Irodov, Problem 1.70

A horizontal plane with the coefficient of friction k supports two bodies: a bar and an electric motor with a battery on a block. A thread attached to the bar is wound on the shaft of the electric motor. The distance between the bar and the electric motor is equal to l. When the motor is switched on, the bar, whose mass is twice as great as that of the other body, starts moving with a constant acceleration w. How soon will the bodies collide?

Time t 0.0 s
The answer in one line

The bodies collide after t = √(2l/(3w + k g)). With the numbers on screen, t = s. The motor block moves with the acceleration w′ = 2w + k g = m/s², which is more than the bar's w.

Problem statement

Problem 1.70. A horizontal plane with the coefficient of friction k supports two bodies: a bar and an electric motor with a battery on a block. A thread attached to the bar is wound on the shaft of the electric motor. The distance between the bar and the electric motor is equal to l. When the motor is switched on, the bar, whose mass is twice as great as that of the other body, starts moving with a constant acceleration w. How soon will the bodies collide?

We assume k = 0.2, l = 2 m and w = 0.5 m/s² to start. The problem uses letters only. All three are sliders.

We assume g = 9.8 m/s² and a mass unit m = 1 kg, so the bar has 2 kg and the motor block 1 kg. The mass only sets the forces in newtons, and the time does not depend on it. Both are sliders.

We assume the thread is wound on the shaft of the motor, stays straight and tight, and has no mass. The bar moves towards the motor block and the motor block moves towards the bar.

Symbols: T is the tension of the thread, w the acceleration of the bar, w′ the acceleration of the motor block, and t the time to collision.

The big idea in plain words

The motor pulls the thread in, so the thread pulls on both bodies with the same force. The bar is heavier, so it gets less acceleration. The motor block is lighter, so it gets more, and it also has less friction to fight. Both move towards each other.

The gap closes at a growing rate. Because both accelerations are constant, the gap shrinks as one body would if it stood still and the other approached it with the combined acceleration w + w′.

Interactive derivation

The solution in each frame

Newton's second law is written in the ground frame, which is inertial. The collision time then comes from the relative motion. A frame fixed to the bar would be accelerating, and so would need a pseudo-force, but for the kinematics alone it gives the same result: in it the motor block approaches with the relative acceleration w + w′. So the frames agree.

The solution step by step

Step 1, the bar. Take the direction towards the motor as positive. The thread pulls the bar with T and friction 2k m g opposes the motion. So T − 2k m g = 2m w, and T = 2m(w + k g) = N.

Step 2, the motor block. The thread pulls the motor block towards the bar with the same T. Its friction is k m g. So T − k m g = m w′.

Step 3, eliminate T. Put T from step 1: m w′ = 2m(w + k g) − k m g = 2m w + k m g. So w′ = 2w + k g = m/s².

Step 4, kinematics. The bar moves x₁ = ½ w t² and the motor block moves x₂ = ½ w′ t². They meet when x₁ + x₂ = l: l = ½(w + w′)t² = ½(3w + k g)t².

Step 5, the time. t = √(2l/(3w + k g)) = √(2 × /(3 × + )) = s. At that moment the bar has moved m and the motor block m, which add up to l.

Step 6, does the motor block really move? Its friction can be at most k m g, and the tension is T = 2m(w + k g), which is bigger than k m g for every w > 0. So the motor block does move.

Numerical check

A separate calculation takes the bar's acceleration w, finds T from the bar's equation, finds the motor block's acceleration from its own equation, and steps both bodies forward in 200000 small time steps until the gap closes. It gives t = s, against s from the formula. It also checks that T from the two equations is the same. The largest relative difference is .

Five methods

1. Force method

Newton's second law for each body, then the same tension in both equations. This is steps 1 to 3.

2. Energy method

The motor does work on the thread and friction takes some of it, but the motor's own power is not given. The energy method needs more data than we have, so it adds nothing here.

3. Graph method

Plot the gap against time. It is a parabola l − ½(3w + k g)t², and the collision is where it reaches zero. The graphs on screen show this and the constant accelerations.

4. Algebraic method (suvat)

Each acceleration is constant and both bodies start from rest, so use s = ½At² for each. This gives x₁ and x₂ as above. The sum of the distances is l at the collision.

5. Check method

Units: k g and w are both in m/s², so 2l/(3w + k g) is in s². Limits: for k = 0, w′ = 2w and t = √(2l/(3w)). This matches the result from conservation of momentum, since the bar (2m) with w and the motor block (m) with 2w have equal and opposite momentum changes. For a very strong motor (w large), t = √(2l/(3w)) becomes small, as expected.

Fastest: the force method with the relative acceleration. Most reliable: the force method followed by the numerical check.

What each slider changes

ControlChanges the answer?What it changes
Acceleration of the bar wYesw′, T, the collision time, both positions, the arrows and every curve
Friction kYesw′, T, the friction arrows, the collision time and the curves
Distance lYesThe gap in the picture, the collision time and the curves
Mass unit mNoOnly the forces in newtons. Not the time
Gravity gYesw′, T, the friction arrows and the collision time
Given-answer modeSets wThe page finds the acceleration for a chosen collision time, and warns if it is out of range
Play and time barNoPlay runs the motion at half speed, holds 1.2 s at the collision, then repeats. The bar sets the time

Parameters

QuantitySymbolValue used
Acceleration of the barw m/s²
Friction coefficientk
Starting distancel m
Mass unitm kg
Gravityg m/s²
Acceleration of the motor blockw′ m/s²
TensionT N
Frictions on the bar and the motor2k m g, k m g N, N
Time to collisiont s

Exam traps

  • Giving the motor block the same acceleration as the bar. The two have different masses and different friction, so w′ is not w.
  • Forgetting that the thread is wound on the motor, so the same tension acts on both bodies, in opposite directions.
  • Using the friction k m g for the bar. The bar has mass 2m, so its friction is 2k m g.
  • Adding the distances wrongly. The bodies meet when the sum of the two distances is l, not when one body has gone the whole distance l.
  • Writing t = √(2l/w). That would be right only if the motor block did not move at all.