← Irodov Series·Problem 1.223prayogashaala.com
Irodov, Problem 1.223

Three forces are applied to a square plate as shown in Fig. 1.53. Find the modulus, direction, and the point of application of the resultant force, if this point is taken on the side BC.

trial point S on the side BC, as a fraction of BC measured from B (Play moves S from B to C, holding 4 s at the midpoint) s = 0.30
Steps:
The answer in one line

The resultant has modulus R = 2F. It points along the diagonal AC, from A toward C. Its line of action crosses the side BC at the midpoint of BC, a distance a/2 from B. Your sliders:

Problem statement

Problem 1.223. Three forces are applied to a square plate as shown in Fig. 1.53. Find the modulus, direction, and the point of application of the resultant force, if this point is taken on the side BC.

Interpretation. The square is drawn with a diagonal along the horizontal. Its corners are A (left), B (top), C (right) and D (bottom). Three forces act at corners: a force F at B pointing to the right, a force F at A pointing up, and a force √2 F at D pointing down and to the right at 45 degrees. The question asks for the single force that replaces the three (the resultant): its size, its direction, and where its line of action meets the side BC.

We assume sample numbers so that the page can draw the situation: F = 5 N and a = 0.5 m, where a is the side of the square. Both are sliders, and the results are written in terms of F and a, so they hold for any values.

Symbols: F is the basic force, a the side of the square, h = a/√2 half of the diagonal, R the resultant, N the moment about the corner C, l the arm of R about C, and S a trial point on the side BC.

The big idea in plain words

Adding the three forces as vectors gives the size and direction of the resultant. A vector sum does not say where the resultant acts, so a second condition is needed: the resultant must have the same turning effect (moment) as the three forces together. Take moments about the corner C. That fixes the height of the line of action above the diagonal AC. The place where that line meets the side BC is the point asked for.

In the picture the hollow circle S is a trial point on BC and the amber arrow is R drawn from S. The graphs show how the moment of R about C compares with the moment of the three forces. They match at one place only: the midpoint of BC. Use Play, or drag the slider, and watch S cross that place.

Interactive derivation

The solution in each frame

Frame of the plate, origin at C

Take x along AC (to the right) and y upward. With the origin at C the corners are A = (−2h, 0), B = (−h, h), D = (−h, −h) and C = (0, 0). The moment of a force with components (Fx, Fy) at the point (x, y) about C is x Fy − y Fx. This frame is used in the steps below.

Frame with another origin

The resultant R and its line of action do not depend on the origin. Taking moments about another corner gives a different N and a different arm, but the same line.

The solution step by step

Step 1, the forces in components. F at B points right: (F, 0). F at A points up: (0, F). √2 F at D points down and right at 45 degrees: (√2 F cos 45°, − √2 F sin 45°) = (F, − F). The numbers now are F = N and a = m, so h = a/√2 = m.

Step 2, the resultant. Add the components:

Rx = F + 0 + F = 2F, Ry = 0 + F − F = 0

So R = 2F = N, directed along AC from A toward C (to the right).

Step 3, the moments about C. The moment of a force about C is the force times its arm. The arm is the perpendicular distance from C to the line along which the force acts. The page draws the three arms in colour and labels them:

  • Force F at B acts along the horizontal line through B. The arm from C is the vertical distance to that line, h. This force turns the plate clockwise.
  • Force F at A acts along the vertical line through A. The arm is the distance CA along the diagonal, 2h. This force also turns the plate clockwise.
  • Force √2 F at D acts at 45 degrees, at right angles to the side DC. The arm is the side CD itself, a = √2 h. This force turns the plate counterclockwise.
N = − F h − F (2h) + √2 F · (√2 h) = − hF − 2hF + 2hF = − hF

The same result comes from x Fy − y Fx with the origin at C: − hF for B, − 2hF for A and + 2hF for D. The sum is N = − hF = − F a/√2. It has size N·m and it is clockwise (into the page). The arm of R about C is l = |N| / R = hF / 2F = h/2 = a/(2√2) = m.

Because N is not zero, the three forces are not balanced about C. If the plate were free to turn about C, it would turn clockwise. The picture shows this turning: the plate swings clockwise about C, with a faint outline at the start. A larger N (larger F or larger a) gives a larger swing in the picture.

Step 4, the point on BC. Let R act at a point S on BC, measured from B by a fraction s of BC. In the frame of the plate S = (− h(1 − s), h(1 − s)), so its height above AC is y_S = h(1 − s). The moment of R = (2F, 0) about C is − y_S · 2F = − 2F h (1 − s). Set it equal to − hF:

2F h (1 − s) = hF so 1 − s = 1/2, s = 1/2

The line of action meets BC at its midpoint, at a distance s a = a/2 = m from B. For your trial point s = the moments differ by hF (2s − 1) = N·m.

Numerical check

A separate search does not use the formulas above. It adds the three force vectors, adds the three moments about C as cross products, and then halves an interval of positions along BC 80 times until the moment of R drawn from that point equals the moment of the three forces. For your numbers it gives s = (formula 0.5, difference ) and R = N.

Other methods

Cancelling parts. The vertical parts, F up at A and F down in the √2 F force, cancel, so only the horizontal parts remain: F at B and F in the √2 F force. Together they are 2F to the right.

Another origin. Take moments about the centre of the square (a different corner or point gives a different N and arm). The line of action found is the same: a horizontal line a height h/2 above the diagonal AC.

Graph. The first graph plots the mismatch hF (2s − 1) against s and it crosses zero at s = 1/2. The second plots the moment of R about C for each trial point and the moment of the three forces. The third plots |N| = F a/√2 against the side a.

Calculus. It is not needed, because the problem has no changing quantities.

Components and moments about C are the fastest method. The search along BC is the independent check.

What each slider changes

ControlWhat it changes
Trial point s (header slider too)The place of S on BC, the arrow of R drawn from S, the mismatch, the dots on graphs 1 and 2, and the labels.
Force FThe length of all arrows, R = 2F, the moment N, the mismatch, and all three graphs.
Side aThe size of the square, h, the moment N, the arm l, the distance from B, and graph 3.

Parameters

QuantitySymbolValue used
Basic forceF N
Side of the squarea m
Half of the diagonalh m
ResultantR N
Moment about CN N·m (clockwise)
Arm of R about Cl m

Exam traps

  • Adding the sizes F + F + √2 F. Forces add as vectors. The vertical parts cancel and the sum is 2F.
  • Forgetting that the √2 F force has two components, F to the right and F down.
  • Taking the resultant to act at the centre of the plate. Its line of action is found from the moment, and it is not through the centre.
  • Using the side a as the arm of every force. The arms about C are different: h for the force at B, 2h for the force at A and a for the force at D. Each is a perpendicular distance to the line of action.
  • Mixing the sign of moments. With the origin at C, the forces at B and A turn the plate clockwise and the force at D turns it counterclockwise. The net moment is clockwise.
  • Giving the point as "on AC". The point is on the side BC, at its midpoint.