← Irodov Series·Problem 1.219prayogashaala.com
Irodov, Problem 1.219

On the pole of the Earth a body is imparted velocity v₀ directed vertically up. Knowing the radius of the Earth and the freefall acceleration on its surface, find the height to which the body will ascend. The air drag is to be neglected.

Launch speed v₀, in km/s (Play scans v₀ from 0.1 km/s to just below the escape speed, holding 4 s at the speed where h = R) v₀ = 5 km/s
Steps:
Launch site:
The answer in one line

On the pole the body rises to the height h = R v₀² / (2 g R − v₀²), where R is the radius of the Earth and g the free-fall acceleration on its surface. For the Earth and v₀ = km/s: . If v₀ reaches the escape speed √(2gR) = km/s, the body never stops. The globe below also shows a throw from the equator or any other place: the height changes only a little, but the path bends and the body lands away from the launch point.

Problem statement

Problem 1.219. On the pole of the Earth a body is imparted velocity v₀ directed vertically up. Knowing the radius of the Earth and the freefall acceleration on its surface, find the height to which the body will ascend. The air drag is to be neglected.

Interpretation. A body is thrown straight up from the pole with the speed v₀. It slows down as it rises, stops at some height, and falls back. The question asks for that highest height above the surface. The answer must be written with v₀, the radius R of the Earth and the free-fall acceleration g on the surface, so the gravitational constant and the mass of the Earth must not appear in it.

We assume the Earth is a sphere of radius R = 6371 km with g = 9.81 m/s² on its surface, so that γM = g R². The pole is used for the answer, so the turning of the Earth adds nothing there. The globe and the site controls show what changes elsewhere, using one turn in 23.934 hours (the day length is a slider). The air is ignored, as the problem says. The problem gives no number for v₀, so v₀, R and g are sliders, starting at the Earth's values and v₀ = 5 km/s. The map is Natural Earth (public domain).

Symbols: v₀ is the launch speed, R the radius of the Earth, g the free-fall acceleration on the surface, h the height reached above the surface, γ the gravitational constant, M the mass of the Earth, m the mass of the body.

The big idea in plain words

Only gravity does work on the body, so its total energy stays the same. At the launch the body has kinetic energy and a negative gravitational energy. At the highest point the speed is zero, so there is only gravitational energy, and it is less negative because the body is farther from the centre. Equate the two total energies and solve for the height.

The mass of the body cancels. The mass of the Earth is replaced using g = γM/R², which is why the answer needs only R and g. The simple rule h = v₀² / (2g) works only when the height is small compared with R. The graphs show where it fails. The picture shows the body flying up and back, slowed down, with its speed and the field g, and a zoomed ruler so that even a small height can be seen.

Interactive derivation

The solution in each frame

Frame of the Earth

At the pole the turning of the Earth gives no sideways motion and no centrifugal term along the vertical, so in the frame of the Earth the only force is the pull of the Earth, γMm/r², with r the distance from the centre.

Other frames

No second frame is needed.

The solution step by step

Step 1, energy at the launch. At the surface r = R. The kinetic energy is ½ m v₀² and the gravitational energy is −γMm/R:

E = ½ m v₀² − γMm / R

Step 2, energy at the highest point. The speed is zero there and r = R + h:

E = − γMm / (R + h)

Only gravity acts, so the two energies are equal:

½ m v₀² − γMm / R = − γMm / (R + h)

Step 3, remove M. On the surface g = γM/R², so γM = g R². Cancel m and write:

½ v₀² − g R = − g R² / (R + h)

Step 4, solve for h. Move terms: g R² / (R + h) = g R − ½ v₀². So R + h = g R² / (g R − ½ v₀²). Subtract R:

h = R v₀² / (2 g R − v₀²)

With your numbers, v₀ = km/s, R = km and g = m/s²: , which is .

Step 5, three limits.

  • A small v₀: the term v₀² in the bottom is small, so h ≈ v₀² / (2g). This is the school rule for a constant g. Your v₀ makes it wrong by percent.
  • v₀ = √(gR) = km/s: the bottom becomes g R, and h = R exactly. The body rises as high as the radius.
  • v₀ → √(2gR) = km/s: the bottom goes to zero, so h grows without limit. This is the escape speed. At or above it there is no highest point.

Step 6, a throw from another place on the Earth. On the pole the ground has no sideways speed. At latitude λ the ground moves east at u = ω R cos λ, where ω = 2π / (length of the day). At your site () u = km/s. A body thrown straight up from the ground shares this sideways speed, so as seen from space it moves along a curve. Two quantities stay the same: the energy per kilogram E = ½ (v₀² + u²) − g R, and the turning quantity per kilogram L = R u (the angular momentum). At the highest point the body moves only sideways, at distance r_a from the centre, so

½ L² / r_a² − g R² / r_a = E

This is a quadratic in 1/r_a. Its solution is r_a = (g R² + √(g²R⁴ + 2 E L²)) / (−2E), and the height is h = r_a − R. For u = 0 it gives the answer of Step 4. With the real Earth u is small, at most 0.465 km/s, so the height changes by a fraction of a percent: here h = km, which is km from the pole value. What you see clearly is the path. Seen from the ground the body is left behind by the turning Earth, so the path bends and the body lands of the launch point. A faster spinning planet (a shorter day) makes both effects larger. A step-by-step check at the site differs from the formula by percent.

Numerical check

A separate calculation does not use the closed formula. It follows the motion in small time steps (fourth-order Runge-Kutta), using only g = γM/r² at each step, until the speed reaches zero. For your numbers it gives (formula , difference percent). The time to the top is .

Other methods

Constant g. Treating g as constant gives h = v₀² / (2g) from the equations of uniform motion. It is quick, and it is right only for small v₀. The third graph shows that its error is exactly minus the square of v₀ over the escape speed.

Energy. This is the method above. It is algebra only and is exact.

Graph. The second graph plots the gravitational energy per kilogram against the height, with the total energy as a horizontal line. The body rises until the line meets the curve. If the line is at or above zero, it never meets the curve.

Calculus. Writing v dv = −γM dr / r² and integrating from the surface to the top gives the same energy equation, so calculus is not needed here.

The energy method is the fastest and the most reliable. The step-by-step motion is the independent check.

What each slider changes

ControlWhat it changes
Launch speed v₀ (header slider too)The height h, the position of the highest point, the speed arrow, the flight time and the dots on all three graphs.
Radius RThe height in kilometres, the escape speed, the zoom, the labels and the dots on the graphs. The graphs are in units of the escape speed and of R, so their axes stay fixed.
Free-fall acceleration gThe height, the escape speed, the flight time, the labels and the dots on the graphs.
LatitudeThe site on the globe, the ground speed, the height at the site, and the landing point. At 90 degrees it is the pole of the problem.
LongitudeThe site on the globe and the landing point. It changes no height.
Length of the dayThe ground speed, the height at the site and the sideways drift. It changes nothing at the pole.

Parameters

QuantitySymbolValue used
Launch speedv₀ km/s
RadiusR km
Free-fall acceleration on the surfaceg m/s²
Length of the dayT hours
Speed that gives h = R√(gR) km/s
Escape speed√(2gR) km/s

Exam traps

  • Using h = v₀² / (2g) for a fast launch. It is only good when h is much smaller than R. At v₀ = √(gR) it gives R/2 when the true height is R.
  • Measuring the energy from the centre instead of the surface. The height h is above the surface, and r at the top is R + h.
  • Writing the gravitational energy as m g h. That form holds only near the surface.
  • Leaving γM in the answer. The problem gives g and R, so use γM = g R².
  • Forgetting that the answer fails when v₀ is the escape speed or more. The bottom of the fraction is then zero or negative, and there is no highest point.
  • Thinking a throw from the equator lands on the launch point. The ground moves east, so the body is left behind and lands to the west of it. At the pole there is no such drift.
  • Mixing units: v₀ in km/s with g in m/s². Change both to metres first.