Find the proper potential energy of gravitational interaction of matter forming (a) a thin uniform spherical layer of mass m and radius R; (b) a uniform sphere of mass m and radius R.
(a) A thin uniform spherical layer: U = −γm²/(2R) = J. (b) A uniform sphere: U = −3γm²/(5R) = J. For your sliders, m = × 1024 kg and R = Mm, and the sphere holds times the energy of the layer.
Problem statement
Problem 1.215. Find the proper potential energy of gravitational interaction of matter forming
(a) a thin uniform spherical layer of mass m and radius R;
(b) a uniform sphere of mass m and radius R.
Interpretation. The proper energy of a body is the energy of all the pulls between its own pieces. It equals the work gravity does when the pieces, spread far apart and at rest, are brought together to make the body. It is negative, because gravity does positive work as the pieces fall together. The question asks for this number for a thin hollow layer and for a solid ball of the same mass and radius.
We assume the layer is so thin that its thickness can be ignored, the density is the same everywhere in each body, and the energy is zero when the pieces are infinitely far apart. The problem gives no numbers, so m and R are sliders. The starting values are the Earth's: m = 5.97 × 1024 kg and R = 6.37 Mm. We use γ = 6.67 × 10-11 N m²/kg².
Symbols: m and R are the mass and radius of the body, γ the gravitational constant, U the proper energy, x the fraction of the mass already assembled, φ the potential (energy per kilogram) at the surface of the body built so far, s the radius of the ball built so far in part (b).
The big idea in plain words
Build the body piece by piece. Bring each small piece from very far away and place it on the body. Gravity does work on the piece, and that work is the energy released. Add the work of all the pieces and you have the proper energy.
The only thing to know at each step is the potential at the surface of the body built so far. For a thin layer, every point of it has the same potential. For a ball, the matter already built acts like a point mass at the centre for the new layer on its surface.
The 3D view tells this in four steps (they play by themselves, or use the step buttons): the potential, one piece added, all the pieces added, and the result. The tabs switch between the layer (a) and the sphere (b). Play of the header slider builds the body from x = 0 up to the finished body at x = 1.
The solution in each frame
Frame of the body
The body is at rest and its pieces are held in place. The energy is found in this frame.
Other frames
A moving frame only adds kinetic energy of the whole body, which is not part of the proper energy. No second frame is used.
The solution step by step
(a) The thin uniform layer
Step 1, potential at a point of the layer. Stand on the layer at point P. Cut the layer into rings around the line from the centre through P. A ring at angle θ from P holds mass dm = m sin θ dθ / 2, and its distance from P is d = 2R sin(θ/2). Its potential at P is
Adding the rings from θ = 0 to π gives φ = −γ m / R. Every point of the layer has the same potential, as if all the mass sat at the centre.
Step 2, the energy. Each piece dm sits at the potential φ, so adding φ dm over all pieces gives φ m. That counts every pair of pieces twice (once from each piece), so the energy is half of it:
With your m and R this is J.
Step 3, the same by building up. When the mass already on the layer is μ, the potential at its surface is −γ μ / R. Bringing a piece dμ from far away releases γ μ dμ / R. The potential grows in a straight line with μ, so its average is half its final value, and U = −(1/2)(γ m / R) m. The same result, with no calculus.
(b) The uniform sphere
Step 4, build it in layers. Suppose a ball of radius s is built, with mass m s³ / R³. Add a layer of thickness ds. Its mass is dm = (3m / R³) s² ds. The built ball pulls the new layer as if all its mass sat at the centre (problem 1.211 and 1.212: a spherical layer acts as a point mass outside it), so the potential at radius s is −γ (m s³ / R³) / s. The work released is
Step 5, add the layers. The sum of s⁴ ds from 0 to R is R⁵ / 5, so
With your m and R this is J. The potential inside is not constant, so here a sum over layers (a power integral) is needed, and algebra alone does not finish it.
Step 6, compare. The sphere is 3/5 divided by 1/2, which is times the layer. It is lower because the sphere has its mass nearer the centre, where the potential is deeper.
Two separate calculations do not use the closed formulas. For the layer, the page adds up the potential at one point from 20000 thin rings, then takes half of that times m. It gives U = J (formula J, difference percent). For the sphere, it cuts the ball into 4000 thin layers, finds the potential at each layer by adding the matter inside and outside, and takes half of the sum of potential times mass. It gives U = J (formula J, difference percent).
Other methods
Half of the potential energy sum. The energy is U = (1/2) ∫ φ dm, with φ the potential at each piece. For the layer φ is constant, which gives −γm²/(2R) straight away. For the sphere, φ = −(3γm / 2R) (1 − r²/3R²) inside, and the mass-weighted average of φ is −6γm / (5R), so U = (1/2)(−6γm²/(5R)). The third graph shows φ and these averages.
Graph. In the first graph, the energy released while the mass grows from 0 to x m is the area under the potential curve of the second graph. For the layer the curve is a straight line, a triangle of area 1/2. For the sphere it is the curve x2/3, with area 3/5.
The ½ ∫ φ dm method is the fastest. The layer-by-layer build-up shows where the energy comes from and is the most reliable check.
What each slider changes
| Control | What it changes |
|---|---|
| Mass assembled x (header slider too) | How much of the body is in place, the energy released so far, the picture, and the dots on graphs 1 and 2. At x = 1 the energy is the answer of the problem. |
| Mass m | Every energy, in proportion to m². The graph shapes stay, because they are in units of γm²/R. |
| Radius R | Every energy, in proportion to 1/R. The drawing keeps a fixed size, so only the labels change. |
| Tabs (a) and (b) | Which body is shown: the thin layer or the solid sphere. The answer line shows both. |
Parameters
| Quantity | Symbol | Value used |
|---|---|---|
| Mass | m | × 1024 kg |
| Radius | R | Mm |
| Unit of energy | γm²/R | J |
| Energy of the layer | U(a) | J |
| Energy of the sphere | U(b) | J |
Exam traps
- Leaving out the factor 1/2 and writing U = φ m. That counts every pair twice.
- Using the potential of a point mass, −γm²/R, for the whole body. The pieces are spread out, so the energy is smaller in size.
- Forgetting the sign. The proper energy is negative, and its size is the work needed to pull the body apart to infinity.
- Using the potential at the centre of the sphere, −3γm/(2R), as if it applied to every piece.
- Mixing up the sphere with the layer: 3/5 for the solid sphere, 1/2 for the thin layer.
- Counting the work of keeping the body round or holding it up. Only the pull between the pieces counts.