A particle of mass m was transferred from the centre of the base of a uniform hemisphere of mass M and radius R into infinity. What work was performed in the process by the gravitational force exerted on the particle by the hemisphere?
The work done by the gravity of the hemisphere is A = −3γmM / (2R). For your sliders that is J. It is negative because gravity pulls the particle back while it leaves. The outside agent that moves it slowly does + J.
Problem statement
Problem 1.212. A particle of mass m was transferred from the centre of the base of a uniform hemisphere of mass M and radius R into infinity. What work was performed in the process by the gravitational force exerted on the particle by the hemisphere?
Interpretation. A solid half ball of equal density has a flat face (the base). The particle starts at the middle of that flat face, which is point O. It is taken out to a place so far away that the pull is gone. The question asks for the work done by the pull of the hemisphere during this trip, not the work done by whoever moves the particle.
We assume the potential is zero at infinity. We assume the particle leaves along the axis, on the curved side, through a thin channel. Gravity is a conservative force, so any other path gives the same work. The problem gives no numbers, so M, R and m are sliders. The starting values are our own choice: M = 6 × 1024 kg, R = 6.4 Mm, m = 1 kg. We use γ = 6.67 × 10-11 N m²/kg².
Symbols: M and R are the mass and radius of the hemisphere, m the mass of the particle, s the radius of a thin layer inside the hemisphere, dr its thickness, x the distance of the particle from O along the axis, φ the gravitational potential, γ the gravitational constant.
The big idea in plain words
Gravity is a conservative force, so the work it does depends only on the start and the end. The work equals m times the potential at the start (the potential at infinity is zero). So the whole job is to find the potential at O.
The potential of many masses is just the sum of the potentials of the small pieces. The trick is to cut the hemisphere into thin half-shell layers around O. Every point of one layer is the same distance s from O. So every piece of that layer adds the same amount to the potential per kilogram, and the layer can be handled in one step.
The solution in each frame
Frame of the hemisphere
The hemisphere is at rest and the particle moves out of it. All the work is found in this frame.
Other frames
A moving or rotating frame adds forces that are not real. They are not needed here, so no second frame is used.
The solution step by step
Step 1, the density. The volume of a hemisphere is (2/3) π R³, so the density is
Step 2, the mass of a thin layer. A half-shell of radius s and thickness dr has area 2π s² and volume 2π s² dr. Its mass is
Step 3, the potential of one layer at O. Every point of the layer is at the same distance s from O. So the potential of the whole layer at O is just that of its mass dm at distance s:
Step 4, add all the layers. The value of dφ per unit dr is −3γM s / R³. It grows in a straight line with s, from 0 at s = 0 to −3γM / R² at s = R. The total is the area under that line, which is a triangle with base R and height 3γM / R²:
(The same sum written as an integral is −(3γM / R³) ∫ s ds from 0 to R, which gives the same result.)
Step 5, the work. The work of gravity is the fall in potential energy: A = m (φ at the start − φ at infinity) = m φO:
The sign is negative because gravity pulls the particle back toward the hemisphere. The outside agent doing the job slowly does the opposite work, +3γ m M / (2R) = J.
Two separate sums were made. First, the hemisphere was cut into 80000 small volume pieces and the potential at O was added up: φO = J/kg, against −3γM/(2R) = J/kg (difference percent). Second, the pull on the particle along the axis was calculated at each distance x, and the area under that pull from x = 0 out to 500 R was added, with a small tail for the rest. That area gives A = J, against J from the formula (difference percent).
The same answer from a whole ball
Put two such hemispheres together and they make a whole ball of mass 2M, with O at its centre. By the same layer argument its centre potential is −3γ(2M) / (2R) = −3γM / R. The two halves are mirror images, so each gives half of this: −3γM / (2R). This agrees with the result above, and it shows why the number is the same as half of the potential at the centre of a whole ball.
Other methods
Energy. The work of gravity equals minus the change in potential energy. To reach infinity with no speed left, the particle needs a starting kinetic energy equal to the size of the work: (1/2) m v² = 3γ m M / (2R). So the speed at O must be v = √(3γM / R) = m/s. This is the escape speed from O.
Graph. The third graph shows the pull on the particle along the axis. The work is the area between that curve and the x axis. The pull at O is 3γMm / (2R²), pointing back toward the hemisphere, and it falls toward 1/x² far away. The area is the same −3γmM / (2R).
Direct force integration. The pull on the particle at each distance x comes from a long formula (square roots of R² + x²), and the integral of that pull is hard to write by hand. The layer method avoids all of that. The layers method is the fastest, and the two numerical sums in the check are the most reliable.
What each slider changes
| Control | What it changes |
|---|---|
| Distance x of the particle (header slider too) | Where the particle is, the pull on it, the work done so far and its share of the total, the dots on the graphs and the pull arrow. The total work A does not change. |
| Radius s of the highlighted layer | The layer drawn, its mass and its share of the potential, and the dot on the first graph. The total A does not change, because the total is the sum of all layers. |
| Mass M of the hemisphere | The density, the layer masses, the potential, the work, the escape speed and the pull. The graphs are in units of γM/R, so their shapes do not change. |
| Radius R | The potential, the work, the escape speed and the pull. The drawing keeps a fixed size, so only the labels change. The graphs use R as their unit. |
| Mass m of the particle | The work, and the pull. The potential and the speed do not depend on m. |
Parameters
| Quantity | Symbol | Value used |
|---|---|---|
| Mass of the hemisphere | M | × 1024 kg |
| Radius of the hemisphere | R | Mm |
| Mass of the particle | m | kg |
| Density | ρ | kg/m³ |
| Potential at O | φO | J/kg |
| Work of gravity | A | J |
Exam traps
- Giving the work as positive. Gravity pulls the particle back, so the work of gravity is negative. The positive 3γmM/(2R) is the work of the outside agent.
- Using −γMm/R, as if all the mass sat at one point at distance R. The layers are at every distance from 0 to R, and the average is much closer to O.
- Using the full-ball formula −3γM/(2R) with M as the mass of the whole ball. Here M is the mass of the hemisphere, and the result happens to look the same only because O is the centre of the flat face.
- Thinking each half-shell layer pulls O in one direction only. The potential is a plain number, so pieces add with no directions, which is why the layers are easy.
- Forgetting that every point of a half-shell layer is at the same distance s from O. This only works because O is the centre of the base.
- Thinking the work depends on the path. Gravity is conservative, so only the start and the end matter.