. A planet of mass M moves around the Sun along an ellipse so that its minimum distance from the Sun is equal to r and the maximum distance to R. Making use of Kepler's laws, find its period of revolution around the Sun.
Interpretation. The planet goes round the Sun on an ellipse. The Sun is at one focus. The closest point of the orbit is at distance r and the farthest point is at distance R. Kepler's laws are the tool to use. The answer is a formula for the time of one lap in terms of r, R, the mass of the Sun and the gravitational constant.
We assume the Sun is so heavy that it stays at the focus, and the planet feels only the pull of the Sun. Numbers use γ = 6.67 × 10-11 N m²/kg² and Ms = 1.97 × 1030 kg, with 1 AU = 1.496 × 1011 m. The problem gives no values for r and R, so they are sliders. The starting values r = 0.4 AU and R = 1.6 AU are our own choice.
Symbols: r is the smallest distance, R is the largest distance, a is the semi-major axis (half the long axis of the ellipse), e is the eccentricity (how flat the ellipse is), T is the period, γ is the gravitational constant and Ms is the mass of the Sun.
The big idea in plain words
Kepler found three rules for planets. First, each orbit is an ellipse with the Sun at one focus. Second, the line from the Sun to the planet sweeps equal areas in equal times, so the planet moves fastest when it is closest. Third, the square of the period is proportional to the cube of the semi-major axis. The same constant works for every planet round the same Sun.
The third rule is the key. The period depends only on the semi-major axis a, and not on how flat the ellipse is. So an ellipse behaves, for the time of one lap, like a circle of radius a. The picture shows this: the hollow ring goes round the circle of radius a and the planet goes round the ellipse, and they come back to the start together.
The solution in each frame
Heliocentric frame
The Sun is at rest at the focus. The only force is the pull of the Sun. Kepler's laws are written in this frame, so the solution is done here.
Frame fixed to the planet
This frame does not apply. A frame fixed to the planet is accelerating, so Kepler's laws do not hold in it.
The solution step by step
Step 1, the semi-major axis. The closest point and the farthest point lie on the long axis of the ellipse, on opposite sides of the Sun. Together they make the whole long axis, so r + R = 2a:
For your sliders a = ( + ) / 2 = AU.
Step 2, the circle case. For a circle of radius a the pull of the Sun is the centripetal force: γ M Ms / a² = M ω² a with ω = 2π / T. The mass M cancels:
Step 3, Kepler's third law. Kepler's third law says the same relation holds on an ellipse, with a as the semi-major axis. That is why a circle of radius a gives the right period. The relation does not contain the flatness of the ellipse:
Step 4, the numbers. a = m, so T = 2π √(()³ / (6.67e-11 × × 1030)) = s = days = years.
The page starts the planet at the closest point, r, with the speed from energy conservation, v = √(γMs (2/r − 1/a)), and lets the pull of the Sun act step by step, small steps (shorter when the planet is close to the Sun). The step-by-step planet comes back to its start after days, against days from the formula. The difference is percent. The same run keeps r × (speed at r) equal to R × (speed at R), which is Kepler's second law: km/s at r and km/s at R.
Five methods
1. Force method
This is the circle argument above: the Sun's pull is the centripetal force, which gives Kepler's third law for a circle of radius a.
2. Energy method
The total energy of the orbit is E = −γ M Ms / (2a). It depends only on a, which is the energy reason why the period depends only on a.
3. Graph method
The first graph shows T against R for the chosen r. T rises like (r + R)3/2. The third graph shows the distance against time: the planet spends more time far from the Sun than near it.
4. Calculus method
Not needed for the answer. Kepler's second law, dA/dt = L / (2M) = constant, is what gives the equal areas shown in the picture. The period then follows from the total area πab divided by dA/dt.
5. Check method
Units: T has the unit of a time because a³ / (γ Ms) has the unit of s². Limits: for r = R the ellipse is a circle and the formula gives 2π √(R³ / γMs). For r = 0.4 AU and R = 1.6 AU, a = 1 AU, so T is about one Earth year (367 days with the constants used here).
Fastest: the circle of radius a. Most reliable: the step-by-step orbit check.
What each slider changes
| Control | Changes the answer? | What it changes |
|---|---|---|
| Smallest distance r | Yes | a, e, T, the ellipse, the circle of radius a, both speeds, the areas and all three graphs |
| Largest distance R (header slider too) | Yes | a, e, T, the ellipse, the circle of radius a, both speeds, the areas and all three graphs. Locked in given-answer mode. |
| Mass of the Sun | Yes | T and all speeds. The ellipse shape does not change. |
| Picture speed | No | Only how fast the planet moves on the screen, in days per second |
| Target period (given-answer mode) | Sets the answer | Solves R = 2a − r with a from T |
| Zoom, Auto-fit | No | Pixels per astronomical unit in the picture only |
Parameters
| Quantity | Symbol | Value used |
|---|---|---|
| Smallest distance | r | AU |
| Largest distance | R | AU |
| Semi-major axis | a | AU |
| Eccentricity | e | |
| Mass of the Sun | Ms | × 1030 kg |
| Period | T | days |
Exam traps
- Using the average of r and R as a distance in the circle formula without saying why. It works because a = (r + R)/2 is the semi-major axis, and Kepler's third law uses a.
- Using r or R alone in the formula. The answer needs the sum r + R.
- Thinking a flatter ellipse means a different period. At the same a, every ellipse has the same period.
- Putting the mass of the planet in the answer. It cancels.
- Forgetting that the Sun is at a focus, not at the centre. The two distances r and R are measured from the focus.
- Mixing the semi-major axis with the whole long axis: the long axis is r + R, and a is half of it.