← Irodov Series·Problem 1.205prayogashaala.com
Irodov, Problem 1.205

A double star is a system of two stars moving around the centre of inertia of the system due to gravitation. Find the distance between the components of the double star, if its total mass equals M and the period of revolution T.

Period T of revolution, in years (Play scans T from 0.05 to 100 years, holding 4 s at T = 1 year) T = 1 yr
The answer in one line

The distance between the two stars is r = ³√(γ M T² / (4π²)), where M is the total mass and T is the period. For M = solar masses and T = years this is r = AU ( m). How the mass is shared between the two stars does not change r.

Problem statement

Problem 1.205. A double star is a system of two stars moving around the centre of inertia of the system due to gravitation. Find the distance between the components of the double star, if its total mass equals M and the period of revolution T.

Interpretation. Two stars pull on each other and both go round their common centre of inertia (the centre of mass). The distance between them is r, and one lap of the pair takes the time T. The task is to find r from M = m1 + m2 and T.

We assume both stars move on circles around the centre of inertia, so the distance r stays the same. We assume nothing else pulls on them. The problem gives no numbers, so M, T and the ratio m1/m2 are sliders. The starting values M = 2 solar masses, T = 1 year and m1/m2 = 2 are our own choice. We use γ = 6.67 × 10-11 N m²/kg², one solar mass 1.99 × 1030 kg, 1 AU = 1.496 × 1011 m and 1 year = 365.25 days.

Symbols: m1 and m2 are the star masses, M is their total, r is the distance between the stars, r1 and r2 are their distances from the centre of inertia, ω = 2π/T is the angular speed, T is the period and γ is the gravitational constant.

The big idea in plain words

Each star is pulled toward the other, and the two pulls are equal and opposite. Neither star stays still: both go round the point where the line between them balances, the centre of inertia. The heavy star stays close to this point and the light star goes far round it. The line joining the stars always passes through the centre of inertia, so both stars turn through the same angle in the same time, with the same ω.

That gives a neat result. The pull on a star is γm1m2/r², and its own circle is smaller than r. When we write the equation for one star, the other mass and the smaller radius combine into the total mass M. So the double star behaves like a planet going round a fixed Sun of mass M, at the distance r.

The left picture shows the real pair. The right picture shows a single star of the reduced mass going round a fixed centre at the same distance r. They go round with the same period.

Interactive derivation

The solution in each frame

Frame of the centre of inertia

The centre of inertia has no force on it, so it stays at rest (or moves steadily), and this frame is inertial. Both stars go round it on circles. The solution is done in this frame.

Frame fixed to one star

This frame does not apply. A star goes round the centre of inertia, so a frame fixed to it is accelerating. In that frame the other star moves on a circle of radius r, which is the same as the reduced-mass picture, but the force equation would need an extra term.

The solution step by step

Step 1, the centre of inertia. The centre of inertia divides the line between the stars so that m1 r1 = m2 r2, and r1 + r2 = r. Solving:

r1 = r m2 / M, r2 = r m1 / M

For your sliders r1 = AU and r2 = AU.

Step 2, the force on star 1. The pull of star 2 is the centripetal force on star 1, which moves on a circle of radius r1 with angular speed ω:

γ m1 m2 / r² = m1 ω² r1 = m1 ω² r m2 / M

The masses m1 and m2 cancel from both sides:

ω² = γ M / r³

Step 3, the distance. Put ω = 2π/T and solve for r:

r³ = γ M T² / (4π²) so r = ³√(γ M T² / (4π²))

Step 4, the numbers. M = kg and T = s give r = ³√(6.67e-11 × × ()² / (4π²)) = m = AU.

Step 5, the speeds. v1 = ω r1 = km/s and v2 = ω r2 = km/s. The momenta m1v1 and m2v2 are equal and opposite, so the centre of inertia stays at rest.

Numerical check

The page puts the two stars at distance r with speeds ω r1 and ω r2 in opposite directions, and lets the pull between them act step by step, 4000 small steps per expected lap. The step-by-step pair makes one lap in years against T = years. The distance between the stars stays between AU and AU against r = AU from the formula. The centre of inertia moves by only AU in the whole lap.

Five methods

1. Force method

This is the method above: the pull of one star is the centripetal force on the other.

2. Energy method

The total kinetic energy of the pair is ½ μ ω² r², with the reduced mass μ = m1m2/M. For circular motion it equals half the size of the potential energy γ m1 m2/r, which gives the same ω² = γ M / r³.

3. Graph method

The first two graphs show r against T and against M on log scales. They are straight lines with slopes 2/3 and 1/3. The third graph shows how r is shared into r1 and r2 by the mass ratio while their sum stays r.

4. Calculus method

Not needed. The algebra above is enough.

5. Check method

Units: γ M T² has the unit m³. Limit: if m2 is much smaller than m1, then r1 is almost 0 and the formula becomes Kepler's third law for a planet going round a fixed star of mass M. Real world: for M = 2 solar masses and T = 1 year, r = 1.26 AU.

Fastest: the reduced-mass picture with the single star μ. Most reliable: the step-by-step pair check.

What each slider changes

ControlChanges the answer?What it changes
Period T (header slider too)Yesr (goes as T to the power 2/3), r1, r2, both speeds, ω, the circles, the arrows and graph dots. Locked in given-answer mode.
Total mass MYesr (goes as M to the power 1/3), r1, r2, both speeds, the star sizes and graph dots
Mass ratio m1/m2Not rOnly how r is shared: r1, r2, v1, v2, the star sizes, the reduced mass and graph 3. It does not change r or T, because M alone is in the answer.
Picture speedNoOnly how fast the stars move on the screen, in laps per second
Target distance r (given-answer mode)Sets the answerSolves T = 2π √(r³ / (γ M))
Zoom, Auto-fitNoPixels per AU in the picture only

Parameters

QuantitySymbolValue used
Total massM solar masses = kg
Mass ratiom1/m2
PeriodT years = s
Distance between the starsr AU = m
Orbit radiir1, r2 AU, AU
Speedsv1, v2 km/s, km/s

Exam traps

  • Using only one star's mass in the formula. The answer needs the total mass M = m1 + m2.
  • Calling r the radius of one star's orbit. r is the distance between the stars. The orbit radii are r1 and r2, and they add up to r.
  • Putting r1 into the force law. The pull uses the distance r between the stars, while the centripetal acceleration uses r1.
  • Thinking the heavier star has the larger orbit. The heavier star has the smaller orbit: m1 r1 = m2 r2.
  • Thinking the stars have different periods. The line joining them turns as one, so both have the same T.
  • Mixing years and seconds. One year is about 3.156 × 107 s.