At what height over the Earth's pole the free-fall acceleration decreases by one per cent; by half?
The free-fall acceleration over the pole is g = g₀ R² / (R + h)², so it has fallen by a fraction f when h = R (1/√(1 − f) − 1). For a fall of one per cent, h = km, about R/200. For a fall of one half, h = (√2 − 1) R = km. Your sliders: f = percent gives h = km.
Problem statement
Problem 1.218. At what height over the Earth's pole the free-fall acceleration decreases by one per cent; by half?
Interpretation. Go straight up from the Earth's pole. The free-fall acceleration gets smaller as the distance from the Earth's centre grows. The question asks for the height above the surface where it has fallen by one per cent of its surface value, and the height where it has fallen to half of its surface value. Two answers are asked for, one for each case.
We assume the Earth is a sphere of radius R = 6371 km and mass M = 5.97 × 1024 kg, with g₀ = γM/R² = 9.81 m/s² at the surface. The pole is used because the Earth's turning adds no centrifugal term there, so the free-fall acceleration is the pure gravitational one. Air and other bodies are ignored. The problem gives no numbers, so R, M and the fall f are sliders, starting at the Earth's values and at one per cent.
Symbols: R is the radius of the Earth, h the height above the pole, g₀ the free-fall acceleration at the surface, g the free-fall acceleration at the height h, f the fraction by which g has fallen, γ the gravitational constant.
The big idea in plain words
Gravity follows the inverse-square law. At the surface the distance from the centre is R, and at the height h it is R + h. If the distance grows by a factor (1 + h/R), the acceleration shrinks by the square of that factor. Set that equal to the wanted fall and solve for h.
For one per cent the height is tiny compared with R, so a short form works. For one half the height is large, and the short form fails. The graphs show the difference. The picture shows the body above the pole, and a zoomed ruler so that even the small height of 32 km can be seen. Four steps run by themselves: the field at a height, the condition, solving for h, and the result for both cases.
The solution in each frame
Frame of the Earth
At the pole the Earth's turning does not push the body sideways or up, so the frame of the Earth gives the free-fall acceleration directly as the gravitational acceleration γM/r², with r the distance from the centre.
Other frames
No second frame is needed.
The solution step by step
Step 1, the field at a height. At the surface g₀ = γM/R². At the height h the distance from the centre is R + h, so
Step 2, the condition. A fall by the fraction f means g = (1 − f) g₀, so
Step 3, solve for h. Take the square root (the positive one, because h is above the surface):
With your f = percent and R = km, h = km.
Step 4, a fall of one per cent (f = 0.01). (1 + h/R)² = 1/0.99, so h/R = and h = km. Because h is much smaller than R, a short form works: (1 + h/R)−2 ≈ 1 − 2h/R, which gives 1 − 2h/R = 0.99 and h = R/200 = km. The short form is within percent.
Step 5, a fall by half (f = 0.5). (1 + h/R)² = 2, so 1 + h/R = √2 and
The short form cannot be used here, because h is not small compared with R. It would give R/4 = km, which is about 40 percent too small.
A separate search does not use the closed formula. It finds the height by bisection: it halves an interval of heights 80 times, each time computing g = γM/(R + h)² and comparing with the wanted value. For your f this gives h = km (formula km, difference percent). For one per cent it gives km and for one half km.
Other methods
Series. For a small fall, 1/√(1 − f) ≈ 1 + f/2, so h ≈ R f / 2. This gives R/200 for one per cent and R/4 for one half. The first is good and the second is wrong, which the third graph shows as the error of the short form.
Energy. Energy does not give g directly, so it does not fit this question.
Graph. The first graph shows g/g₀ against h/R, with the two wanted heights marked. The second shows h/R against f, exact and short form. The third shows the error of the short form.
The exact formula is the fastest and works for every f. The bisection search is the most reliable check.
What each slider changes
| Control | What it changes |
|---|---|
| Fall f (header slider too) | The height h, the body in the picture, g at that height, the ruler, and the dots on all three graphs. |
| Radius R | The height h in kilometres (h is proportional to R), g₀, the labels and the drawing of the ruler. The graphs are in h/R, so their shapes stay. |
| Mass M | g₀ and g in m/s², and the labels. It does not change h, because h/R depends only on f. The note says why. |
Parameters
| Quantity | Symbol | Value used |
|---|---|---|
| Radius | R | km |
| Mass | M | × 1024 kg |
| Surface value | g₀ | m/s² |
| Height for a fall of one per cent | h | km |
| Height for a fall by half | h | km |
Exam traps
- Writing g = g₀ (1 − h/R) or taking the fall to be proportional to the height. The law is inverse-square, so the fall is about twice h/R for small h.
- Using the short form for the fall by half. The height is then not small compared with R, and the short form is about 40 percent off.
- Reading "decreases by half" as a fall to half and then using f = 1 − 0.5 or 1/2 wrongly. The condition is g = g₀/2, which gives (1 + h/R)² = 2.
- Using the distance from the centre, R + h, as if it were the height. The height is measured from the surface.
- Using the equator. There the Earth's turning also changes the free-fall acceleration. At the pole it does not.
- Keeping the negative root of the square. A negative h would be below the surface, so it is rejected.