← Irodov Series·Problem 1.225prayogashaala.com
Irodov, Problem 1.225

Calculate the moment of inertia (a) of a copper uniform disc relative to the symmetry axis perpendicular to the plane of the disc, if its thickness is equal to b = 2.0 mm and its radius to R = 100 mm; (b) of a uniform solid cone relative to its symmetry axis, if the mass of the cone is equal to m and the radius of its base to R.

Part:
Steps:
The answer in one line

(a) For the copper disc, I = π ρ b R⁴ / 2 = m R² / 2, about 2.8 g·m² for the given numbers. (b) For the cone, I = 3 m R² / 10. Your sliders: disc ; cone .

Problem statement

Problem 1.225. Calculate the moment of inertia (a) of a copper uniform disc relative to the symmetry axis perpendicular to the plane of the disc, if its thickness is equal to b = 2.0 mm and its radius to R = 100 mm; (b) of a uniform solid cone relative to its symmetry axis, if the mass of the cone is equal to m and the radius of its base to R.

Interpretation. In part (a) the disc is a short solid cylinder, and the axis is its line of symmetry, at right angles to the flat faces. In part (b) the cone is solid, and the axis goes from the tip through the middle of the base. Both bodies are uniform.

We assume the density of copper, ρ = 8.9 g/cm³ = 8900 kg/m³, because the problem does not give it. It is a slider. For the cone the problem gives no numbers, so the sample is m = 2 kg, R = 0.30 m and a height h = 0.60 m. The result for the cone does not depend on h.

Symbols: ρ is the density, b the thickness of the disc, R the radius, m the mass, h the height of the cone, I the moment of inertia, r the distance of a piece from the axis, and x the distance from the tip of the cone along the axis.

The big idea in plain words

The moment of inertia adds up (distance from the axis)² × (mass) for all pieces. For a round body about its symmetry axis, cut it into slices that are themselves round: rings for the disc, thin discs for the cone. Each slice is easy, and the slices are added.

The 3D picture can be turned with the mouse. The vertical line is the axis. The amber ring (disc) or amber slice (cone) is a probe that scans the body, and the page prints its mass and its share of I.

Interactive derivation

The solution in each frame

Frame of the body

The axis is fixed in the body and passes through its centre of mass in both parts, so the sums below are taken in this frame directly.

Other frames

No second frame is needed. The moment of inertia belongs to the body and the axis, not to the frame.

The solution step by step

Part (a), the copper disc

Step 1, one piece. Cut the disc into thin rings. A ring at distance r from the axis, with width dr, has the area 2π r dr and the volume 2π r b dr. Its mass is dm = ρ · 2π r b dr.

Step 2, its share. Every part of the ring is at the same distance r from the axis, so

dI = r² dm = 2π ρ b r³ dr

Step 3, add up. Add the rings from r = 0 to r = R. The sum of r³ dr from 0 to R is R⁴/4:

I = 2π ρ b · R⁴ / 4 = π ρ b R⁴ / 2

The mass of the disc is m = ρ π R² b, so I = m R² / 2.

Step 4, numbers. For ρ = kg/m³, b = mm and R = mm the mass is m = kg and I = kg·m² = g·m². For the given problem, ρ = 8900 kg/m³, b = 2.0 mm, R = 100 mm: I = π × 8900 × 0.0020 × 0.100⁴ / 2 = 2.8 × 10⁻³ kg·m², that is 2.8 g·m².

Part (b), the solid cone

Step 1, one piece. Put the tip at x = 0, and measure x along the axis towards the base, where x = h. The cone is made of thin discs. At distance x from the tip the radius of the disc is r = R x / h, because the radius grows in proportion to x. The disc has the volume π r² dx, so its mass is dm = ρ π r² dx. The density follows from the whole mass: ρ = m / (π R² h / 3) = 3 m / (π R² h).

Step 2, its share. A thin disc has the moment of inertia (1/2) dm r² about its own axis (part a), and its axis is the axis of the cone:

dI = (1/2) r² dm = (1/2) ρ π r⁴ dx = ρ π R⁴ x⁴ dx / (2 h⁴)

Step 3, add up. The sum of x⁴ dx from 0 to h is h⁵/5. Hence

I = ρ π R⁴ h / 10 = (3 m / (π R² h)) · π R⁴ h / 10 = 3 m R² / 10

The height h cancels. A tall thin cone and a short wide cone with the same m and R have the same I.

Step 4, numbers. For m = kg and R = m, I = kg·m². The sample (2 kg, 0.30 m) gives 3 × 2 × 0.09 / 10 = 0.054 kg·m².

Numerical check

A separate sum does not use the formulas. For the disc it cuts the radius into 4000 rings and adds r² dm for each. For the cone it cuts the height into 4000 thin discs and adds (1/2) r² dm for each. For your numbers the disc sum is kg·m² (formula , difference ) and the cone sum is kg·m² (formula , difference ).

Other methods

Disc as one piece. A uniform disc is the standard case, I = m R² / 2. It gives the disc answer without any sum: here m R² / 2 = kg·m².

Comparison with a cylinder. A solid cylinder of the same m and R has I = m R² / 2 = kg·m². The cone has 3/5 of that, because its mass lies closer to the axis.

Graph. For the disc the first graph plots dI/dr = 2π ρ b r³ against r, and for the cone it plots dI/dx against x. The area under the curve is I.

Calculus. It is needed once, for a simple power: r³ for the disc and x⁴ for the cone.

The disc is fastest from the known formula. The cone needs the slice sum, and the numerical sum is the independent check.

What each slider changes

ControlWhat it changes
Density ρ (part a)The mass of the disc, I, the probe values and all graphs of part (a).
Thickness b (part a)The thickness of the disc in the 3D view (drawn 4 times larger), its mass, I, the probe values and the graphs.
Radius R, part (a) (header slider too)The radius of the disc, its mass, I (as R⁴), the probe ring and the graphs.
Mass m (part b)The density of the cone, dm, I and the graphs.
Radius R, part (b) (header slider too)The base of the cone, the density, I (as R²), the probe slice and the graphs.
Height h (part b)The shape of the cone, its density, the slices and the first graph. It does not change I, because h cancels in the result.

Parameters

QuantitySymbolValue used
Density of copperρ kg/m³
Disc: thickness, radiusb, R mm, mm
Cone: mass, radius, heightm, R, h kg, m, m
I of the discπ ρ b R⁴ / 2 kg·m²
I of the cone3 m R² / 10 kg·m²

Exam traps

  • Mixing units. R and b must be in metres in the formula: 100 mm is 0.100 m, and 2.0 mm is 0.0020 m. The answer is in kg·m², and 1 kg·m² = 1000 g·m².
  • Using the whole disc as one piece at distance R. The pieces are at all distances from 0 to R, and the result is m R² / 2, not m R².
  • Using m R² / 2 for the cone. That is the cylinder value. The cone has 3 m R² / 10.
  • Thinking the height of the cone matters. With m and R fixed, h cancels.
  • Forgetting that the radius of a cone slice is not R but r = R x / h, so r² grows as x².
  • Using the density of the cone as m / (π R² h). The cone has only one third of the cylinder volume, so ρ = 3 m / (π R² h).