← Irodov Series·Problem 1.213prayogashaala.com
Irodov, Problem 1.213

Inside a uniform sphere of density ρ there is a spherical cavity whose centre is at a distance l from the centre of the sphere. Find the strength G of the gravitational field inside the cavity.

Distance l between the centre of the sphere and the centre of the cavity, as a fraction of R (Play moves the cavity from the centre outward, holding 4 s at l = 0.5 R) l = 0.5 R
3D steps:
The answer in one line

The field inside the cavity is the same at every point: G = (4/3) π γ ρ l, pointing from the centre of the cavity toward the centre of the sphere. For your sliders G = m/s². It does not depend on the radius of the cavity or on where P is inside it.

Problem statement

Problem 1.213. Inside a uniform sphere of density ρ there is a spherical cavity whose centre is at a distance l from the centre of the sphere. Find the strength G of the gravitational field inside the cavity.

Interpretation. A big ball of equal density has a round hollow space inside it. The hollow is not at the centre: its centre C is a distance l from the centre O of the ball. The question asks for the gravitational field (the pull per kilogram) at any point P inside the hollow.

We assume the cavity lies fully inside the sphere (l plus the cavity radius a is less than R), and that nothing else pulls on P. The problem gives no numbers, so the density ρ, the radius R of the sphere, the radius a of the cavity and l are sliders. The starting values are our own choice: ρ = 5500 kg/m³, R = 6.4 Mm, a = 0.25 R, l = 0.5 R. We use γ = 6.67 × 10-11 N m²/kg².

Symbols: R is the radius of the sphere, a the radius of the cavity, l the vector from O to C, r+ the vector from O to P, r− the vector from C to P, ρ the density, γ the gravitational constant, G the field strength.

The big idea in plain words

A solid ball is easy: the field inside it is simple. A ball with a hole is hard. The trick is to ask what the ball would be if the hole were filled. A filled ball is the real ball plus the missing lump. So the real field is the field of the full ball minus the field of the missing lump.

Subtracting a lump of matter is the same as adding a lump of the same size with negative density, −ρ. The two fields are both simple, and they are straight arrows. Their sum turns out to be one arrow that is the same everywhere in the hole.

The 3D view shows this in four steps (they play by themselves, or use the step buttons): the cavity alone, the sphere without the cavity, the real sphere with the cavity, and the final value. A quarter of the solid sphere is cut away so that the hollow can be seen.

Interactive derivation

The solution in each frame

Frame of the sphere

The sphere is at rest. The field is found in this frame.

Other frames

A moving or rotating frame adds forces that are not real, and they are not needed here. No second frame is used.

The solution step by step

Step 1, the field inside a full uniform sphere. At a distance r from the centre only the matter inside radius r pulls (the outer layers give zero, as in the spherical layer result). The mass inside is (4/3) π r³ ρ. So the pull per kilogram is

G = γ (4/3) π r³ ρ / r² = (4/3) π γ ρ r, pointing toward the centre.

As a vector from the centre, G1 = −(4/3) π γ ρ r+ at P. For your sliders, |G1| = m/s².

Step 2, fill the cavity. Put matter of density ρ in the cavity so the sphere is full. Then add matter of density −ρ in the same place, so the real cavity is empty again. The added negative lump is a sphere of density −ρ centred at C. The same formula applies with the distance measured from C: G2 = −(4/3) π γ (−ρ) r− = +(4/3) π γ ρ r−. It points away from C, and |G2| = m/s².

Step 3, add the two fields.

G = G1 + G2 = −(4/3) π γ ρ (r+ − r−)

Step 4, the vectors give l. From the figure, O to P is O to C plus C to P: r+ = l + r−. So r+ − r− = l, the same for every point P:

G = −(4/3) π γ ρ l , magnitude (4/3) π γ ρ l = m/s²

The field is the same at every point of the cavity, in size and in direction. It points from the cavity toward the centre of the sphere, along the line from C to O. It is the fraction l / R = of the field g = (4/3) π γ ρ R = m/s² at the surface of the full sphere.

Numerical check

A separate calculation does not use the cavity trick. From P, the page looks in 45000 directions. In each direction the matter starts where the ray leaves the cavity and ends where it leaves the sphere, and a thin cone of that length pulls with γ ρ times its length (the cone method: the pull of a cone is γ ρ dΩ times its length). Adding all directions gives Gx = m/s² and Gy = m/s², against − m/s² and 0 from the formula (difference percent of g).

Second method: the potential

Inside a uniform sphere the potential is φ = (2/3) π γ ρ r² + a constant, because its slope must give −(4/3) π γ ρ r. The negative lump has the opposite sign: φ = −(2/3) π γ ρ r−² + another constant. The total is (2/3) π γ ρ (r+² − r−²) + a constant. With r+ = l + r−, r+² − r−² = l² + 2 l · r−. That is a straight-line function of position, so its slope is a constant: G = −(4/3) π γ ρ l again.

Which other methods apply?

Adding up the pull of every piece of the matter with a volume integral is possible, but the geometry of a sphere with a hole makes it very long. The check above does it numerically in 45000 directions. The superposition method is the fastest and shows why G is uniform. The numerical check is the most reliable. Energy methods do not find a field directly, and the graphs only confirm it, as the second graph does with its flat piece.

What each slider changes

ControlWhat it changes
Distance l between the centres (header slider too)Where the cavity is, the field G, the length of l, the arrows in the picture and the dots on graphs 1 and 2.
Cavity radius aThe size of the cavity, the pieces of the picture and the dots on graph 3. The field G does not change, and this is a result of the problem.
Position of P (distance and direction)Where P is, the lengths r+ and r−, and the two component arrows G1 and G2. The sum G does not change.
Density ρThe field G, G1, G2 and the surface field of the full sphere. The graph shapes stay, because they are in units of (4/3) π γ ρ R.
Radius R of the sphereThe distances in metres, the field G and the arrows. The drawing keeps a fixed size, so only the labels change.

Parameters

QuantitySymbolValue used
Densityρ kg/m³
Radius of the sphereR Mm
Radius of the cavitya Mm
Distance between the centresl Mm
Field in the cavityG m/s²
Field at the surface of the full sphereg m/s²

Exam traps

  • Saying the field is zero inside the cavity, as in a spherical layer. That only holds when the cavity is at the centre (l = 0). Here the field is not zero.
  • Thinking the field depends on the size of the cavity. It does not. Only the density and l matter.
  • Thinking the field changes from point to point inside the cavity. It is uniform: same size, same direction everywhere in the hollow.
  • Getting the direction wrong. G points from the cavity toward the centre of the sphere, along −l, not away from it.
  • Forgetting the minus sign of the cavity. The missing matter must be subtracted, so its field is added with the sign reversed.
  • Using the mass of the whole sphere. The answer needs only ρ and l, and no mass appears in it.