← Irodov Series·Problem 1.214prayogashaala.com
Irodov, Problem 1.214

A uniform sphere has a mass M and radius R. Find the pressure p inside the sphere, caused by gravitational compression, as a function of the distance r from its centre. Evaluate p at the centre of the Earth, assuming it to be a uniform sphere.

Distance r of the point Q from the centre, as a fraction of R (Play moves Q from the surface down to the centre, holding 4 s at r = 0, the centre of the Earth) r = 0 R
3D steps:
The answer in one line

The pressure at distance r from the centre is p = (2π/3) γ ρ² (R² − r²) = (3/8π) (γ M² / R⁴) (1 − r²/R²). For your sliders, at r = R it is Pa. At the centre, p = 3γM² / (8π R⁴) = Pa, which is atmospheres.

Problem statement

Problem 1.214. A uniform sphere has a mass M and radius R. Find the pressure p inside the sphere, caused by gravitational compression, as a function of the distance r from its centre. Evaluate p at the centre of the Earth, assuming it to be a uniform sphere.

Interpretation. A ball of equal density squeezes itself with its own gravity. The deeper you go, the more matter lies above you and presses down, so the pressure grows toward the centre. The question asks for the pressure at every depth, and then for the value at the centre if the Earth were such a ball.

We assume the density ρ is the same everywhere, the material is a fluid that passes pressure equally in all directions, and the pressure at the surface is zero. The problem gives numbers only for the Earth, so M and R are sliders. The starting values are the Earth's: M = 5.97 × 1024 kg and R = 6.37 Mm, which give ρ close to 5500 kg/m³. We use γ = 6.67 × 10-11 N m²/kg² and 1 atmosphere = 101325 Pa.

Symbols: M and R are the mass and radius of the sphere, ρ = 3M / (4π R³) its density, r the distance from the centre, s the radius of one thin layer, dr its thickness, g(r) the gravitational field at radius r, p the pressure, γ the gravitational constant.

The big idea in plain words

Think of one thin spherical layer inside the ball. The layer is pulled toward the centre by all the matter inside it. The matter outside the layer gives no net pull on it (the spherical layer result of problem 1.211). A pull spread over the area of the layer is a pressure. So each layer adds a small step of pressure, and the pressure at a point is the sum of the steps from all the layers above it.

That sum is the weight of a column of matter above the point, divided by the area of the column. The only catch is that the weight of a slice is not the same everywhere: the field g gets weaker toward the centre, and it grows in a straight line with r. That straight line makes the sum easy: it is the area of a trapezoid.

The 3D view shows this in four steps (they play by themselves, or use the step buttons): the pull on one layer, the pressure step it gives, the layers added from the point up to the surface, and the final pressure map. A quarter of the solid sphere is cut away so that the layers can be seen.

Interactive derivation

The solution in each frame

Frame of the sphere

The sphere is at rest and the matter inside it is in balance (hydrostatic equilibrium). The pressure is found in this frame.

Other frames

A moving or rotating frame adds forces that are not real, and they are not needed here. No second frame is used.

The solution step by step

Step 1, the density. ρ = M / ((4/3) π R³) = kg/m³.

Step 2, the pull on one layer. Take a thin layer of radius s and thickness dr. Its area is 4π s², and its mass is dm = ρ 4π s² dr. Only the matter inside radius s pulls it, with mass m(s) = ρ (4/3) π s³. So the force on the layer is

dF = γ m(s) dm / s² = γ ρ (4/3) π s³ · ρ 4π s² dr / s² = (16π²/3) γ ρ² s³ dr

Step 3, the pressure step. The pressure is force per area, so the layer adds

dp = dF / (4π s²) = (4/3) π γ ρ² s dr

This is the same as dp = ρ g(s) dr, the weight of a slab of thickness dr per unit area, with g(s) = (4/3) π γ ρ s.

Step 4, add the layers from r to R. The size of dp per unit dr is a straight line in s, from (4/3) π γ ρ² r at the point to (4/3) π γ ρ² R at the surface. The sum is the area of a trapezoid with width R − r and the two side lengths above:

p(r) = (R − r) · [(4/3) π γ ρ² r + (4/3) π γ ρ² R] / 2 = (2π/3) γ ρ² (R² − r²)

The pressure is zero at r = R, as it must be at the surface.

Step 5, put in the mass. With ρ = 3M / (4π R³), ρ² = 9M² / (16 π² R⁶), so

p(r) = (3/8π) (γ M² / R⁴) (1 − r² / R²)

At your r this is Pa.

Step 6, the centre of the Earth. Put r = 0: pc = 3γM² / (8π R⁴) = (2π/3) γ ρ² R². With M = 5.97 × 1024 kg and R = 6.37 Mm, pc = Pa, which is atmospheres.

Numerical check

A separate calculation does not use the closed formula. The page cuts the sphere into 4000 thin layers, adds up their masses to get the mass inside each radius, finds g at each radius from that mass, and then adds ρ g dr from the surface inward. This gives p at r = R of Pa (formula Pa, difference percent) and p at the centre of Pa (formula Pa, difference percent).

Other methods

Energy. The work done by gravity when a thin layer is moved is not the pressure, so energy does not give p directly. The pressure is a force question, and the force method above is the one that works.

Constant g (fast estimate). If you wrongly use the surface value gR = m/s² everywhere, you get p = ρ gR (R − r), which is Pa at your r, about times the right value. At the centre the estimate is exactly twice too big, because g falls to zero there and the average g is half of gR. The second graph shows both curves.

Graph. The first graph shows g against s as a straight line. The pressure is ρ times the shaded area under it from r to R, a trapezoid. Calculus gives the same area: p = ρ ∫ g ds from r to R.

Direct force on a layer. The pull on a layer grows as s³ and its area as s², so the pressure step grows as s. Third graph.

The layer method is the fastest and shows why the answer has the form R² − r². The step-by-step numerical sum is the most reliable.

What each slider changes

ControlWhat it changes
Distance r of the point Q (header slider too)Where Q is, the field g at Q, the pressure p at Q, the column of layers above it, the picture and the dots on graphs 1 and 2.
Radius s of the layer inspectedThe layer drawn, the mass inside it, the pull on it, its pressure step dp and the dots on graph 3. The pressure p at Q does not change, because p comes from all the layers together.
Mass MThe density, the fields, and every pressure, in proportion to M². The graph shapes stay, because they are in units of their own largest values.
Radius RThe density, the fields and every pressure, in proportion to 1/R⁴. The drawing keeps a fixed size, so only the labels change.

Parameters

QuantitySymbolValue used
Mass of the sphereM × 1024 kg
Radius of the sphereR Mm
Densityρ kg/m³
Field at the surfacegR m/s²
Pressure at Qp Pa
Pressure at the centrepc Pa

Exam traps

  • Using the surface value of g everywhere. That gives twice the right pressure at the centre. Inside the sphere g falls in a straight line to zero at the centre.
  • Thinking the pressure is greatest at the surface. It is zero there and greatest at the centre.
  • Using the whole mass M for the pull on a deep layer. Only the matter inside the layer pulls it, with mass M s³/R³.
  • Forgetting that the pressure must be zero at r = R. The constant of the sum is fixed by that.
  • Using this value for the real Earth. The real Earth is denser near the centre, so its central pressure is higher, about twice this model value. The problem asks for a uniform sphere, so the answer here is the model one.
  • Mixing units. 1 atm = 101325 Pa, so a pressure of 1011 Pa is about a million atmospheres.