← Irodov Series·Problem 1.208prayogashaala.com
Irodov, Problem 1.208

Using the conservation laws, demonstrate that the total mechanical energy of a planet of mass m moving around the Sun along an ellipse depends only on its semi-major axis a. Find this energy as a function of a.

Eccentricity e, the flatness of the ellipse, with a fixed (Play scans e from 0 to 0.8, holding 4 s at e = 0.6) e = 0.6
The answer in one line

E = −γ m Ms / (2a). It depends only on the semi-major axis a, not on the flatness of the ellipse. For your sliders E = J.

Problem statement

Problem 1.208. Using the conservation laws, demonstrate that the total mechanical energy of a planet of mass m moving around the Sun along an ellipse depends only on its semi-major axis a. Find this energy as a function of a.

Interpretation. Two planets on different ellipses that have the same long axis 2a must have the same total energy, even if one orbit is nearly a circle and the other is very flat. The question asks us to show this with conservation of angular momentum and of energy, and to write the energy using a, m and the mass of the Sun.

We assume only the pull of the Sun acts on the planet, the Sun does not move, and the energy is zero when the planet is infinitely far away. The problem gives no numbers, so a, e, m and the mass of the Sun Ms are sliders. The starting values are our own choice: a = 1 AU, e = 0.6 (so r2 = 0.4 AU and r1 = 1.6 AU), Ms = 1.97 × 1030 kg and m = 6 × 1024 kg. We use γ = 6.67 × 10-11 N m²/kg².

Symbols: γ is the gravitational constant, E the total mechanical energy (kinetic K plus potential U), e the eccentricity (0 for a circle, near 1 for a very flat ellipse), r1 and r2 the farthest and nearest distances, so r1 + r2 = 2a.

The big idea in plain words

At every point of the orbit the energy is K + U, where K grows when the planet is near the Sun and U becomes more negative there. The sum stays the same all around the orbit. We only need to find it at one convenient place, the nearest point.

At the nearest and farthest points the velocity is sideways, so angular momentum gives a simple link between the two speeds. Combine this with the energy equation and almost everything cancels. What is left depends only on r1 + r2, which is the long axis 2a. That is why the shape does not matter.

Use the header slider to change e while a stays fixed. The ellipse changes shape, the speeds change, the bars for K and U swing up and down, but the total E does not move.

Interactive derivation

The solution in each frame

Frame of the Sun

The Sun is at rest at the focus. Energy and angular momentum are both measured in this frame, and the solution is done here.

Frame fixed to the planet

This frame rotates, and kinetic energy there would be zero while the planet is at rest in it. It does not help, so no second frame is used.

The solution step by step

Step 1, the speeds at the ends. At the farthest point (r1, speed v1) and the nearest point (r2, speed v2) the velocity is sideways. The pull of the Sun has no torque about the Sun, so

m v1 r1 = m v2 r2, so v1 = v2 r2 / r1

Step 2, the energy. The total energy is the same at both ends:

−γ Ms m / r1 + ½ m v1² = −γ Ms m / r2 + ½ m v2²

Step 3, the speed. Put in v1 and solve for v2:

v2² = 2γ Ms r1 / (r2 (r1 + r2))

Step 4, the energy at the nearest point.

E = ½ m v2² − γ Ms m / r2 = γ Ms m r1 / (r2 (r1 + r2)) − γ Ms m / r2 = −γ Ms m / (r1 + r2)

Step 5, the long axis. The nearest and farthest points lie on the long axis, so r1 + r2 = 2a:

E = −γ Ms m / (2a) = J

The eccentricity e has dropped out, so only a matters. The energy is negative, so the planet is bound to the Sun.

The same result from any point. At any distance r, with L the angular momentum, E = ½ m ṙ² + L² / (2 m r²) − γ Ms m / r. At the end points ṙ = 0, so r1 and r2 are the two roots of E r² + γ Ms m r − L² / (2m) = 0. The sum of the roots of a x² + b x + c = 0 is −b/a, so r1 + r2 = −γ Ms m / E = 2a, which is the same result.

Numerical check

The page starts the planet at the nearest point with the speed from step 3 and follows its path in small time steps, adding K + U at every step. The largest difference from E = −γ Ms m / (2a) is percent, and the farthest distance reached is AU against r1 = AU (difference percent).

Five methods

1. Force method

Integrating Newton's second law along the orbit gives the same E, but it is long. Only the conservation laws are needed.

2. Energy method

Energy conservation together with angular momentum conservation, as in steps 1 to 5.

3. Graph method

Plot K, U and E against time. K and U swing in opposite directions and their sum is a flat line at −γ Ms m / (2a). The graph below the picture shows this in units of |E|.

4. Calculus method

The roots of the quadratic E r² + γ Ms m r − L²/(2m) = 0 give r1 + r2 = −γ Ms m / E.

5. Check method

Units: γ Ms m / a is N m²/kg² × kg × kg / m = N m = J. Limit: for a circle (r1 = r2 = a) K = γ Ms m / (2a) and U = −γ Ms m / a, so E = −γ Ms m / (2a), equal to −K.

Fastest: the circle limit, because it already shows that only a matters. Most reliable: the step-by-step sum of K + U.

What each slider changes

ControlWhat it changes
Semi-major axis aE (goes as 1/a), the size of the ellipse and the circle, both end speeds, graph 1 and the dots. Locked in given-answer mode.
Eccentricity e (header slider)The shape of the ellipse, r1, r2, the speeds, K and U at the ends and the energy curves. It does not change E, which is the whole point of the problem.
Planet mass mE (proportional to m), the size of the planet and the energy readings. The orbit and speeds do not depend on m.
Mass of the Sun MsE (proportional to Ms), every speed and the period.
Picture speedOnly how fast the planet moves on the screen.
Target E (given-answer mode)Sets E, and the model solves a = γ Ms m / (2|E|).
ZoomPixels per astronomical unit in the picture only.

Parameters

QuantitySymbolValue used
Planet massm × 1024 kg
Mass of the SunMs × 1030 kg
Semi-major axis, eccentricitya, e AU,
Nearest and farthest distancer2, r1 AU, AU
Speeds at the two endsv2, v1 km/s, km/s
Total energyE J

Exam traps

  • Forgetting the minus sign. E is negative for a bound planet, and E = −K for a circle.
  • Using the distance r instead of the semi-major axis a. For an ellipse r changes all the time, a does not.
  • Using only energy conservation. It has two unknown speeds, so angular momentum conservation is needed too.
  • Thinking a flatter ellipse has a different energy. At the same a every ellipse has the same E.
  • Writing E = −γ Ms m / a. The factor 2 in the denominator comes from r1 + r2 = 2a.
  • Mixing up the energy of the planet with the energy needed to escape. Escape needs E = 0, so the energy to add is γ Ms m / (2a).