← Irodov Series·Problem 1.222prayogashaala.com
Irodov, Problem 1.222

A force F₁ = Aj is applied to a point whose radius vector r₁ = ai, while a force F₂ = Bi is applied to the point whose radius vector r₂ = bj. Both radius vectors are determined relative to the origin of coordinates O, i, and j are the unit vectors of the x and y axes, a, b, A, B are constants. Find the arm l of the resultant force relative to the point O.

size B of the force F₂ = B i, in N (Play scans B, holding 4 s at the given B = 1.5 N and where N = 0) B = 1.5 N
Steps:
The answer in one line

The resultant is F = B i + A j. The moment of the two forces about O is N = (aA − bB) k, so l = |N| / |F| = |aA − bB| / √(A² + B²). Your sliders:

Problem statement

Problem 1.222. A force F₁ = Aj is applied to a point whose radius vector r₁ = ai, while a force F₂ = Bi is applied to the point whose radius vector r₂ = bj. Both radius vectors are determined relative to the origin of coordinates O, i, and j are the unit vectors of the x and y axes, a, b, A, B are constants. Find the arm l of the resultant force relative to the point O.

Interpretation. The force F₁ acts at the point P₁ = (a, 0) on the x axis and points along y. The force F₂ acts at the point P₂ = (0, b) on the y axis and points along x. Neither force acts at O. The resultant is F = F₁ + F₂. Its arm l is the shortest distance from O to the line along which F acts.

We assume sample numbers so that the page can draw the situation: a = 3 m, b = 2 m, A = 2 N and B = 1.5 N. All four are sliders, so any other constants can be tried. The formulas hold for any values.

Symbols: a is the x coordinate of P₁ and b is the y coordinate of P₂, both in metres. A and B are the sizes of the forces in newtons. i, j and k are the unit vectors along x, y and z. The z axis points out of the page.

The big idea in plain words

The resultant has the same turning effect about O as the two forces together. So its moment about O is the sum of the two moments: N = r₁ × F₁ + r₂ × F₂. Both forces lie in the xy plane, so N points along z. The arm of the resultant is then its moment divided by its size, l = |N| / |F|.

The picture is the xy plane. The two thin dashed lines are the lines of action of F₁ (the vertical one) and F₂ (the horizontal one). They cross at Q = (a, b). The resultant acts along the line through Q, and the red segment is its arm. Move any slider and everything changes together.

Interactive derivation

The solution in each frame

Frame with origin at O

This is the frame of the question. Use the components of the radius vectors and the forces and the rules for the unit vectors. It is the frame used in the steps below.

Frame with the origin moved

If the origin is moved to another point, the moments and the arm change, but the resultant F does not. If the new origin lies on the line of action of F, the moment is zero and the arm is zero.

The solution step by step

Step 1, the numbers and then the vectors. The point P₁ has coordinates (a, 0) and the point P₂ has coordinates (0, b). The force F₁ has components (0, A) and the force F₂ has components (B, 0). The first number of each pair goes with i (along x), the second with j (along y). So r₁ = a i, r₂ = b j, F₁ = A j and F₂ = B i. With your sliders (a, 0) = (, 0) m and (0, b) = (0, ) m, (0, A) = (0, ) N and (B, 0) = (, 0) N.

Step 2, the two moments.

N₁ = r₁ × F₁ = a i × A j = a A (i × j) = a A k
N₂ = r₂ × F₂ = b j × B i = b B (j × i) = − b B k

Here i × j = k and j × i = − k. With your sliders N₁ = k N·m and N₂ = k N·m.

Step 3, the resultant and its arm. The resultant is

F = F₁ + F₂ = B i + A j, |F| = √(A² + B²)

The moment of the resultant about O is the sum of the two moments:

N = N₁ + N₂ = (aA − bB) k

Since |N| = |F| l,

l = |aA − bB| / √(A² + B²)

Why N is perpendicular to F does not matter here. Both lie in the xy plane, N points along z and F lies in the xy plane, so N · F = 0 and the arm is simply N divided by F. With your sliders N = k N·m, |F| = N and l = m.

Step 4, the sign and the special cases. A plus sign of N means counterclockwise turning about O and a minus sign means clockwise. N = 0 when aA = bB. Then the resultant passes through O and l = 0. If only F₁ acts (B = 0), the line of action is the vertical line x = a and l = |a|. If only F₂ acts (A = 0), the line is the horizontal line y = b and l = |b|.

Numerical check

A separate search does not use the formula for N. It finds, by halving an interval 100 times, the point on an axis about which the two forces together have zero moment. That point lies on the line of action of the resultant. Then it moves along that line, measuring the distance from O, and narrows down the smallest distance by repeated thirds (200 steps). For your numbers it gives l = m (formula m, difference ).

Other methods

Where the lines cross. The line of action of F₁ is the vertical line x = a. The line of action of F₂ is the horizontal line y = b. They cross at Q = (a, b). Both forces can be slid along their lines to Q without changing anything, so the resultant acts at Q. Then N = r × F with r = a i + b j and F = B i + A j gives N = (aA − bB) k again.

Graph. The first graph shows N against B. The second shows the arm against B. The third shows the two moments N₁ and N₂ separately: N₁ = aA does not depend on B, and N₂ = − bB falls as B grows. Their sum is the first graph.

Calculus. It is not needed, because the problem has no changing quantities.

Moving both forces to Q is the fastest method. The search along the line of action is the independent check.

What each slider changes

ControlWhat it changes
aThe place of P₁ and of the line of action of F₁, the point Q, N₁, N, l and the graphs.
bThe place of P₂ and of the line of action of F₂, the point Q, N₂, N, l and the graphs.
AThe length of the arrow F₁, the resultant F, N₁, N, l and the graphs.
B (header slider too)The length of the arrow F₂, the resultant F, N₂, N, l, the turning arrow at O and the dots on the graphs.

Parameters

QuantitySymbolValue used
x of P₁a m
y of P₂b m
Force F₁ = A jA N
Force F₂ = B iB N
Moment about ON k N·m
Arm of the resultantl m

Exam traps

  • Writing N = aB − bA. In this problem F₁ = A j acts at r₁ = a i, so the term is aA. The other term is − bB, with a minus sign because j × i = − k.
  • Thinking that both forces act at O. F₁ acts at (a, 0) and F₂ acts at (0, b). O is only the point about which the moments are taken.
  • Taking the arm of the resultant as the arm of one force. The resultant has its own line of action, and its arm is |N| / |F|.
  • Adding the two arms. Arms do not add. The moments add, and the arm is found afterwards.
  • Dividing by |A| + |B| instead of √(A² + B²). The size of the resultant is the square root of the sum of squares.
  • Forgetting the absolute value. The arm is a distance, so it is never negative. The sign belongs to N.