← Irodov Series·Problem 1.210prayogashaala.com
Irodov, Problem 1.210

A cosmic body A moves to the Sun with velocity v0 (when far from the Sun) and aiming parameter l the arm of the vector v0 relative to the centre of the Sun (Fig. 1.51). Find the minimum distance by which this body will get to the Sun.

Aiming parameter l, in AU (Play scans l from 0.05 to 6 AU, holding 4 s at 1.5 AU) l = 1.5
The answer in one line

rmin = (γ Ms / v0²) [√(1 + (l v0² / (γ Ms))²) − 1]. For your sliders rmin = AU.

Problem statement

Problem 1.210. A cosmic body A moves to the Sun with velocity v0 (when far from the Sun) and aiming parameter l the arm of the vector v0 relative to the centre of the Sun (Fig. 1.51). Find the minimum distance by which this body will get to the Sun.

Interpretation. A body comes from very far away with speed v0. If gravity were switched off it would move on a straight line that passes the Sun at a perpendicular distance l. That distance l is the aiming parameter. Because of the pull of the Sun the real path bends and the body comes closer than l. The question asks for the closest distance on the real path.

We assume only the pull of the Sun acts on the body and the Sun does not move. The problem gives no numbers, so v0, l and the mass of the Sun Ms are sliders. The starting values are our own choice: v0 = 20 km/s, l = 1.5 AU and Ms = 1.97 × 1030 kg. We use γ = 6.67 × 10-11 N m²/kg².

Symbols: γ is the gravitational constant, Ms the mass of the Sun, v the speed at the closest point, rmin the closest distance. The length a = γ Ms / v0² is a distance made from the given numbers. It tells how strong the pull of the Sun is for this speed.

The big idea in plain words

Far from the Sun the body has kinetic energy ½ m v0² and the potential energy is zero. The pull of the Sun points at the Sun, so the angular momentum about the Sun cannot change. Far away it is m v0 l, because l is the arm of the velocity.

At the closest point the velocity is exactly sideways, so the angular momentum there is m v rmin. Energy and angular momentum together give one equation for rmin. It is a quadratic equation, and only its positive root is a distance.

Use the header slider to change l. For a very small l the body nearly hits the Sun. For a very large l the body hardly bends and rmin is a little smaller than l.

Interactive derivation

The solution in each frame

Frame of the Sun

The Sun is at rest, and the aiming parameter l is measured from its centre. The solution is done in this frame.

Frame fixed to the body

This frame accelerates and rotates, so it adds forces that are not real. It does not help here, so no second frame is used.

The solution step by step

Step 1, angular momentum. Far away the arm of the velocity is l. At the closest point the velocity v is at a right angle to the line to the Sun, so its arm is rmin:

m v0 l = m v rmin, so v = v0 l / rmin

Step 2, energy. Far away the potential energy is zero, so

½ m v0² = −γ Ms m / rmin + ½ m v²

Step 3, one equation. Put v from step 1 into step 2, multiply by 2 rmin² / m and collect the terms:

v0² rmin² + 2γ Ms rmin − v0² l² = 0

Step 4, the root. The positive root of the quadratic equation is

rmin = [−γ Ms + √(γ² Ms² + v0⁴ l²)] / v0² = (γ Ms / v0²) [√(1 + (l v0² / (γ Ms))²) − 1]

For your sliders a = γ Ms / v0² = AU and l / a = , so rmin = AU. The speed at the closest point is v = v0 l / rmin = km/s.

What the number under the root means. The path is a hyperbola with eccentricity e = √(1 + (l/a)²), and rmin = a (e − 1). The body is turned through the angle δ = 2 arcsin(1/e). For your sliders e = and δ = °.

Checks of the formula. For a small l (l much smaller than a) the root is close to 1 + l²/(2a²) and rmin is close to l² / (2a), much smaller than l. For a large l (l much larger than a) the body is hardly bent and rmin is close to l − a. In both cases rmin is smaller than l, because the pull of the Sun bends the path inwards.

Numerical check

The page starts the body far away on the straight line with speed v0 and aiming parameter l and follows its path in small time steps. The smallest distance it reaches is AU against AU from the formula (difference percent).

Five methods

1. Force method

Solving Newton's second law along the path is long. The two conservation laws replace it.

2. Energy method

Energy plus angular momentum, as in steps 1 to 4. This is the method used.

3. Graph method

The graph of rmin against l starts at zero, rises like l² for a small l and approaches the straight line rmin = l − a for a large l. The first graph below the picture shows this.

4. Calculus method

The distance is smallest when dr/dt = 0, which means the velocity is sideways. This is the step that lets us write the angular momentum as m v rmin.

5. Check method

Units: γ Ms / v0² is (m³/s²)/(m²/s²) = m. Limits: l = 0 gives rmin = 0 (a head-on hit), and a very large v0 gives rmin close to l, a straight line.

Fastest: the quadratic equation in step 3. Most reliable: the step-by-step path.

What each slider changes

ControlWhat it changes
Aiming parameter l (header slider)The distance of the straight line from the Sun, the shape of the hyperbola, rmin, the speed at the closest point, the angle δ and the graphs. Locked in given-answer mode.
Speed v0a = γ Ms / v0², the bending of the path, rmin, δ, the speeds and graph 2.
Mass of the Sun Msa, the bending of the path, rmin, δ and the speeds.
Picture speedOnly how fast the body moves on the screen.
Target rmin (given-answer mode)Sets rmin, and the model solves l = √(rmin² + 2 a rmin).
ZoomPixels per astronomical unit in the picture only.

Parameters

QuantitySymbolValue used
Speed far from the Sunv0 km/s
Aiming parameterl AU
Mass of the SunMs × 1030 kg
Length made from the dataa AU
Eccentricity, turning anglee, δ, °
Closest distancermin AU

Exam traps

  • Taking rmin = l. That is true only when gravity is negligible. The pull makes rmin smaller than l.
  • Using only energy conservation. The speed at the closest point is not v0, so angular momentum is needed too.
  • Taking the root with the minus sign. It gives a negative number, which is not a distance.
  • Putting the speed at the closest point equal to v0. It is v0 l / rmin, which is larger.
  • Writing the potential energy far away as −γ Ms m / l. Far away it is zero.
  • Measuring l to the edge of the Sun. It is measured to the centre of the Sun.