A point moves in the plane xy according to the law x = at, y = at(1 − αt), where a and α are positive constants, and t is time. Find: (a) the equation of the point’s trajectory y(x); plot this function; (b) the velocity v and the acceleration w of the point as functions of time; (c) the moment t0 at which the velocity vector forms an angle π/4 with the acceleration vector.
The path is the parabola y = x − (α/a)x². The velocity is v = (a, a(1 − 2αt)) with |v| = a√(1 + (1 − 2αt)²), and the acceleration is w = (0, −2aα) with |w| = 2aα. The angle between them is 45° at t0 = 1/α. With the numbers on screen: y = x − x², w = m/s² and t0 = s. At t = s the angle is °.
Problem statement
Problem 1.25. A point moves in the plane xy according to the law x = at, y = at(1 − αt), where a and α are positive constants, and t is time. Find: (a) the equation of the point’s trajectory y(x); plot this function; (b) the velocity v and the acceleration w of the point as functions of time; (c) the moment t0 at which the velocity vector forms an angle π/4 with the acceleration vector.
Interpretation. The coordinates x and y are given as functions of time. Part (a) asks for the path with t removed. Part (b) asks for the velocity and acceleration vectors, as functions of time. Part (c) asks for the time t0 when the angle between the velocity vector and the acceleration vector is 45° (π/4 in radians).
We assume a = 2 m/s and α = 0.5 1/s, because the problem gives no numbers. The units follow from the formulas: a is a speed, and α is one over a time, so that αt has no unit. Both are sliders. The graphs run from t = 0 to 4 s.
Symbols: v is the velocity, w the acceleration, θ the angle between v and w, t0 the moment when θ = 45°.
The big idea in plain words
Treat the two directions separately. Sideways, x = at, so the speed a never changes. Up and down, y = at − aαt²: the point is thrown upward and pulled down at a steady rate, like a ball. So the path is a parabola and the acceleration is constant and points straight down. The velocity starts tilted upward, becomes sideways at the top, and then tilts downward. The angle between v and the downward acceleration therefore starts at 135°, passes 90° at the top, and falls. It reaches 45° when the point has come back to its starting height.
The solution in each frame
Only the ground frame is needed. The problem gives x and y in one frame and asks for everything in that frame, so there is no second frame.
The solution step by step
Step 1, the path (part a). From x = at we get t = x/a. Put this into y = at(1 − αt): y = x(1 − αx/a) = x − (α/a)x². This is a parabola that opens downward. It crosses y = 0 at x = 0 and at x = a/α, and the top is half way between. Here y = x − x². The plot is the bright and dashed curve on the canvas.
Step 2, velocity and acceleration (part b), by comparison with the suvat equations. Each direction has the form of motion with constant acceleration: s = ut + ½At². Compare term by term. For x = at, there is no t² term, so the starting speed is ux = a and the acceleration is Ax = 0. For y = at − aαt², the t term gives uy = a, and ½Ay = −aα gives Ay = −2aα. Now use v = u + At: vx = a and vy = a − 2aαt = a(1 − 2αt). So |v| = √(vx² + vy²) = a√(1 + (1 − 2αt)²). The acceleration is w = (0, −2aα) = −2aα j, and |w| = 2aα = m/s² at every moment. No calculus was needed, because x and y are polynomials of degree 2 in t.
Step 3, the 45° moment (part c). The dot product gives v·w = vywy = −2a²α(1 − 2αt). Divide by vw: cos θ = −(1 − 2αt)/√(1 + (1 − 2αt)²). For θ = 45° we need cos θ = 1/√2. This happens when −(1 − 2αt) = 1, that is 2αt = 2. So t0 = 1/α = s. The other possible sign, 1 − 2αt = 1, gives t = 0. At t = 0 the velocity points up and to the right, so the angle with the downward w is 135°, not 45°. Only t0 = 1/α works.
Step 4, the cases. The problem has one situation, so no cases are needed. A check of the answer: at t0 = 1/α, vy = a(1 − 2) = −a, so v = (a, −a) and w points straight down. The velocity is half way between "down" and "sideways", so the angle is 45°. The height is y = a(1/α)(1 − 1) = 0, so the point is back at its starting height. The top of the path is at t = 1/(2α) = s.
A separate calculation does not use the formulas for v, w or θ. It takes the positions x(t) and y(t) and finds the velocity and acceleration by small differences (steps of 0.001 s). It gets the angle from the dot product of those two vectors, at t = 0.5, 1, 2 and 4 s. It then searches for the time when that angle is 45° by repeated halving of a time interval. The largest relative difference from the formulas, including t0 = s, is .
Methods
1. Force method
No mass or force is given, so this method does not apply. The problem is about motion only (kinematics).
2. Energy method
Energy does not help here, since no mass is given.
3. Graph method
The first graph shows vx as a flat line at a and vy as a straight line that falls through zero at the top of the path. The second graph shows θ falling from 135°. It crosses 90° at the top and 45° at t0. The third graph shows the height y, which returns to zero at t0 too.
4. Algebraic method (comparison with suvat)
Write the x and y laws next to s = ut + ½At² and read off u and A in each direction: u = (a, a) and A = (0, −2aα). Then v = u + At and w = A. For the angle, w points straight down, so θ = 45° when the velocity has equal sideways and downward parts: vy = −vx, so a(1 − 2αt) = −a and t0 = 1/α. This is the fastest route, with no calculus.
5. Calculus method
Differentiate x and y once for v and twice for w, then use the dot product. It gives the same results, and it is the method to use when the laws are not simple polynomials in t.
6. Check method
Units: αt has no unit, so α is in 1/s. Then aα is in m/s², which is right for an acceleration. Limits: for α going to 0, the point moves along a straight line (y = x) and w goes to 0, so the angle has no meaning. A bigger α makes t0 = 1/α smaller: the point bends over sooner. The answer does not depend on a, because both vx and vy are proportional to a.
Fastest: the algebraic method. Most reliable: the algebraic method with the numerical check.
What each slider changes
| Control | Changes the answer? | What it changes |
|---|---|---|
| Constant a | Yes | The size of the path, v, w = 2aα and the picture scale. The angle and t0 do not change |
| Constant α | Yes | The curve of the path, vy, w, the angle and t0 = 1/α |
| Moment shown t | No | The point, the arrows, the angle arc, the dots on the graphs and the live readings. The path and w do not depend on it |
| Given-answer mode | Sets t | The page finds the time at which the angle has a chosen value, and warns if that time is below 0 or above 4 s |
| Play and time bar | No | Play sweeps t from 0 to 4 s, holds 2 s at t0 and 1.5 s at the end, then repeats. The bar sets the time |
Parameters
| Quantity | Symbol | Value used |
|---|---|---|
| Sideways speed | a | m/s |
| Constant in y = at(1 − αt) | α | 1/s |
| Path coefficient | α/a | 1/m |
| Acceleration size | 2aα | m/s² |
| Time of the top of the path | 1/(2α) | s |
| Moment when the angle is 45° | t0 = 1/α | s |
Exam traps
- Taking both signs of the square root and keeping t = 0. At t = 0 the angle is 135°. Check the sign of the dot product.
- Measuring the angle from the x axis instead of from the acceleration. The problem asks for the angle between v and w, and w points straight down.
- Giving |v| as a + a(1 − 2αt). The two parts are at right angles, so the size is the square root of the sum of squares.
- Forgetting that α is not an angle. It has the unit 1/s.
- Writing the path as y = at(1 − αt) without removing t. Part (a) wants y as a function of x.