← Irodov Series·Problem 1.221prayogashaala.com
Irodov, Problem 1.221

A force F = Ai + Bj is applied to a point whose radius vector relative to the origin of coordinates O is equal to r = ai + bj, where a, b, A, B are constants, and i, j are the unit vectors of the x and y axes. Find the moment N and the arm l of the force F relative to the point O.

y component B of the force, in N (Play scans B, holding 4 s at the given B = 3 N and where N = 0) B = 3 N
Steps:
The answer in one line

N = r × F = (aB − bA) k, and l = |N| / |F| = |aB − bA| / √(A² + B²). Your sliders:

Problem statement

Problem 1.221. A force F = Ai + Bj is applied to a point whose radius vector relative to the origin of coordinates O is equal to r = ai + bj, where a, b, A, B are constants, and i, j are the unit vectors of the x and y axes. Find the moment N and the arm l of the force F relative to the point O.

Interpretation. The point P is at the place r = ai + bj in the xy plane. The force F = Ai + Bj acts at P and lies in the same plane. The moment N is the torque of F about O, a vector. The arm l is the shortest distance from O to the line along which F acts.

We assume sample numbers so that the page can draw the situation: a = 3 m, b = 2 m, A = 2 N and B = 3 N. All four are sliders, so any other constants can be tried. The formulas hold for any values.

Symbols: a and b are the coordinates of the point P in metres. A and B are the components of the force in newtons. i, j and k are the unit vectors along x, y and z. The z axis points out of the page.

The big idea in plain words

A force turns things about O. The turning effect is the force times the arm, where the arm is the shortest distance from O to the line of the force. In vector form the same thing is r × F. Because r and F both lie in the xy plane, the result points along z. Its size is |N| and its sign tells whether the turning is counterclockwise (plus) or clockwise (minus).

The picture is the xy plane. The green arrow is r, the amber arrow is F, the red segment is the arm l. Move any slider and the arrows, the arm and the numbers change together. The hollow circle slides along the line of action: N and l stay the same, because only the line matters.

Interactive derivation

The solution in each frame

Frame with origin at O

This is the frame of the question. Use the components of r and F and the rules for the unit vectors. It is the frame used in the steps below.

Frame with the origin moved

If the origin is moved to another point O′, the moment about O′ is N′ = (r − r₀) × F, where r₀ is the vector from O to O′. The force F does not change, but N and l do. If O′ lies on the line of action of F, then N′ = 0 and l′ = 0.

The solution step by step

Step 1, the numbers and then the vectors. The point P has coordinates (a, b) and the force has components (A, B). The first number of each pair is the part along x (it multiplies i). The second number is the part along y (it multiplies j). So r = a i + b j and F = A i + B j. With your sliders (a, b) = (, ) m and (A, B) = (, ) N, which gives r = m and F = N. For the sample, r = 3i + 2j and F = 2i + 3j: the point is at x = 3, y = 2, while the force has the smaller part along x (2) and the larger along y (3).

Step 2, the moment. By definition N = r × F, so

N = (ai + bj) × (Ai + Bj) = aA (i × i) + aB (i × j) + bA (j × i) + bB (j × j)

The cross product of a vector with itself is zero, so i × i = 0 and j × j = 0. For the axes, i × j = k and j × i = − k. Therefore

N = (aB − bA) k

With your sliders N = ( − ) k = k N·m.

Step 3, the arm. The moment is the force times the arm, so |N| = |F| l, and

l = |N| / |F| = |aB − bA| / √(A² + B²)

Here |F| = N, so l = m.

Step 4, the sign and the special cases. A plus sign means counterclockwise turning (k out of the page). A minus sign means clockwise turning. N = 0 when aB = bA, that is when F is along r (or opposite to it): the line of action passes through O and l = 0. The arm is as large as it can be, l = |r| = √(a² + b²), when F is perpendicular to r.

Numerical check

A separate search does not use the formula for N. It moves a point along the line of action, measures its distance from O each time, and narrows down the smallest distance by repeated thirds (200 steps). For your numbers it gives l = m (formula m, difference ).

Other methods

Components. Only the part of F perpendicular to r turns the point about O. That part is F sin φ, where φ is the angle between r and F. So |N| = r F sin φ and the arm is l = r sin φ. The third graph shows sin φ against the direction of F.

Area. |N| is the area of the parallelogram built on r and F. For the given numbers that area is |aB − bA| = .

Determinant. N = (aB − bA) k can be written as the determinant of the 2 by 2 array with rows a, b and A, B.

Calculus. It is not needed, because the problem has no changing quantities.

The unit vector rules are the fastest method. The search along the line of action is the independent check.

What each slider changes

ControlWhat it changes
aThe position of P, the arrow r, the line of action, N, l and all three graphs.
bThe position of P, the arrow r, the line of action, N, l and all three graphs.
AThe direction and length of the arrow F, the line of action, N, l and all three graphs.
B (header slider too)The direction and length of the arrow F, the line of action, N, l, the turning arrow at O and the dots on the graphs.

Parameters

QuantitySymbolValue used
x of the pointa m
y of the pointb m
x of the forceA N
y of the forceB N
MomentN k N·m
Arml m

Exam traps

  • Writing N = aA − bB or N = aA + bB. The dot product is not the moment. The moment is the cross product, aB − bA.
  • Getting the sign wrong. N = aB − bA, not bA − aB. Check with a = 1, b = 0, A = 0, B = 1: the force pushes up at a point on the x axis, so the turning is counterclockwise and N is plus k.
  • Taking the arm as the distance from O to the point P. The arm is the distance from O to the line of the force. It equals |r| only when F is perpendicular to r.
  • Forgetting the absolute value. The arm is a distance, so it is never negative. The sign belongs to N.
  • Dividing by |r| instead of |F|. The arm is |N| divided by the size of the force.
  • Thinking that sliding the force along its line changes the moment. It does not.