← Irodov Series·Problem 1.209prayogashaala.com
Irodov, Problem 1.209

A planet A moves along an elliptical orbit around the Sun. At the moment when it was at a distance r0 from the sun, its velocity was equal to v0 and the angle between the radius vector r0 and the velocity vector v0 was equal to α. Find the maximum and minimum distances that will separate this planet from the Sun during its orbital motion.

Angle α between the radius vector r0 and the velocity v0, in degrees (Play scans α from 10 to 170, holding 4 s at 60) α = 60
The answer in one line

rmax,min = r0 [1 ± √(1 − (2 − η) η sin²α)] / (2 − η), where η = v0² r0 / (γ Ms). For your sliders rmax = AU and rmin = AU.

Problem statement

Problem 1.209. A planet A moves along an elliptical orbit around the Sun. At the moment when it was at a distance r0 from the sun, its velocity was equal to v0 and the angle between the radius vector r0 and the velocity vector v0 was equal to α. Find the maximum and minimum distances that will separate this planet from the Sun during its orbital motion.

Interpretation. We know where the planet is (distance r0 from the Sun), how fast it moves (v0), and in which direction (the angle α between the line from the Sun to the planet and the direction of motion). From these three numbers the whole orbit is fixed. We must find the farthest and the nearest distance on that orbit.

We assume only the pull of the Sun acts on the planet and the Sun does not move. The problem gives no numbers, so r0, v0, α and the mass of the Sun Ms are sliders. The starting values are our own choice: r0 = 1 AU, v0 = 35 km/s, α = 60° and Ms = 1.97 × 1030 kg. We use γ = 6.67 × 10-11 N m²/kg². The problem says the orbit is an ellipse, which needs v0 below the escape speed (η below 2). The page also shows what happens above it.

Symbols: γ is the gravitational constant, Ms the mass of the Sun, η (eta) a number without units that compares the speed with the circular speed: η = v0² r0 / (γ Ms) equals 1 for a circular orbit and 2 for escape speed.

The big idea in plain words

Two things do not change along the orbit: the angular momentum about the Sun and the total energy. At the nearest and the farthest point the velocity is exactly sideways, so there the angular momentum is just (mass) × (speed) × (distance). Write both conservation laws for the start point and for such an extreme point. Eliminate the speed there and one equation for the distance remains. It is a quadratic equation, so it has two roots. One root is the farthest distance and the other is the nearest distance.

Use the header slider to turn the velocity direction. When α is 90° the planet starts at an extreme point, so r0 is one of the two roots. When α is small the planet moves almost straight at the Sun and the nearest distance becomes very small.

Interactive derivation

The solution in each frame

Frame of the Sun

The Sun is at rest at the focus, and angular momentum and energy are measured here. The solution is done in this frame.

Frame fixed to the planet

This frame rotates, so it adds forces that are not real. It does not help, so no second frame is used.

The solution step by step

Step 1, angular momentum. The pull of the Sun has no torque about the Sun. The sideways part of the velocity at the start is v0 sin α. At an extreme distance r the velocity v is entirely sideways. So

m v r = m v0 r0 sin α, so v = v0 r0 sin α / r

Step 2, energy. Total energy is the same at the start and at the extreme point:

½ m v0² − γ Ms m / r0 = ½ m v² − γ Ms m / r

Step 3, one equation for r. Put in v from step 1, multiply by r² and collect the terms:

(v0² − 2γ Ms / r0) r² + 2γ Ms r − v0² r0² sin²α = 0

Step 4, simpler form. Divide by γ Ms / r0 and write x = r / r0 and η = v0² r0 / (γ Ms):

(η − 2) x² + 2x − η sin²α = 0

Step 5, the roots. The solutions of the quadratic equation are

x = [1 ± √(1 − (2 − η) η sin²α)] / (2 − η)

The plus sign gives the farthest distance and the minus sign the nearest distance:

rmax = r0 [1 + √(1 − (2 − η) η sin²α)] / (2 − η) = AU
rmin = r0 [1 − √(1 − (2 − η) η sin²α)] / (2 − η) = AU

What the number under the root means. The root is the eccentricity of the orbit: e = √(1 − (2 − η) η sin²α). The semi-major axis is a = r0 / (2 − η), and rmax,min = a (1 ± e). For your sliders η = , e = and a = .

Checks of the formula. If α = 90° and η = 1, the root is zero and rmax = rmin = r0, a circle. If α = 90° and η is not 1, r0 itself is one of the two extreme distances, because the root equals |1 − η|. If η reaches 2 the planet has escape speed, the orbit is not closed and the farthest distance is infinite. Above that (η above 2) the same minus-sign formula still gives the nearest distance.

Numerical check

The page starts the planet at distance r0 with the given speed and angle and follows its path in small time steps. The smallest distance it reaches is AU against AU from the formula.

Five methods

1. Force method

Solving Newton's second law along the orbit is long. The two conservation laws replace it.

2. Energy method

Energy plus angular momentum, as in steps 1 to 5. This is the method used.

3. Graph method

The graph of the distance r against the angle round the Sun shows the planet going from the nearest to the farthest distance. Its lowest and highest values are rmin and rmax.

4. Calculus method

The distance is extreme when dr/dt = 0, which means the velocity is sideways. This is the step that lets us write the angular momentum as m v r.

5. Check method

Units: η has no units, because v² r / (γ Ms) is (m²/s²) m / (m³/s²). Limits: α = 90° with η = 1 gives a circle, and a very small α gives a very small rmin. The sum of the two roots is rmax + rmin = 2 r0 / (2 − η) = 2a, the long axis.

Fastest: the quadratic equation in step 4. Most reliable: the step-by-step orbit.

What each slider changes

ControlWhat it changes
Distance r0η, rmax, rmin, the start point on the orbit, the circle of radius r0 and all three graphs.
Speed v0η, the orbit shape and size, the velocity arrow, rmax, rmin, the orbit type and graph 3. Locked in given-answer mode.
Angle α (header slider)The direction of the velocity, the orbit shape and tilt, rmax, rmin and graph 1.
Mass of the Sun Msη, the orbit, the circular and escape speeds and all the distances.
Picture speedOnly how fast the planet moves on the screen.
Target rmax (given-answer mode)Sets rmax, and the model solves v0 by bisection for the chosen r0, α and Ms.
ZoomPixels per astronomical unit in the picture only.

Parameters

QuantitySymbolValue used
Distance, speed, angle at the startr0, v0, α AU, km/s, °
Mass of the SunMs × 1030 kg
Number ηη
Eccentricitye
Farthest and nearest distancermax, rmin AU, AU

Exam traps

  • Using m v r instead of m v r sin α for the angular momentum at the start. Only the sideways part of v0 counts.
  • Using energy conservation alone. Angular momentum is needed too, or there are two unknowns.
  • Taking r0 as the nearest or farthest distance. That is true only when α = 90°.
  • Mixing up the two roots. The plus sign gives the larger distance.
  • Forgetting that the formula for rmax needs η below 2. At escape speed or above there is no farthest distance.
  • Measuring α from the wrong line. It is the angle between the radius vector from the Sun to the planet and the velocity, not the angle to the tangent.