In the arrangement shown in Fig. 1.18 the mass of ball 1 is η = 1.8 times as great as that of rod 2. The length of the latter is l = 100 cm. The masses of the pulleys and the threads, as well as the friction, are negligible. The ball is set on the same level as the lower end of the rod and then released. How soon will the ball be opposite the upper end of the rod?
The ball is opposite the upper end of the rod after t = √(2l(η + 4)/(3g(2 − η))). With the numbers on screen, t = s. This only works for η below 2. For η = 2 or more the ball never gets there.
Problem statement
Problem 1.74. In the arrangement shown in Fig. 1.18 the mass of ball 1 is η = 1.8 times as great as that of rod 2. The length of the latter is l = 100 cm. The masses of the pulleys and the threads, as well as the friction, are negligible. The ball is set on the same level as the lower end of the rod and then released. How soon will the ball be opposite the upper end of the rod?
Interpretation. In the arrangement shown, the mass of ball 1 is η = 1.8 times as great as that of rod 2. The length of the rod is l = 100 cm. The masses of the pulleys and the threads, and the friction, are negligible. The ball is set on the same level as the lower end of the rod and then released. How soon will the ball be opposite the upper end of the rod?
We assume g = 9.8 m/s². It is a slider.
We assume the rod has a mass M = 1 kg, so the ball has m = ηM. The mass only sets the forces in newtons, and the time does not depend on it. It is a slider.
We assume the threads stay tight and do not stretch, and the pulley axles have no friction.
Symbols: w₁ is the upward acceleration of the ball, w₂ the downward acceleration of the rod, T the tension in the thread on the ball, and T′ the tension in the thread on the rod.
The big idea in plain words
The thread from the ball holds the moving pulley. The pulley has no mass, so the thread from the ball must pull it up with exactly the force of the two parts of the rod's thread pulling down: T = 2T′. A moving pulley gives half the force and twice the distance.
When the moving pulley goes down by one step, the ball goes up by one step, but the rod goes down by two steps. So the rod always has twice the acceleration of the ball. Since the ball goes up and the rod goes down, they separate with the sum w₁ + w₂, which is 3w₁.
The solution in each frame
Only the ground frame is needed. It is inertial and all the forces are real. A frame fixed to the moving pulley would accelerate and would need pseudo-forces, which adds work and nothing else. The relative climb of the ball on the rod is found from the relative acceleration in step 5.
The solution step by step
Step 1, the thread length. If the moving pulley goes down by s, the thread over the fixed pulley lifts the ball by s. The thread of the rod is tied to a fixed support at one end, so when the pulley goes down by s the rod goes down by 2s. So w₂ = 2w₁.
Step 2, the moving pulley. It has no mass, so the net force on it is zero: T − 2T′ = 0, and T′ = T/2.
Step 3, the ball. Take up as positive. T − mg = m w₁, so T = m(g + w₁).
Step 4, the rod. Take down as positive. Mg − T′ = M w₂. Put in T′ = m(g + w₁)/2 and w₂ = 2w₁: Mg − m(g + w₁)/2 = 2M w₁. So w₁ = (2M − m)g/(m + 4M) = (2 − η)g/(η + 4) = m/s². The rod falls with w₂ = m/s². The tensions are T = N and T′ = N.
Step 5, the time. The ball starts level with the lower end of the rod. It rises with w₁ while the rod falls with w₂, so the ball climbs along the rod with the relative acceleration w₁ + w₂ = 3w₁. It is level with the upper end after a climb of l: l = ½(3w₁)t². So t = √(2l/(3w₁)) = √(2l(η + 4)/(3g(2 − η))) = s.
Step 6, the cases. The sign of w₁ depends on 2 − η.
- Case a, η < 2: w₁ is positive. The ball goes up, the rod goes down, and the ball reaches the upper end after the time above. As η tends to 2 the time grows without limit. As η tends to 0 it tends to √(4l/(3g)) = s, the shortest time possible.
- Case b, η = 2: w₁ = 0. The ball, being twice the rod, holds it still. Nothing moves, so the ball never gets there.
- Case c, η > 2: w₁ is negative. The ball goes down and the rod goes up, so the ball slips further below the lower end. It is never opposite the upper end.
The given η = 1.8 is close to the limit. That is why the time (about 1.4 s) is longer than for a light ball.
A separate calculation solves the four equations (ball, rod, moving pulley and thread length) as one linear system. It gives w₁ = m/s², against m/s² from the formula. When the ball can reach the top, it then lets the ball climb on the rod in 400000 small time steps, and finds that it arrives after s, against s from the formula. The largest relative difference, including T′, is .
Five methods
1. Force method
Newton's second law for the ball and the rod, the pulley rule and the thread length. This is steps 1 to 5.
2. Energy method
The ball rises by s while the rod falls by 2s. The change of energy is m g s up and M g 2s down. The kinetic energy is ½m v² + ½M (2v)². Setting the net gain of kinetic energy equal to the work gives (2M − m)g s = ½(m + 4M)v², so w₁ = (2M − m)g/(m + 4M). This is the same, with no tensions needed.
3. Graph method
The third graph shows the rise of the ball on the rod against time. It is a parabola that meets the line y = l at the time t. For η at or above 2 it never rises to that line.
4. Algebraic method (suvat)
Because w₁ is constant, use s = ½At² with zero starting speed and position to get the rise of the ball on the rod, ½(w₁ + w₂)t².
5. Check method
Units: l/g is in s², so the root is in seconds. Limits: for a very light ball (η = 0) there is no tension in the ball's thread, so the thread over the fixed pulley cannot pull the moving pulley. Then the rod falls freely with w₂ = g, and w₁ = g/2, which is what the formula gives. For η = 2 the formula blows up, as it should.
Fastest: the energy method, because it skips the tensions. Most reliable: the force method followed by the numerical check, because it also gives T and T′.
What each slider changes
| Control | Changes the answer? | What it changes |
|---|---|---|
| Mass ratio η | Yes | w₁, w₂, both tensions, the time (or why there is none), the ball size and every curve |
| Rod length l | Yes | The rod in the picture, the time and the curves |
| Mass M | No | Only the forces in newtons and the sizes of rod and ball. Not the time |
| Gravity g | Yes | w₁, w₂, the forces and the time |
| Case buttons a, b, c | Set η | a: η = 1.8. b: η = 2. c: η = 2.6 |
| Run a, b, c | No | Plays the three cases in order |
| Given-answer mode | Sets η | The page finds η for a chosen time, and warns if the time is too short |
| Play and time bar | No | Play runs the motion at half speed (faster for long times), holds 1.2 s at the end, then repeats. The bar sets the time |
Parameters
| Quantity | Symbol | Value used |
|---|---|---|
| Mass ratio, ball to rod | η | |
| Rod length | l | m |
| Rod mass | M | kg |
| Ball mass | m = ηM | kg |
| Gravity | g | m/s² |
| Accelerations of ball and rod | w₁, w₂ | , m/s² |
| Tensions | T, T′ = T/2 | N, N |
| Time to the upper end | t | s |
Exam traps
- Giving the ball and the rod the same acceleration. The rod always has twice the acceleration of the ball.
- Using T = T′. The moving pulley has two parts of the second thread pulling on it, so T = 2T′.
- Using only w₁ in the climb equation. The ball goes up and the rod goes down, so the relative acceleration is w₁ + w₂ = 3w₁.
- Putting a negative number under the root when η is above 2. In that case the ball goes down and there is no time at which it reaches the upper end.
- Forgetting the weight of the ball when writing the ball's equation. The tension is T = m(g + w₁), not mw₁.