Demonstrate that in the case of a thin plate of arbitrary shape there is the following relationship between the moments of inertia: I1 + I2 = I3, where subindices 1, 2, and 3 define three mutually perpendicular axes passing through one point, with axes 1 and 2 lying in the plane of the plate. Using this relationship, find the moment of inertia of a thin uniform round disc of radius R and mass m relative to the axis coinciding with one of its diameters.
(a) For a thin plate, I1 + I2 = I3 for any three perpendicular axes through one point, with 1 and 2 in the plate. (b) For a thin round disc about a diameter, I = m R² / 4. Your sliders: plate ; disc .
Problem statement
Problem 1.226. Demonstrate that in the case of a thin plate of arbitrary shape there is the following relationship between the moments of inertia: I1 + I2 = I3, where subindices 1, 2, and 3 define three mutually perpendicular axes passing through one point, with axes 1 and 2 lying in the plane of the plate. Using this relationship, find the moment of inertia of a thin uniform round disc of radius R and mass m relative to the axis coinciding with one of its diameters.
Interpretation. The plate is so thin that all its pieces lie in one plane. Axes 1 and 2 are two straight lines in that plane, at right angles to each other, meeting at a point O. Axis 3 is the line through O at right angles to the plane. The point O may be anywhere in the plane. Part (a) asks for a proof, and part (b) uses it for a round disc.
We assume sample numbers so that the page can draw the bodies: for the plate, mass m = 2 kg, a bean-like shape of size s = 0.40 m, and the point O a little off-centre; for the disc, m = 2 kg and R = 0.20 m. All are sliders, and the results are written with symbols, so they hold for any values.
Symbols: m is the mass, I1, I2 and I3 the moments of inertia about axes 1, 2 and 3, x and y the coordinates of a piece along axes 1 and 2 (measured from O), r its distance from O, and R the radius of the disc.
The big idea in plain words
A piece of the plate has a distance to each axis. The distance to axis 1 is the sideways coordinate y, the distance to axis 2 is x, and the distance to axis 3 (the line standing up from O) is r, the distance from O in the plane. These three distances form a right triangle in the plate, so r² = x² + y². Each moment of inertia adds up mass times distance², so the same relation holds for the sums.
The 3D picture can be turned with the mouse. The amber piece is a probe that scans the plate, and the page prints its distances and its three shares.
The solution in each frame
Frame of the plate
The plate and the point O are at rest, and the axes are fixed in the plate. The sums are taken in this frame.
Other frames
No second frame is needed. The moment of inertia belongs to the plate and the axis.
The solution step by step
Part (a), the proof
Step 1, coordinates. Put O at the origin, axis 1 along x and axis 2 along y, both in the plane of the plate. Axis 3 is the z axis. A piece of mass dm is at the point (x, y, 0).
Step 2, three distances. The distance of the piece from axis 1 is |y|, because axis 1 is the x axis and the piece lies in the xy plane. The distance from axis 2 is |x|. The distance from axis 3 is r = √(x² + y²).
Step 3, three sums.
Step 4, compare. Since r² = x² + y² for every piece,
This holds for any shape, and for any point O and any direction of the axes 1 and 2 in the plane. No integral is needed, only the Pythagorean rule for each piece. If the axes 1 and 2 are turned about axis 3, I1 and I2 change, but their sum stays equal to I3.
Step 5, numbers. For your plate, I1 = kg·m², I2 = kg·m², and their sum is kg·m², equal to I3 = kg·m².
Part (b), the round disc
Step 1, choose the point. Take O at the centre of the disc. Axis 3 is the symmetry axis at right angles to the disc, and axes 1 and 2 are two perpendicular diameters.
Step 2, use the symmetry. A round disc looks the same after a turn about its centre, so every diameter gives the same moment of inertia. Hence I1 = I2 = I, the value asked for.
Step 3, the third axis. For a uniform disc about the axis through the centre at right angles to its plane, I3 = m R² / 2. (This is the disc of the previous problem, found with thin rings: I = ∫ r² dm = m R² / 2.)
Step 4, apply part (a).
Step 5, numbers. For m = kg and R = m, I3 = kg·m² and I = kg·m². For the sample, I = 2 × 0.2² / 4 = 0.02 kg·m².
A separate sum divides the plate into a grid of equal small pieces. For the plate it adds r² dm for each piece, and separately adds y² dm and x² dm, and compares I3 with I1 + I2: the plate sums are and kg·m² (difference ). For the round disc it adds the distance² to the diameter over the grid and compares with m R² / 4: the sum is kg·m² (formula , difference ).
Other methods
Direct sum for the disc. A ring-free way: for a diameter along x, the distance of a piece to it is y = r sin θ, so I = Σ r² sin²θ dm. The average of sin²θ around a circle is 1/2, so I = (1/2) Σ r² dm = (1/2)(m R² / 2) = m R² / 4. It uses the same symmetry.
Graph. For the plate, the first graph plots I1, I2 and I3 against the angle of the axes. I1 and I2 swing up and down in opposite ways, and I3 is the flat line equal to their sum. For the disc the graphs show I and I3 against R.
Calculus. It is not needed for part (a) or for the step from I3 to the diameter. The only integral is hidden in I3 = m R² / 2 for the disc, which is a known result.
The plate relation is the fastest method for the disc. The grid sum is the independent check.
What each slider changes
| Control | What it changes |
|---|---|
| Mass m | The mass of every piece (dm), I1, I2, I3, the probe values and the graphs, in both parts. |
| Size s of the plate (part a) | The plate in the 3D view, all three moments (as s²), the probe path and the graphs. |
| Position of O, x and y (part a) | Where the axes meet, I1, I2 and I3 (all three change, and I3 = I1 + I2 still holds), the legs of the probe and the graphs. |
| Angle of the axes (part a, header slider too) | The directions of axes 1 and 2 in the 3D view, I1 and I2 (they trade), the probe legs and the first graph. I3 does not change. |
| Radius R (part b, header slider too) | The disc in the 3D view, I and I3 (as R²), the probe and the graphs. |
| Angle of the diameter (part b) | The direction of axes 1 and 2 in the 3D view and the probe legs. I1 and I2 do not change, because the disc is round. |
Parameters
| Quantity | Symbol | Value used |
|---|---|---|
| Mass | m | kg |
| Plate: moments about axes 1, 2, 3 | I1, I2, I3 | , , kg·m² |
| Disc: radius | R | m |
| Disc: moment about a diameter | m R² / 4 | kg·m² |
Exam traps
- Using the relation for a thick body. It needs a thin plate, with all pieces in one plane. For a cylinder or a sphere it fails.
- Putting axis 3 anywhere other than through the same point O. The three axes must meet at one point.
- Taking axes 1 and 2 outside the plane of the plate. Both must lie in the plane.
- Forgetting the symmetry step for the disc. I1 = I2 only because the disc is round. For a rectangle they differ.
- Writing I = m R² / 2 for a diameter. That is the value about the axis at right angles to the disc. The diameter gives half of it, m R² / 4.
- Thinking I1 and I2 must stay fixed when the axes are turned. They change, and only their sum is fixed.