A planet of mass m moves along an ellipse around the Sun so that its maximum and minimum distances from the Sun are equal to r1 and r2 respectively. Find the angular momentum M of this planet relative to the centre of the Sun.
M = m √(2γMs r1 r2 / (r1 + r2)), which is kg m²/s for your sliders. M = m v2 r2 = m v1 r1 at every point of the orbit.
Problem statement
Problem 1.207. A planet of mass m moves along an ellipse around the Sun so that its maximum and minimum distances from the Sun are equal to r1 and r2 respectively. Find the angular momentum M of this planet relative to the centre of the Sun.
Interpretation. The planet circles the Sun on an ellipse, with the Sun at one focus. The farthest point is at distance r1 and the nearest point is at distance r2. The question asks for one number, the angular momentum of the planet about the Sun, written with m, r1, r2 and the Sun's mass. The letter M here means angular momentum, not a mass.
We assume only the pull of the Sun acts on the planet, and the Sun is so heavy that it does not move. The problem gives no numbers, so m, r1, r2 and the mass of the Sun Ms are sliders. The starting values are our own choice: r1 = 1.6 AU, r2 = 0.4 AU, Ms = 1.97 × 1030 kg, and a planet of 6 × 1024 kg. We use γ = 6.67 × 10-11 N m²/kg².
Symbols: γ is the gravitational constant, Ms the mass of the Sun, v1 and v2 the speeds of the planet at the farthest and nearest points, d the distance now, v⊥ the part of the velocity at right angles to the line to the Sun. Angular momentum of a moving mass is m × distance × sideways speed.
The big idea in plain words
The pull of the Sun always points straight at the Sun. A pull along the line to the Sun cannot turn the planet around the Sun, so the angular momentum about the Sun never changes. At the nearest and farthest points the planet moves exactly sideways to the line to the Sun, so there the angular momentum is simply m v r. That gives m v1 r1 = m v2 r2.
That is one equation for two unknown speeds. The second equation is energy: the planet has the same total energy at both points. Together they give both speeds, and then M follows.
Follow the five steps. They show why the speed from one law is put into the other law. The picture uses your sliders.
The simulation shows the planet moving on the ellipse. The sideways part of its velocity (green) shrinks when the planet is far and grows when it is near, in just the way that keeps m d v⊥ the same.
The solution in each frame
Frame of the Sun
The Sun is at rest at the focus, and angular momentum is measured about it. The solution is done in this frame.
Frame fixed to the planet
This frame rotates and accelerates, so it adds forces that are not real. It does not help here, so no second frame is used.
The solution step by step
Step 1, the angular momentum. The pull of the Sun passes through the Sun, so its torque about the Sun is zero. At the nearest and farthest points the velocity is at a right angle to the line to the Sun. So
Step 2, the energy. Kinetic plus potential energy is the same at both points:
Step 3, the speed. Put v1 = v2 r2 / r1 into the energy equation and collect the terms with v2:
Step 4, the result.
For your sliders M = kg m²/s, with v2 = km/s and v1 = km/s.
A useful form. The number 2 r1 r2 / (r1 + r2) is the semi-latus rectum p of the ellipse, the distance from the Sun to the orbit measured at a right angle to the long axis. So M = m √(γ Ms p). For a circle p is the radius, and this becomes the circular result m √(γ Ms r).
The page starts the planet at the nearest point with the speed v2 found above and follows its path in small time steps. The farthest distance it reaches is AU, against r1 = AU (difference percent). Along the whole path m d v⊥ stays within percent of M.
Five methods
1. Force method
The pull of the Sun has no torque about the Sun, so the angular momentum is constant. Newton's second law for rotation, torque = rate of change of angular momentum, gives this at once.
2. Energy method
Mechanical energy is constant. This fixes the speeds at the two ends, as in step 2.
3. Graph method
The graph of sideways speed against distance is the curve v⊥ = M/(m d), a hyperbola. The planet moves along it between r2 and r1. The area-per-time of Kepler's second law, ½ d v⊥ = M/(2m), is the same number at every point.
4. Calculus method
The torque is r × F. Here F is along r, so r × F = 0 and dM/dt = 0.
5. Check method
Units: kg × m × m/s = kg m²/s. Limit: for r1 = r2 = r the result is m √(γ Ms r), the circular orbit. Another check: the page follows the orbit step by step and gets the same farthest distance.
Fastest: conservation of angular momentum with energy. Most reliable: the step-by-step orbit.
What each slider changes
| Control | What it changes |
|---|---|
| Smallest distance r2 | M, both speeds, the ellipse, the orbit shape, the three graphs and the dots. |
| Largest distance r1 (header slider) | M, both speeds, the ellipse, the three graphs and the dots. Locked in given-answer mode. |
| Planet mass m | M (proportional to m), the size of the planet, the readings and graph 1. The speeds and the orbit do not depend on m. |
| Mass of the Sun Ms | M (goes as the square root of Ms) and every speed. The shape of the ellipse does not change. |
| Picture speed | Only how fast the planet moves on the screen. |
| Target M (given-answer mode) | Sets M, and the model solves the largest distance r1 for the chosen r2, m and Ms. |
| Zoom | Pixels per astronomical unit in the picture only. |
Parameters
| Quantity | Symbol | Value used |
|---|---|---|
| Planet mass | m | × 1024 kg |
| Mass of the Sun | Ms | × 1030 kg |
| Farthest and nearest distance | r1, r2 | AU, AU |
| Speeds at the two ends | v1, v2 | km/s, km/s |
| Angular momentum | M | kg m²/s |
| Semi-latus rectum | p | AU |
Exam traps
- Using m v r at a point that is not the nearest or farthest point. There v is not at a right angle to r, so you need only the sideways part, v⊥.
- Writing M = m √(γ Ms a) with the semi-major axis a. That is the circle result and it is wrong for an ellipse.
- Forgetting m. Angular momentum is proportional to the planet mass, unlike the speeds.
- Mixing up r1 and r2 in v2. The nearest point has the larger speed, so v2 is larger than v1.
- Using the energy at one point only. Energy and angular momentum must both be used, because there are two unknown speeds.
- Reading M as a mass. In this problem M is the angular momentum.