Find the potential energy of the gravitational interaction (a) of two mass points of masses m1 and m2 located at a distance r from each other; (b) of a mass point of mass m and a thin uniform rod of mass M and length l, if they are located along a straight line at a distance a from each other; also find the force of their interaction.
(a) U = −γ m1 m2 / r, which is J for your sliders. (b) U = −(γ m M / l) ln(1 + l/a), which is J, and the force of attraction is F = γ m M / (a (a + l)) = N.
Problem statement
Problem 1.206. Find the potential energy of the gravitational interaction (a) of two mass points of masses m1 and m2 located at a distance r from each other; (b) of a mass point of mass m and a thin uniform rod of mass M and length l, if they are located along a straight line at a distance a from each other; also find the force of their interaction.
Interpretation. Part (a) asks for the energy stored in the pull between two small masses. Part (b) asks the same for a small mass and a rod that lie on one straight line, and also for the pull between them. Potential energy of gravity is measured from zero when the bodies are infinitely far apart.
We assume the distance a in part (b) is measured from the point mass to the nearer end of the rod, which is the usual reading. The problem gives no numbers, so the masses and distances are sliders. Masses are in 1024 kg and distances in megametres (1 Mm = 106 m). The starting values are our own choice. We use γ = 6.67 × 10-11 N m²/kg².
Symbols: γ is the gravitational constant, U is the potential energy, F is the force, V is the potential (energy per kilogram). In part (b) the point mass is on the axis of the rod and x is the distance from it to a small piece of the rod.
The big idea in plain words
Gravity pulls two bodies together, so we must do work to pull them apart. Potential energy is the work we must do to separate them to a very large distance, with a minus sign, so it is negative when the bodies are bound. For two points the force is γ m1 m2 / x² at distance x, and the work to separate them from r to infinity is the sum of force times small step for all the steps from r outward. That sum is γ m1 m2 / r.
For a rod the mass is spread out. We cut the rod into thin pieces. Each piece is a point mass at its own distance x, so it has its own small energy. Adding the energies of all pieces gives the total. The pieces nearer to the point mass count more, because the energy goes as 1/x. This sum is a logarithm.
Use the tabs under the header bar to switch between part (a) and part (b). The picture and the graphs follow the tab.
The solution in each frame
Frame at rest
Potential energy of a pair depends only on the distance between the bodies, so any frame in which the two bodies are at rest gives the same answer. The solution is done in that frame.
Frame fixed to one body
This frame adds nothing here. The energy does not depend on the frame, so no second frame is needed.
The solution step by step
Part (a), step 1. The gravitational potential of m1 at distance x is V(x) = −γ m1 / x. This is the work per kilogram done against gravity to bring a small mass from infinity to x. It comes from the field G = −γ m1 / x² and the sum of G times step:
Part (a), step 2. The energy of m2 in this potential is m2 V. The same argument for m1 in the potential of m2 gives the same number, so it is one energy shared by the pair:
Part (b), step 1. Put the point mass at the origin. A piece of the rod of length dx at distance x has mass dM = (M/l) dx and its energy is
Part (b), step 2. The rod goes from x = a to x = a + l. Add all the pieces:
For your sliders U = J.
Part (b), step 3, the force. The force of attraction is the rate at which the energy changes with the distance a: F = −∂U/∂a in the direction of increasing energy, which is the pull toward the rod:
For your sliders F = N, directed toward the rod.
Check of the limits. For a long distance (a much larger than l), ln(1 + l/a) is nearly l/a, so U becomes −γ m M / a and F becomes γ m M / a², which are the results for two point masses.
Part (a): the page adds up force times a small step from r outward, with steps that grow along a logarithmic grid to 107 r, and gets J against J from the formula. Part (b): the page cuts the rod into 4000 equal pieces and adds the energy of each piece, which gives J against J from the formula (difference percent). Adding the pull of every piece gives N, and the slope of U against a gives N, against N from the formula.
Five methods
1. Force method
Add up force times step from the distance out to infinity. This is how part (a) is done.
2. Energy method
Add the energies of the pieces of the rod, as in part (b). Energy adds directly, because it is a number and not a vector.
3. Graph method
The area under the force graph from r to infinity is the size of U. The graph of U against distance rises toward zero, and the slope of that graph at a point is the force.
4. Calculus method
Both parts use integrals: the integral of 1/x² for part (a) and the integral of 1/x for part (b). The force in part (b) is the derivative of U with respect to a.
5. Check method
Units: γ m1 m2 / r has the unit N m² kg-2 kg² m-1 = J. Limit: for a long way off the rod behaves like a point. Another check: if the rod is cut in half, each half has mass M/2 and the energies add.
Fastest: the formulas themselves. Most reliable: the sum over 4000 pieces.
What each slider changes
| Control | Part | What it changes |
|---|---|---|
| Mass m1, mass m2 | (a) | U, F, the body sizes, the energy bar and all three graphs. U and F are both proportional to m1 m2. |
| Distance r (header slider in tab a) | (a) | U (goes as 1/r), F (goes as 1/r²), the picture and the dots on the graphs. Locked in given-answer mode. |
| Point mass m, rod mass M | (b) | U, F, the colours of the rod pieces, the body sizes and all three graphs. Both are proportional to m M. |
| Rod length l | (b) | The rod in the picture, U, F, the pieces and graph 3. For a fixed M a longer rod puts mass farther away, so U becomes less negative. |
| Gap a (header slider in tab b) | (b) | The rod position, U, F, the pieces, the tangent on graph 1 and the dots. Locked in given-answer mode. |
| Target |U| (given-answer mode) | both | Sets U and the model solves the distance: r = γ m1 m2 / |U| in (a), and a from ln(1 + l/a) = |U| l / (γ m M) in (b) |
| Zoom | both | Pixels per megametre in the picture only |
Parameters
| Quantity | Symbol | Value used |
|---|---|---|
| Masses, part (a) | m1, m2 | , × 1024 kg |
| Distance, part (a) | r | Mm |
| Point mass, rod mass | m, M | , × 1024 kg |
| Rod length, gap | l, a | Mm, Mm |
| Potential energies | U(a), U(b) | J, J |
| Forces | F(a), F(b) | N, N |
Exam traps
- Writing U = +γ m1 m2 / r. The energy is negative, because zero is at infinity and the bodies are bound.
- Using the formula for two points in part (b) with the distance to the centre of the rod. That is only right when a is much larger than l.
- Measuring a from the middle of the rod. Here a is the gap to the nearer end, and the rod runs from a to a + l.
- Forgetting the factor M/l for the mass of a piece, or integrating 1/x² instead of 1/x for the energy.
- Giving the force of the rod as γ m M / a². The right result is γ m M / (a (a + l)), which is smaller.
- Counting the pair energy twice. U is one energy for the pair, not one for each body.