← Irodov Series·Problem 1.204prayogashaala.com
Irodov, Problem 1.204

Suppose we have made a model of the Solar system scaled down in the ratio η but of materials of the same mean density as the actual materials of the planets and the Sun. How will the orbital periods of revolution of planetary models change in this case?

Scale ratio η = real size ÷ model size (Play scans η from 1 to 1000, holding 4 s at η = 10) η = 10
The answer in one line

The orbital periods do not change. A model scaled down in the ratio η, made of material of the same density, has T′ = T for every planet, whatever η is. Here η = , and the Earth model has a period of days, against days for the real Earth.

Problem statement

Problem 1.204. Suppose we have made a model of the Solar system scaled down in the ratio η but of materials of the same mean density as the actual materials of the planets and the Sun. How will the orbital periods of revolution of planetary models change in this case?

Interpretation. Every length in the model is the real length divided by η. This covers the distances of the planets from the Sun and the sizes of the planets and of the Sun. The model is built from material with the same mean density as the real bodies. The question is how the time of one lap of a model planet compares with the time of one lap of the real planet.

We assume η is larger than 1 for a smaller model, and η = 1 is the real Solar system. The gravitational constant γ is the same in the model, and the model planets go round on circles because of the Sun's pull only. A slider for the density ratio is added to show what the "same density" condition does. Its value in the given case is 1.

We assume the real data used for the pictures are the Sun's mass Ms = 1.99 × 1030 kg and the planet distances Mercury 0.387 AU, Venus 0.723 AU, Earth 1 AU and Mars 1.524 AU (1 AU = 1.496 × 1011 m), with γ = 6.67 × 10-11 N m²/kg².

Symbols: η is the scale ratio, R is the distance of a planet from the Sun, Ms is the mass of the Sun, ρ is the mean density, T is the period, γ is the gravitational constant. A prime (′) means the value in the model.

The big idea in plain words

Shrink every length by η and the volume of every body shrinks by η³. With the same density, the mass shrinks by η³ too. The Sun's pull per kilogram on a model planet is γ Ms′ / R′² = γ (Ms/η³) / (R/η)² = (γ Ms / R²) / η. So the pull per kilogram is the real value divided by η.

A smaller circle also needs less pull. The pull that a circle of radius R′ = R/η needs is also the real value divided by η, when the angular speed ω is the same. Both fit with the same ω, which means the same period. The model planet moves more slowly (speed also divided by η) but has a shorter way round, so the lap takes the same time.

The picture shows two Solar systems drawn at the same size on the screen. They go round in step. The real numbers are written under each one.

Interactive derivation

The solution in each frame

Heliocentric frame

The Sun is at rest at the centre in both the real system and the model. Each planet goes round it on a circle. The solution is done in this frame.

Frame fixed to a planet

This frame does not apply. The planet goes round the Sun, so a frame fixed to it is accelerating, and Kepler's third law is not written in it.

The solution step by step

Step 1, the period of a planet. The Sun's pull is the centripetal force: γ m Ms / R² = m (2π/T)² R. The mass m cancels:

T = 2π R3/2 / √(γ Ms)

Step 2, the model distance. All lengths are divided by η, so R′ = R / η.

Step 3, the model Sun's mass. The mass is density times volume. The volume goes as length cubed, and the density is the same:

Ms′ = ρ V′ = ρ V / η³ = Ms / η³

Step 4, the model period. Put R′ and Ms′ into the formula from Step 1:

T′ = 2π (R/η)3/2 / √(γ Ms / η³) = 2π R3/2 η-3/2 η3/2 / √(γ Ms) = T

The two factors of η cancel. The periods of the model planets are the same as the real ones, for every planet and every η.

Step 5, with a different density. If the model material had a density ρ′ = d ρ, then Ms′ = d Ms / η³ and T′ = T / √d. For your sliders d = , so T′ = / = days for the Earth.

Step 6, the other quantities. For η = : R′ = m, Ms′ = kg, the Earth's model speed is m/s against m/s for the real Earth.

Numerical check

The page puts a model Earth at R′ = R/η from a model Sun of mass Ms′, and lets the Sun's pull act step by step, 4000 small steps per expected lap. The step-by-step lap takes days against days from the formula. The difference is percent. The same step-by-step run for the real Earth gives days.

Five methods

1. Force method

This is the method above: the pull equals the centripetal force, and η cancels.

2. Energy method

On a circle, v² = γ Ms / R. In the model, v′² = γ (Ms/η³) / (R/η) = v² / η², so v′ = v / η. The period is 2πR′ / v′ = 2πR / v, which is the real one.

3. Graph method

The first graph shows the period of the Earth model against η. It is a flat line. The second graph shows the log of each ratio: the distance and the speed fall with a slope of −1, the mass with a slope of −3, and the period stays at 0. The third graph shows what changes the period: the density.

4. Calculus method

Not needed. The algebra with powers of η is enough.

5. Check method

Units: R³ / (γ Ms) has the unit of s². Limit: for η = 1 the model is the real system, and T′ = T. Another view: Ms = (4/3) π ρ Rs³ with Rs the radius of the Sun, so T² = 3π (R/Rs)³ / (γ ρ). The model has the same ratio R/Rs and the same density ρ, so T is the same.

Fastest: put R′ and Ms′ into Kepler's law and watch η cancel. Most reliable: the step-by-step orbit check.

What each slider changes

ControlChanges the answer?What it changes
Scale ratio η (header slider too)Not the periodR′, Ms′, the speeds, the accelerations, the scale bar under the model and the dots on graphs 1 and 2. The period stays the same, and its note says why.
Density ratio ρ′/ρYesThe model's period (T′ = T/√d), how fast the model goes round on the screen, the model's Sun mass and graph 3. Locked in given-answer mode.
Picture speedNoOnly how fast the systems move on the screen, in days per second
Target period ratio T′/T (given-answer mode)Sets the answerSolves d = (T/T′)²
Zoom, Auto-fitNoThe size of both pictures on the screen

Parameters

QuantityRealModel
Scale ratio η1
Earth's distance R m m
Mass of the Sun kg kg
Earth's speed m/s m/s
Earth's period days days
Density ratio1

Exam traps

  • Scaling the distances but forgetting that the Sun's mass changes. The mass goes down by η³ when all lengths go down by η.
  • Saying the model planets move at the same speed. The speed is the real one divided by η. Only the period is the same.
  • Thinking a smaller system goes round faster because the path is shorter. The path is shorter, but the pull is weaker, so the speed is lower by the same factor.
  • Using the density of the material wrongly: the periods stay the same only if the density is the same. A denser model has shorter periods (T′ = T/√d).
  • Mixing up η and 1/η. Here η is the scale-down ratio, so lengths are divided by it.
  • Forgetting that every planet keeps its own period: the model Mercury still takes 88 days and the model Mars 687 days.