← Irodov Series·Problem 1.216prayogashaala.com
Irodov, Problem 1.216

Two Earth's satellites move in a common plane along circular orbits. The orbital radius of one satellite r = 7000 km while that of the other satellite is t = 0.5 τ less. What time interval separates the periodic approaches of the satellites to each other over the minimum distance?

Time t since a closest approach, in units of τ, the time between approaches (Play runs the satellites and holds 4 s at t = τ, the next closest approach) t = 0.5 τ
3D steps:
The answer in one line

The time between closest approaches is τ = 2π / (ω₀ ∓ ω), with ω = √(γM/r³) for the outer satellite and ω₀ = √(γM/(r − Δr)³) for the inner one. Moving in the same direction (minus sign): τ = (4.44 days exactly; the short form for a small gap gives 4.50 days, about 4.5 days). Moving in opposite directions (plus sign): τ = (about 0.80 hour). Your sliders: r = km and Δr = km.

Problem statement

Problem 1.216. Two Earth's satellites move in a common plane along circular orbits. The orbital radius of one satellite r = 7000 km while that of the other satellite is Δr = 70 km less. What time interval separates the periodic approaches of the satellites to each other over the minimum distance?

Interpretation. Both satellites circle the Earth in the same plane, the inner one a little faster. Now and then they pass on the same radial line, and the distance between them is then the smallest possible, which is Δr. The question asks how long it is from one such closest approach to the next. The problem does not say whether the two move in the same sense or in opposite senses, so both cases are worked out, in tabs (a) and (b).

We assume that the Earth's gravity is the only force, that the orbits are exact circles around the Earth's centre, and that the satellites do not disturb each other. We use γM = 3.98 × 1014 m³/s², where M is the mass of the Earth, and an Earth radius of 6371 km. The problem gives r and Δr, so they are sliders with the problem's values as the starting point.

Symbols: r is the radius of the outer orbit, Δr the gap, r − Δr the radius of the inner orbit, ω and ω₀ the angular speeds of the outer and inner satellite, T and T₀ their periods, τ the time between closest approaches.

The big idea in plain words

Think of two runners on circular tracks. They are closest when they stand on the same radial line. Look at the angle between them. In the same-direction case this angle grows at the difference of the two angular speeds. In the opposite-direction case it grows at their sum. The angle returns to zero (closest approach) each time it has grown by one full turn, 2π. So the time between approaches is 2π divided by that relative angular speed.

The picture runs fast in time. In (a) the two satellites go the same way, and the speed difference between them is exaggerated (the page prints by how many times) so that the inner one visibly overtakes the outer one. In (b) they go opposite ways and the speeds have their true ratio. The header slider is the time since a closest approach, in units of τ. It shows the gap between the orbits larger than it is, because 70 km out of 7000 km would be invisible. The four steps (they play by themselves, or use the step buttons) show the angular speeds, the relative angle, the closest approach, and the result.

Interactive derivation

The solution in each frame

Frame of the Earth

The centre of the Earth is at rest, and each satellite moves on a circle with its own constant angular speed. The solution is done in this frame.

Frame of the outer satellite

In a frame turning with the outer satellite, the outer one stands still and the inner one circles it at the relative angular speed. This is the same picture as the relative angle in the steps, and it gives the same τ. No other frame is needed.

The solution step by step

Step 1, the angular speeds. For a circular orbit, gravity gives the centripetal force: γ M m / r² = m ω² r, so

ω = √(γM / r³) and ω₀ = √(γM / (r − Δr)³)

With your numbers, ω = rad/s (period T = ) and ω₀ = rad/s (period T₀ = ). The inner satellite is faster.

Step 2, the relative angle. Measure the angle between the two radial lines. If both go round in the same sense, it changes at ω₀ − ω. If they go round in opposite senses, it changes at ω₀ + ω.

Step 3, the time between approaches. The satellites are closest each time this angle has grown by 2π, so

τ = 2π / (ω₀ ∓ ω) (minus: same sense, plus: opposite senses)

Step 4, same direction (a). ω₀ − ω = rad/s, so τ = .

Step 5, opposite directions (b). ω₀ + ω = rad/s, so τ = .

Step 6, the short form for a small gap. When Δr is much smaller than r, (r − Δr)−3/2 ≈ r−3/2 (1 + 3Δr/(2r)). Then ω₀ = ω (1 + 3Δr/(2r)), and

τ = (2π/ω) / (3Δr/(2r) + δ), δ = 0 for the same sense and δ = 2 for opposite senses

With your numbers this gives for (a) and for (b). With the numbers of the problem the short form gives 4.50 days and 0.804 hour, close to the exact 4.44 days and 0.804 hour.

Numerical check

A separate calculation does not use the formula for τ. It moves the two satellites round their circles, computes the distance between them from their positions, finds two successive times of smallest distance by a search, and takes the difference. It gives τ = for the same sense (formula , difference percent) and τ = for opposite senses (formula , difference percent).

Other methods

Periods. In the same-sense case the inner satellite gains one lap on the outer one in τ, so τ / T₀ − τ / T = 1. This gives 1/τ = 1/T₀ − 1/T, the same result. For opposite senses the two meet 1/T + 1/T₀ times per unit time, so 1/τ = 1/T + 1/T₀.

Energy. Energy does not fit this question, because it tells the speeds but not when the satellites meet. The angular speeds from the force method are what is needed.

Graph. The first graph shows the distance between the satellites against time. It dips to Δr at every closest approach. The second shows the relative angle growing in a straight line and dropping back each time it passes a full turn. The third shows how τ depends on Δr.

The relative angle method is the fastest. The search for the minimum of the distance is the most reliable check.

What each slider changes

ControlWhat it changes
Time t (header slider)The positions of both satellites, the clock, the closest-approach flag and the dots on graphs 1 and 2. At t = τ the satellites are at their next closest approach.
Gap ΔrThe inner radius, ω₀, the relative angular speed, τ, the drawing, the curves and the dot on graph 3.
Outer radius rBoth angular speeds, τ, the picture, and graph 3.
Screen seconds for one intervalOnly how fast Play runs. The answer does not change, because it comes from the physics, not the playback speed.
Tabs (a) and (b)Same direction or opposite directions of the inner satellite, which sets the relative angular speed and τ.

Parameters

QuantitySymbolValue used
Radius of the outer orbitr km
Gap between the orbitsΔr km
Radius of the inner orbitr − Δr km
Angular speedsω, ω₀ and rad/s
Time between approachesτ (same, opposite),

Exam traps

  • Adding the angular speeds when both go the same way, or subtracting them when they go opposite ways. Same sense: difference. Opposite sense: sum.
  • Using the period of one satellite as the answer. The answer is the time for the relative angle to grow by a full turn.
  • Forgetting that the two periods are different. The inner satellite has the shorter period, since T is proportional to r3/2.
  • Using the radius of the inner orbit as 7000 km. The inner radius is 7000 − 70 = 6930 km.
  • Mixing units. Angular speeds in rad/s with times in seconds, then convert to days or hours at the end.
  • Using the short form when Δr is not small. It is an approximation that assumes Δr is much smaller than r. The third graph shows where it parts from the exact curve.