← Irodov Series·Problem 1.220prayogashaala.com
Irodov, Problem 1.220

A thin uniform rod AB of mass m = 1.0 kg moves translationally with acceleration w = 2.0 m/s² due to two antiparallel forces F₁ and F₂ (Fig. 1.52). The distance between the points at which these forces are applied is equal to a = 20 cm. Besides, it is known that F₂ = 5.0 N. Find the length of the rod.

Acceleration w of the rod, in m/s² (Play scans w, holding 4 s at the given 2.0 m/s²) w = 2 m/s²
Steps:
The answer in one line

The rod does not turn, so the torque about its centre is zero. Together with F₂ − F₁ = m w this gives l = 2 a F₂ / (m w). For the given numbers, l = 2 × 0.20 × 5.0 / (1.0 × 2.0) = 1.0 m. Your sliders:

Problem statement

Problem 1.220. A thin uniform rod AB of mass m = 1.0 kg moves translationally with acceleration w = 2.0 m/s² due to two antiparallel forces F₁ and F₂ (Fig. 1.52). The distance between the points at which these forces are applied is equal to a = 20 cm. Besides, it is known that F₂ = 5.0 N. Find the length of the rod.

Interpretation. The rod is thin and uniform, so its centre of mass (CM) is at its middle. It moves translationally: every point has the same acceleration w and the rod does not turn. Two forces act on it, in opposite directions (antiparallel). In Fig. 1.52 the force F₁ is applied at the end A and the force F₂ at a point a below A along the rod. The rod speeds up toward the side of F₂, so F₂ is the larger force. The question asks for the length l of the rod.

We assume the rod is straight and uniform, the forces are perpendicular to the rod as in the figure, and nothing else gives a torque. The weight of the rod, if there is one, acts at the centre along the rod, so it gives no torque and does not change the answer. The lengths are in metres: a = 20 cm = 0.20 m.

Symbols: m is the mass of the rod, w the acceleration of the rod, F₁ and F₂ the two forces, a the distance between the points where they act, l the length of the rod, A and B its two ends.

The big idea in plain words

A rod that only moves, without turning, has no net torque about its centre. The forces F₁ and F₂ would turn it in opposite ways, so their turning effects must be equal. The net force gives the acceleration, and that fixes F₁. The equal turning effects then fix the length.

The picture follows Fig. 1.52. Two bars show the turning effect of each force about the centre. They are equal for the right length. Use the "free length" button to try another length: the bars become unequal and the rod starts to turn. Four steps run by themselves: translation, no turning, solving for l, and the numbers.

Interactive derivation

The solution in each frame

Frame of the ground (lab frame)

Use Newton's second law for the centre of mass and the rule that the torque about the centre is zero when the rod does not turn. This is the frame used in the steps below.

Frame of the rod

In a frame that moves with the rod, the rod is at rest. A force m w, opposite to the acceleration, acts at the centre. The forces F₁, F₂ and m w then balance, and the torques about the centre balance. This gives the same two equations.

The solution step by step

Step 1, translation. Take the direction of F₂ as positive. The centre of mass has acceleration w, so

F₂ − F₁ = m w

This gives F₁ = F₂ − m w = N.

Step 2, no turning. The centre of mass is at the middle of the rod, a distance l/2 below A. The force F₁ acts at A, so its arm about the centre is l/2. The force F₂ acts a distance a below A, so its arm is l/2 − a, on the same side of the centre as A. The two forces point in opposite directions on the same side of the centre, so they turn the rod in opposite ways. For no turning, the turning effects are equal:

F₁ · l/2 = F₂ · (l/2 − a)

Step 3, solve for l. Put F₁ = F₂ − m w into the torque equation:

(F₂ − m w) · l/2 = F₂ · l/2 − F₂ a

The term F₂ l/2 cancels on both sides, so − m w l/2 = − F₂ a, and

l = 2 a F₂ / (m w)

Step 4, numbers. l = 2 × 0.20 m × 5.0 N / (1.0 kg × 2.0 m/s²) = 1.0 m. Check: F₁ = 3.0 N, F₁ l/2 = 1.5 N·m and F₂ (l/2 − a) = 5.0 × 0.30 = 1.5 N·m, equal. With your sliders: m = kg, w = m/s², a = cm, F₂ = N give l = m, F₁ l/2 = N·m and F₂ (l/2 − a) = N·m.

Step 5, when the answer exists. The point of F₂ must lie between A and the centre, so l/2 > a, that is l > 2a. With the result for l, this means w < F₂/m, which is the same as F₁ > 0. For F₂ = 5.0 N and m = 1.0 kg the acceleration must stay below 5.0 m/s². If w reaches F₂/m, F₁ falls to zero and F₂ acts at the centre.

Numerical check

A separate search does not use the formula for l. For each trial length it finds the net torque about the centre, with F₁ from the force equation, and it halves the interval of lengths 80 times until the torque is zero. For your numbers it gives l = m (formula m, difference percent).

Other methods

Torque about another point. For a rod that only moves, the net torque about any point P equals m times the cross product of the vector from P to the centre with the acceleration. Take P at the point where F₂ acts. Then only F₁ gives a torque, F₁ a, and the centre is a distance l/2 − a away: F₁ a = m w (l/2 − a). With F₁ = F₂ − m w this gives the same l. Here F₁ a = N·m and m w (l/2 − a) = N·m.

Frame of the rod. Add the force m w at the centre and use statics. The torque about the point of F₂ gives F₁ a = m w (l/2 − a) again.

Graph. The first graph plots the net torque about the centre, divided by F₂ a, against the length divided by the answer. It is the straight line 1 − l/l₀ and crosses zero at the answer. The second graph shows the acceleration that the rod can have for a given length, and the third shows F₁/F₂.

Calculus. It is not needed, because the problem has no changing quantities.

The torque about the centre is the fastest method. The numerical search is the independent check.

What each slider changes

ControlWhat it changes
Acceleration w (header slider too)The length l, the force F₁, the arms, the picture of the rod and the dots on the graphs.
Mass mThe length l, the force F₁, the arms, the drawing and the labels.
Distance aThe length l, the position of the point where F₂ acts, the arms and the labels.
Force F₂The length l, the force F₁, the arrows, the arms and the labels.
Free lengthOnly in the free-length mode: the length of the rod in the picture, the net torque, and how fast the rod starts to turn. The answer l stays the solved one.

Parameters

QuantitySymbolValue used
Mass of the rodm kg
Accelerationw m/s²
Distance between the pointsa cm
Force F₂F₂ N
Force F₁ (from step 1)F₁ N
Length of the rodl m

Exam traps

  • Treating the rod as in balance, with F₁ = F₂. The rod accelerates, so F₂ − F₁ = m w.
  • Taking the arm of F₂ as l/2 + a. The point of F₂ is a below A, so its arm about the centre is l/2 − a.
  • Using a as the distance from the centre. a is the distance between the two points where the forces act.
  • Taking the torque about A and setting it to zero. The centre of mass accelerates, so the torque about A is not zero. It equals m w l/2.
  • Mixing units: a = 20 cm must be 0.20 m.
  • Forgetting the limit w < F₂/m. Above it F₁ would be negative and the forces would no longer be antiparallel.