A small body starts falling onto the Sun from a distance equal to the radius of the Earth's orbit. The initial velocity of the body is equal to zero in the heliocentric reference frame. Making use of Kepler's laws, find how long the body will be falling.
The fall time is t = T / (4√2), where T is the Earth's period. This is t = days for the starting distance R = AU. In symbols, t = π √(R³ / (8γMs)).
Problem statement
Problem 1.203. A small body starts falling onto the Sun from a distance equal to the radius of the Earth's orbit. The initial velocity of the body is equal to zero in the heliocentric reference frame. Making use of Kepler's laws, find how long the body will be falling.
Interpretation. A small body is let go, at rest, at a distance R from the Sun, where R is the radius of the Earth's orbit. R is only the starting distance. The Earth is not part of the fall: it stays on its own circular orbit. The body has no sideways speed, so it falls on a straight line to the Sun. The question is the time until it reaches the Sun. Kepler's third law is used, so the straight line is treated as a very thin ellipse.
We assume the body is so small that only the Sun's pull acts on it, and the Sun stays at rest. The Earth's orbit radius is R = 1 AU = 1.496 × 1011 m and the mass of the Sun is Ms = 1.99 × 1030 kg, which gives the Earth a year of 365.25 days with γ = 6.67 × 10-11 N m²/kg². The starting distance is a slider, and R = 1 AU is the given case.
We assume the fall ends at the centre of the Sun, as in the point-mass model of the problem. The page also shows the time to reach the Sun's surface (radius 6.96 × 108 m). The two differ by a tiny amount.
Symbols: R is the starting distance, a is the semi-major axis of the thin ellipse, T is the period of a circular orbit of radius R (the Earth's year), T′ is the period of the thin ellipse, t is the fall time, γ is the gravitational constant and Ms is the mass of the Sun.
The big idea in plain words
The Earth's orbit only tells us how far from the Sun the body starts. The Earth keeps going round. The small body is a different object, and it falls toward the Sun.
Why a straight line? A body at rest has no sideways speed. The Sun pulls it straight toward the Sun, so nothing turns it aside. Why an ellipse then? Kepler's third law is a rule for orbits, and a straight fall is the limit of an orbit with a tiny sideways speed: a very thin ellipse. The law gives the time of that orbit, and the fall is half of it.
A body that falls straight to the Sun is a planet on an extremely thin ellipse. The Sun is at one end of the ellipse and the start point is at the other end. Such an ellipse has no width, so the whole orbit is one line of length R. Its semi-major axis is half of that line: a = R/2.
Kepler's third law says the period depends only on a. So the thin ellipse has a period much shorter than the Earth's, because a is half as big. One full period goes down to the Sun and back up to the start. The fall is only the first half, so t = T′/2.
In the picture the body falls along the line to the Sun, then comes back up the same line to the start. That whole trip, down and back, is one period T′ of the thin ellipse. The way down and the way back take equal times, so the fall we want is only half of T′. The bar under the line marks the two halves.
The solution in each frame
Heliocentric frame
The Sun is at rest and the body starts with zero velocity in this frame. The only force is the Sun's pull. The solution is done here.
Frame fixed to the Earth
This frame does not apply. The Earth goes round the Sun, so a frame fixed to it is accelerating, and the body does not start at rest in it.
The solution step by step
Step 1, the thin ellipse. The body starts at rest, so it has no sideways speed and falls on a straight line to the Sun. This line is the limit of an ellipse that gets thinner and thinner. The nearest point of this ellipse is the Sun (distance 0) and the farthest point is the start (distance R). The long axis is R, so
Here a = AU.
Step 2, Kepler's third law. T² is proportional to a³. Compare the thin ellipse (a = R/2, period T′) with the circle of radius R (period T, the Earth's year):
Step 3, half a period. One period T′ goes from the start to the Sun and back to the start. The fall is the first half only:
Step 4, the numbers. For the Earth's orbit T = days, so t = / 5.657 = days. In seconds, t = s.
The page drops the body from rest at R and lets the Sun's pull act step by step on a straight line, with smaller steps near the Sun, until the body reaches the Sun's surface. The step-by-step time is days against days from the exact fall formula for the same end point. The difference is percent. A separate sum of dd / v over 2000 slices from R to the centre gives days, against days from the formula. The fall to the centre takes days from T / (4√2), which is days longer than the fall to the surface.
Second method: energy and an integral
This method does not use Kepler's law. It finds the speed from energy, then adds up the time.
Step 1, the speed. Only the Sun's pull acts. The gain in kinetic energy equals the loss in potential energy, with U = −γMs m / d:
At d = R the speed is zero. The speed grows as d gets smaller, so the dots in the picture spread out.
Step 2, the time. Speed is distance per time, so dt = dd / v. Add this up from d = R down to d = 0. The speed has a square root, v = √(2γMs (R − d) / (d R)), so a good choice of variable makes (R − d)/d a perfect square. Try d = R cos²ψ, with ψ from 0 to π/2. Then (R − d)/d = (1 − cos²ψ)/cos²ψ = tan²ψ, so the root disappears: v = √(2γMs/R) tanψ. Also |dd| = 2R cosψ sinψ dψ. Dividing,
Draw a circle with the line from the Sun to the start as its diameter. A point Q on the circle is seen from the Sun at the angle ψ. The angle at Q is 90° (a triangle in a semicircle). So SQ = R cosψ. Drop a perpendicular from Q to the line. It meets the line at a distance d = SQ cosψ = R cos²ψ from the Sun. As ψ goes from 0 to 90°, d goes from R (the start) to 0 (the Sun). The circle is only a drawing aid for this step. The body itself moves on the straight line.
The numbers use the R and the mass of the Sun set in the main controls.
Step 3, the integral. The integral of cos²ψ from 0 to π/2 is π/4. So
This is the same result as T / (4√2). For this page, t = days.
Which other methods apply?
The force method (Newton's second law with constant acceleration) does not apply, because the pull γMs / d² changes all the time. Constant-acceleration equations give a wrong time. A graph only shows the result and does not find it. So two methods solve this problem: Kepler's third law, which is the fastest, and the energy integral, which is the most direct. The step-by-step fall in the numerical check is the most reliable.
What each slider changes
| Control | Changes the answer? | What it changes |
|---|---|---|
| Starting distance R (header slider too) | Yes | The fall time, the starting point, the dots, the speeds and all three graphs. Locked in given-answer mode. |
| Mass of the Sun | Yes | The fall time and every speed (t goes as 1 over the square root of the mass) |
| Picture speed | No | Only how fast the fall plays on the screen, in days per second |
| Target fall time (given-answer mode) | Sets the answer | Solves R = (8γMs t² / π²)1/3 |
| Zoom, Auto-fit | No | Pixels per astronomical unit in the picture only |
Parameters
| Quantity | Symbol | Value used |
|---|---|---|
| Starting distance | R | AU |
| Semi-major axis of the thin ellipse | a = R/2 | AU |
| Mass of the Sun | Ms | × 1030 kg |
| Period of a circle of radius R | T | days |
| Fall time | t | days |
Exam traps
- Thinking the Earth falls into the Sun too. R is only the starting distance. The Earth stays on its circle.
- Using the full period T′ as the fall time. The fall is half of it.
- Using a = R instead of a = R/2. The thin ellipse has a long axis R, so its semi-major axis is R/2.
- Thinking the acceleration is constant. The pull grows as the body comes closer, so suvat equations do not work.
- Using the Earth's year as the answer scale without the factor 1/(4√2), which is about 1/5.66.
- Putting the mass of the body in the answer. It cancels.
- Giving the answer in hours or years without checking: 64.6 days is about 0.18 years.