Irodov, Problem 1.71

Find the acceleration w of body 2 in the arrangement shown in Fig. 1.15, if its mass is η times as great as the mass of bar 1 and the angle that the inclined plane forms with the horizontal is equal to α. The masses of the pulleys and the threads, as well as the friction, are assumed to be negligible. Look into possible cases.

Time t 0.0 s
The answer in one line

w = 2g(2η − sin α)/(4η + 1), taken as positive downwards. With the numbers on screen, w = m/s², so body 2 moves . Body 2 goes down if 2η > sin α, stays still if 2η = sin α, and goes up if 2η < sin α.

Problem statement

Problem 1.71. Find the acceleration w of body 2 in the arrangement shown in Fig. 1.15, if its mass is η times as great as the mass of bar 1 and the angle that the inclined plane forms with the horizontal is equal to α. The masses of the pulleys and the threads, as well as the friction, are assumed to be negligible. Look into possible cases.

Interpretation. Find the acceleration w of body 2 in the arrangement shown, if its mass is η times as great as the mass of bar 1 and the angle that the inclined plane forms with the horizontal is α. The masses of the pulleys and the threads, as well as the friction, are negligible. Look into the possible cases.

We assume η = 1 and α = 30° to start. The problem uses letters only. Both are sliders, and the case buttons a, b and c set η for each case.

We assume g = 9.8 m/s² and m₁ = 1 kg. The mass only sets the forces in newtons. The acceleration does not depend on it. Both are sliders.

We assume the first thread runs from the bar over a fixed pulley to a moving pulley. A second thread is tied to the wall, runs over the moving pulley and holds body 2. The threads stay tight and do not stretch.

Symbols: m₁ is the mass of bar 1, m₂ = ηm₁ the mass of body 2, T₁ the tension in the thread on the bar, T₂ the tension in the thread on body 2, w₁ the acceleration of the bar up the slope, and w the acceleration of body 2 downwards.

The big idea in plain words

Two things pull on the moving pulley: the thread from the bar pulls it up, and the thread holding body 2 pulls it down twice, once on each side of the pulley. The pulley has no mass, so the upward pull must equal the downward pulls: T₁ = 2T₂.

The same thread passes round the moving pulley, so when the pulley moves down by a distance s, body 2 moves down by 2s. So body 2 always accelerates twice as fast as the bar. This is the trade-off of a moving pulley: half the force, twice the distance.

Interactive derivation

The solution in each frame

Only the ground frame is needed. It is inertial, and all the forces are real. A frame fixed to the moving pulley would accelerate and would need a pseudo-force, which adds work and nothing else.

The solution step by step

Step 1, the bar. Take up the slope as positive. The thread pulls the bar up with T₁. Gravity pulls it down the slope with m₁g sin α. So T₁ − m₁g sin α = m₁w₁.

Step 2, body 2. Take down as positive. Gravity pulls it down with m₂g and the thread pulls it up with T₂. So m₂g − T₂ = m₂w.

Step 3, the moving pulley. It has no mass, so the net force on it is zero even when it accelerates: T₁ − 2T₂ = 0.

Step 4, the thread length. The second thread has a fixed length. If the pulley moves down by s, body 2 moves down by 2s, and the bar moves up the slope by s. So w = 2w₁.

Step 5, eliminate. Put T₁ = 2T₂ and w₁ = w/2 into step 1: 2T₂ − m₁g sin α = m₁w/2. Put T₂ = m₂(g − w) from step 2: 2m₂g − 2m₂w − m₁g sin α = m₁w/2. Divide by m₁ and use m₂/m₁ = η: 2ηg − g sin α = w(2η + 1/2). So w = 2g(2η − sin α)/(4η + 1) = m/s².

Step 6, the cases. The sign of w depends only on the sign of 2η − sin α.

  • Case a, η > sin α/2: w is positive. Body 2 goes down and the bar goes up the slope. For η > 1 this always holds, since sin α is never above 1.
  • Case b, η = sin α/2: w = 0. Everything stays still. For α = ° this needs η = .
  • Case c, η < sin α/2: w is negative. Body 2 goes up and the bar slides down the slope.

Step 7, tensions. T₂ = m₂(g − w) = m₁gη(1 + 2 sin α)/(4η + 1) = N, which is above zero in every case, so the threads stay tight. T₁ = 2T₂ = N. The bar presses on the slope with N = m₁g cos α = N.

Numerical check

A separate calculation solves the four equations (bar, body 2, pulley, thread length) as one linear system. It gives w = m/s², against m/s² from the formula. It also steps the pulley forward in 20000 small time steps for one second, using the energy form of the equation of motion, and finds that body 2 moves m, against m from ½wt². The largest relative difference, including T₁, is .

Five methods

1. Force method

Newton's second law for the bar, body 2 and the pulley, plus the thread-length link. This is steps 1 to 5.

2. Energy method

Let the pulley move down by s. Body 2 moves down 2s and the bar moves up s along the slope. The work done is m₂g(2s) − m₁g sin α (s). The kinetic energy is ½m₁(s’)² + ½m₂(2s’)². Setting the power equal gives s” = g(2η − sin α)/(4η + 1), and w = 2s”. This is the same answer, with no tensions needed.

3. Graph method

Plot w/g against η. It is a smooth rise that crosses zero at η = sin α/2 and levels off towards 1 for large η. The first graph shows this, and the dot is the current case.

4. Algebraic method (suvat)

Because w is constant, use the suvat equations from rest: v = wt and distance = ½wt². The speeds graph shows two straight lines, with the bar's slope half that of body 2.

5. Check method

Units: g is in m/s² and η and sin α have no units, so w is in m/s². Limits: for α = 0 the bar is on a flat table and w = 4gη/(4η + 1). For η very large, w goes to g, free fall, as expected. For η very small, w = −2g sin α: the bar slides down freely at g sin α and body 2 goes up at twice that.

Fastest: the energy method, because it skips the tensions. Most reliable: the force method followed by the numerical check, because it also gives the tensions.

What each slider changes

ControlChanges the answer?What it changes
Mass ratio ηYesw, the direction of motion, both tensions, the picture and every curve
Angle αYesThe slope in the picture, w, T₁, N and the curves
Mass m₁NoOnly the forces in newtons. Not the acceleration
Gravity gYesw, w₁ and the forces
Case buttons a, b, cSet ηa: η = 1. b: η = sin α/2. c: η = sin α/4. Moving α keeps the case
Run a, b, cNoPlays the three cases in order
Given-answer modeSets ηThe page finds η for a chosen w, and warns if it is out of range
Play and time barNoPlay runs the motion at half speed, holds 1.2 s at the end, then repeats. The bar sets the time

Parameters

QuantitySymbolValue used
Mass ratioη
Incline angleα°
Mass of bar 1m₁ kg
Mass of body 2m₂ = ηm₁ kg
Gravityg m/s²
Acceleration of body 2 (down +)w m/s²
Acceleration of the bar (up the slope +)w₁ = w/2 m/s²
TensionsT₂, T₁ = 2T₂ N, N
Force of the slope on the barN N

Exam traps

  • Giving body 2 the same acceleration as the bar. It moves twice as far in the same time, so w = 2w₁.
  • Using T₁ = T₂. The moving pulley has two threads pulling down, so T₁ = 2T₂.
  • Writing w = g(2η − sin α)/(4η + 1) and forgetting the factor 2 from w = 2w₁.
  • Assuming body 2 always falls. If η is below sin α/2 it goes up, and w comes out negative.
  • Saying the tension equals the weight m₂g. Body 2 accelerates, so T₂ = m₂(g − w).