← Irodov Series·Problem 1.217prayogashaala.com
Irodov, Problem 1.217

Calculate the ratios of the following accelerations: the acceleration w₁ due to the gravitational force on the Earth's surface, the acceleration w₂ due to the centrifugal force of inertia on the Earth's equator, and the acceleration w₃ caused by the Sun to the bodies on the Earth.

Latitude λ of the body on the Earth, in degrees (the problem is at the equator, λ = 0; Play moves the body from the pole down to the equator and holds 4 s there) λ = 0°
3D steps:
The answer in one line

The three accelerations are w₁ = γM/R² (gravity at the surface), w₂ = ω²R (centrifugal, at the equator) and w₃ = γMS/d² (the pull of the Sun). Their ratio is w₁ : w₂ : w₃ = 1 : : , which is about 1 : 0.0034 : 0.0006. In numbers: w₁ = m/s², w₂ = m/s², w₃ = m/s².

Problem statement

Problem 1.217. Calculate the ratios of the following accelerations: the acceleration w₁ due to the gravitational force on the Earth's surface, the acceleration w₂ due to the centrifugal force of inertia on the Earth's equator, and the acceleration w₃ caused by the Sun to the bodies on the Earth.

Interpretation. Three different things can make a body on the Earth accelerate. The Earth's own gravity pulls it toward the centre. Because the Earth turns, a body at the equator also feels an outward centrifugal push in the turning frame of the Earth. The Sun also pulls the body toward itself. The question asks how large each of these accelerations is compared with gravity, so it asks for the three numbers in the ratio w₁ : w₂ : w₃.

We assume the Earth is a sphere of mass M = 5.97 × 1024 kg and radius R = 6371 km, the Sun has mass MS = 1.99 × 1030 kg and is d = 1.496 × 1011 m (1 AU) away, and the Earth turns once in 86164 s (a sidereal day). We use γ = 6.67 × 10-11 N m²/kg². The Earth's rotation period and the distance to the Sun are sliders, with these values as the starting point. The problem is at the equator, so the latitude slider starts at 0.

Symbols: γ is the gravitational constant, M and R the mass and radius of the Earth, ω = 2π/T its angular speed of rotation, T its rotation period, λ the latitude of the body, MS the mass of the Sun, d the distance from the Earth to the Sun.

The big idea in plain words

Each acceleration comes from a different cause, and each has a simple formula. Gravity comes from the mass of the Earth, centrifugal acceleration comes from the turning, and the pull of the Sun comes from the mass of the Sun far away. Compute each one in m/s² and divide by w₁.

The 3D view shows the Earth with its axis and a body on it. Four steps (they play by themselves, or use the step buttons) show gravity toward the centre, the centrifugal acceleration away from the axis, the pull of the Sun toward the Sun, and the ratios. The arrows of w₂ and w₃ are drawn much longer than true, because at true size they would be too short to see. The page prints by how many times.

Interactive derivation

The solution in each frame

Frame of the Earth (turning)

This is the frame of someone standing on the Earth. In it, a body at rest feels gravity toward the centre and the centrifugal force of inertia, m ω² ρ, pointing away from the axis, where ρ is the distance from the axis. The problem asks for this frame at the equator.

Frame of the Sun

The Sun's pull is found in the frame of the Sun, as γMS/d². The Earth itself falls toward the Sun with the same acceleration, so on the surface the Sun's pull mostly cancels and only a tiny tidal difference remains. The problem asks for the pull itself, so no cancellation is applied.

The solution step by step

Step 1, gravity at the surface. The force on a body of mass m at distance R from the centre is γ M m / R², so

w₁ = γ M / R² = m/s²

Step 2, the centrifugal acceleration. A point at latitude λ circles the axis on a circle of radius ρ = R cos λ with angular speed ω = 2π/T, so

w₂ = ω² R cos λ

At the equator (λ = 0), ω = rad/s and w₂ = ω² R = m/s². At your latitude, w₂ = m/s².

Step 3, the pull of the Sun. The Sun gives a body the acceleration

w₃ = γ MS / d² = m/s²

Step 4, the ratios. Divide by w₁:

w₂ / w₁ = , w₃ / w₁ =

So w₁ : w₂ : w₃ = 1 : : .

Step 5, what the numbers mean. Gravity is about 300 times stronger than the centrifugal acceleration, which is why the Earth's turning changes the weight at the equator by only about 0.3 percent. The pull of the Sun is about 1700 times weaker than gravity, but it is the force that keeps the Earth in its orbit.

Numerical check

Each acceleration is found a second way from different data. For w₁, the Moon's orbit (radius 384 400 km, period 27.32 days) gives an acceleration 4π² r / T², and the inverse-square law scales it from the Moon's distance down to the Earth's surface: m/s² (formula m/s², difference percent). For w₂, the speed of the equator, v = 2πR cos λ / T, gives v²/(R cos λ) = m/s² (difference percent). For w₃, the Earth's own orbit around the Sun (period 365.256 days) gives 4π² d / T² = m/s² (formula m/s², difference percent).

Other methods

Using the orbital period. The Sun's pull equals the acceleration of the Earth on its orbit, 4π² d / Tyear², which gives w₃ without knowing the mass of the Sun. The check above does this.

Energy. Energy does not fit this question, because the question asks for accelerations, which are forces per unit mass.

Graph. The first graph compares the three accelerations on a logarithmic scale, so that numbers 300 and 1700 times apart can be seen together. The second shows how w₂ / w₁ falls to zero at the pole. The third shows how w₃ / w₁ depends on the distance to the Sun.

The direct formulas are the fastest. The check from the orbital data is the most reliable.

What each slider changes

ControlWhat it changes
Latitude λ (header slider too)The position of the body, the centrifugal acceleration w₂ = ω² R cos λ, its ratio, the arrows, and the dot on graph 2. Gravity and the Sun's pull do not depend on λ.
Rotation period TThe angular speed, w₂ and its ratio, the arrow of w₂ and the curve of graph 2.
Distance d to the SunThe pull of the Sun w₃, its ratio, the arrow of w₃ and the dot on graph 3.
Time of day (angle from the Sun)Only the direction in which the Sun's pull points at the body, and the picture. The sizes of the accelerations do not change.

Parameters

QuantitySymbolValue used
Rotation periodT h
Distance to the Sund AU
Gravity at the surfacew₁ m/s²
Centrifugal acceleration at the equatorw₂ m/s²
Pull of the Sunw₃ m/s²

Exam traps

  • Using the radius of the Earth's orbit in w₁ or the radius of the Earth in w₃. Gravity uses R = 6371 km, the Sun's pull uses d = 1.5 × 108 km.
  • Using the period of 24 hours as if it were the real period. The Earth turns once in 23 h 56 min relative to the stars. The difference changes w₂ by about 0.7 percent, so 0.0034 or 0.0035 are both accepted.
  • Using the radius R for the centrifugal acceleration at every latitude. The circle has radius R cos λ, so w₂ falls to zero at the pole.
  • Forgetting to square the angular speed, or using the period instead of 2π/T.
  • Thinking the Sun's pull is negligible because it is small. It is only small compared with gravity at the surface. It is the force that holds the Earth in its orbit.
  • Mixing units. Use metres and seconds for all three accelerations, and divide at the end.