The following parameters of the arrangement of Fig. 1.11 are available: the angle α which the inclined plane forms with the horizontal, and the coefficient of friction k between the body m1 and the inclined plane. The masses of the pulley and the threads, as well as the friction in the pulley, are negligible. Assuming both bodies to be motionless at the initial moment, find the mass ratio m2/m1 at which the body m2 (a) starts coming down; (b) starts going up; (c) is at rest.
(a) m₂ starts coming down if m₂/m₁ > sin α + k cos α. (b) m₂ starts going up if m₂/m₁ < sin α − k cos α. (c) Everything stays at rest between these two values. With the numbers on screen the limits are 0.4134 and 0.5866, and at η = 0.667: m₂ comes down.
Problem statement
Problem 1.63. The following parameters of the arrangement of Fig. 1.11 are available: the angle α which the inclined plane forms with the horizontal, and the coefficient of friction k between the body m1 and the inclined plane. The masses of the pulley and the threads, as well as the friction in the pulley, are negligible. Assuming both bodies to be motionless at the initial moment, find the mass ratio m2/m1 at which the body m2 (a) starts coming down; (b) starts going up; (c) is at rest.
Interpretation. The arrangement in the figure has an inclined plane at angle α with the horizontal, and the coefficient of friction between the body m₁ and the plane is k. The masses of the pulley and the threads are negligible, and the friction in the pulley is negligible. Assuming both bodies are at rest at the start, find the mass ratio m₂/m₁ at which the body m₂ (a) starts coming down, (b) starts going up, (c) is at rest.
We assume α = 30° and k = 0.10 to start. The problem uses letters only, and these are the values of the next problem. Both are sliders.
We assume g = 9.8 m/s² and m₁ = 3 kg. They only set the forces in newtons and the speed of the motion on screen. The thresholds depend only on the ratio. Both are sliders.
We assume the thread stays tight, and static friction has the same limit k as sliding friction.
Symbols: η = m₂/m₁, T is the thread tension, w is the acceleration of m₂, and f is friction on m₁.
The big idea in plain words
Two forces fight over m₁. The thread pulls it up the slope with a force up to m₂g. Gravity pulls it down the slope with m₁g sin α. Friction is a referee: it can add up to k m₁g cos α on whichever side is losing.
Nothing moves until one side beats the other by more than the friction limit. That gives a band of mass ratios where everything stays still, and two edges where motion starts. The edges sit at sin α ± k cos α. If friction is large enough, the lower edge falls below zero. Then m₁ can never slide down, even with no m₂ at all.
The solution in each frame
Only the ground frame is used. It is an inertial frame, so Newton's second law holds as written. A frame moving with m₁ would need a pseudo-force and give the same thresholds with more writing, so it adds nothing here.
The solution step by step
Step 1, at the first instant. Nothing moves yet, so the thread tension equals the weight of m₂: T = m₂g. The normal force on m₁ is N = m₁g cos α, so friction cannot exceed k m₁g cos α.
Step 2, part (a). m₂ comes down and m₁ goes up the slope if the pull up the slope beats gravity plus the friction limit: m₂g > m₁g sin α + k m₁g cos α. Divide by m₁g: η > sin α + k cos α = 0.5 + 0.1 × 0.866 = 0.5866.
Step 3, part (b). m₂ goes up and m₁ slides down if gravity on m₁ beats the thread by more than the friction limit: m₁g sin α − m₂g > k m₁g cos α. So η < sin α − k cos α = 0.4134. If this number is zero or negative, case (b) never happens.
Step 4, part (c). Between the two limits, 0.4134 < η < 0.5866, neither inequality holds, so everything stays at rest. Friction then adjusts: f = (m₂ − m₁ sin α) g, which is below the limit.
Step 5, what happens once motion starts. For η above the upper limit, the two equations m₂g − T = m₂w and T − m₁g sin α − k m₁g cos α = m₁w give w = g (η − sin α − k cos α)/(1 + η). Below the lower limit, m₂ goes up with a = g (sin α − k cos α − η)/(1 + η). At the limits, w = 0, so the motion starts smoothly. Now: m₂ comes down, w = 0.4726 m/s², T = 18.66 N.
When the system moves, a separate calculation solves the two Newton equations as a 2 × 2 system and steps the motion in 3000 small steps for 2 s. It gives w = 0.47264253 m/s², T = 18.664042 N and a distance of 0.94528507 m, against 0.94528507 m from ½ w t². The largest relative difference is 6.0 × 10⁻¹⁵. It shows "none" when everything is at rest.
Five methods
1. Force method
The inequalities above. They come straight from comparing the forces at the first instant, so they are the shortest route.
2. Energy method
Let m₁ move a small distance d up the slope. The system gains energy if m₂g d − m₁g sin α d − k m₁g cos α d > 0. Dividing by m₁g d gives the same inequality as part (a). It is Newton's law in energy form, and it also needs the friction limit.
3. Graph method
The left graph shows w/g against η. It is zero in a flat band, then rises on the right (m₂ down) and falls below zero on the left (m₂ up). The edges of the flat band are the answers. The right graph shows friction: a sloping line inside the band, flat at ±k outside it.
4. Calculus method
Treat the two bodies as one system with a net driving force F(η) = m₂g − m₁g sin α along the thread. Friction can cancel F as long as |F| ≤ k m₁g cos α. The boundary values of F give the same two limits.
5. Check method
Units: η is a ratio of masses, and sin α, k cos α have no units. Limits: with k = 0 both edges meet at sin α, so there is no rest band and m₂ balances m₁ only at η = sin α. With α = 90°, m₁ hangs freely, and the band is at η = 1. With k large, the lower edge becomes negative.
Fastest: the force method. Most reliable: the force method followed by the check method, by putting a value of η just inside each edge.
What each slider changes
| Control | Changes the answer? | What it changes |
|---|---|---|
| Angle α | Yes | Both thresholds, the regime, w, T, friction, the drawing and the graphs |
| Friction k | Yes | Both thresholds, the width of the rest band, w, friction and the graphs |
| Ratio η | Yes | w, T, friction and the drawing, inside the chosen case only |
| Mass m₁ | No | The forces in newtons and the speed of the motion on screen. Not the thresholds |
| Gravity g | No | w, the forces in newtons and the motion on screen. Not the thresholds |
| Given-answer mode | Sets η | The page finds the ratio that gives the chosen acceleration |
| Case buttons a, b, c | Yes | Which case is simulated. The η slider then moves only inside that case |
| Play and Pause | No | In cases a and b, they start and stop the real-time motion, which repeats with a 1.2 s pause. In case c, Play sweeps η across the rest band, with 1.2 s holds at the two edges |
Parameters
| Quantity | Symbol | Value used |
|---|---|---|
| Angle of the plane | α | 30° |
| Friction coefficient | k | 0.1 |
| Mass ratio | η | 0.667 |
| Block mass, hanging mass | m₁, m₂ | 3 kg, 2 kg |
| Gravity | g | 9.8 m/s² |
| Upper limit | sin α + k cos α | 0.5866 |
| Lower limit | sin α − k cos α | 0.4134 |
| Acceleration of m₂ | w | 0.4726 m/s² |
| Tension | T | 18.66 N |
| Friction on m₁ | f | 2.55 N |
Exam traps
- Using the limit k m₁g cos α for the rest case. At rest friction only balances the forces and is usually smaller than its limit.
- Getting the sign of friction wrong. When m₂ comes down, friction on m₁ points down the slope. When m₂ goes up, it points up the slope.
- Writing η > sin α for case (a). That would be true only for a smooth plane. Friction shifts the edge up by k cos α.
- Forgetting that case (b) can be impossible. If k ≥ tan α, then sin α − k cos α is zero or negative, and m₁ will not slide down.
- Dropping the g in m₂g − m₁g sin α and then mixing units. Each force has the form (mass) × g.