Irodov, Problem 1.75

In the arrangement shown in Fig. 1.19 the mass of body 1 is η = 4.0 times as great as that of body 2. The height h = 20 cm. The masses of the pulleys and the threads, as well as the friction, are negligible. At a certain moment body 2 is released and the arrangement set in motion. What is the maximum height that body 2 will go up to?

Time t 0.0 s
The answer in one line

Body 2 reaches a maximum height H = 2h + v₂²/(2g) = 6ηh/(η + 4). With η = and h = m, H = m. For the given η = 4.0 and h = 20 cm, H = 60 cm.

Problem statement

Problem 1.75. In the arrangement shown in Fig. 1.19 the mass of body 1 is η = 4.0 times as great as that of body 2. The height h = 20 cm. The masses of the pulleys and the threads, as well as the friction, are negligible. At a certain moment body 2 is released and the arrangement set in motion. What is the maximum height that body 2 will go up to?

Interpretation. In the arrangement shown, body 1 has a mass η = 4.0 times that of body 2. Its height above the floor is h = 20 cm. The masses of the pulleys and threads, and the friction, are negligible. At a certain moment body 2 is released and the arrangement starts to move. What maximum height will body 2 reach?

We assume g = 9.8 m/s². The height does not depend on it, but the times and the forces do. It is a slider.

We assume body 2 has a mass of 1 kg. It only sets the forces in newtons. It is a slider.

We assume body 2 starts on the floor and body 1 lands without bouncing, so the thread goes slack at once.

Symbols: w₁ is the downward acceleration of body 1, w₂ the upward acceleration of body 2, T₁ the tension on the moving pulley, T₂ the tension in the thread on body 2.

The big idea in plain words

The motion has two parts. First the thread is tight: body 1 comes down a height h while body 2 goes up twice as far, with constant accelerations. Then body 1 lands. The thread goes slack and pulls no more. Body 2 is now a free projectile with the speed it had, and it rises further until gravity stops it.

Interactive derivation

The solution in each frame

Only the ground frame is needed. It is inertial, so every force is real. A frame on the moving pulley accelerates and adds pseudo-forces for no gain.

The solution step by step

Step 1, the moving pulley. It has no mass, so the forces on it balance. Two parts of the thread pull it up with T₂ each, and body 1 pulls it down with T₁. So T₁ = 2T₂.

Step 2, the thread length. If body 1 goes down by s, both sides of the loop on the moving pulley get s shorter, so body 2 rises by 2s. So w₂ = 2w₁.

Step 3, Newton's law. Body 1, down positive: m₁g − T₁ = m₁w₁. Body 2, up positive: T₂ − m₂g = m₂w₂. Put T₁ = 2T₂ into the first: T₂ = m₁(g − w₁)/2. Then m₁(g − w₁)/2 − m₂g = 2m₂w₁, which gives w₁ = (m₁ − 2m₂)g/(m₁ + 4m₂) = (η − 2)g/(η + 4) = m/s². So w₂ = m/s². The tensions are T₂ = N and T₁ = N.

Step 4, the speed at landing. Body 1 falls h, so body 2 has risen 2h = m. Body 1 lands at t₁ = √(2h/w₁) = s with v₁ = m/s. Body 2 then has v₂ = 2v₁ = m/s, and v₂² = 2w₂(2h) = 8h(η − 2)g/(η + 4).

Step 5, the free flight. The thread is slack, so only gravity acts on body 2. It rises a further h′ = v₂²/(2g) = 4h(η − 2)/(η + 4) = m.

Step 6, the maximum height. H = 2h + h′ = 2h + 4h(η − 2)/(η + 4) = 6ηh/(η + 4). For η = 4 and h = 0.20 m: H = 6 × 4 × 0.20/8 = 0.60 m. The page shows H = m.

Step 7, the cases.

  • Case a, η > 2: w₁ is positive, body 1 comes down and the two-part motion above happens. H lies between 2h (as η tends to 2) and 6h (very heavy body 1, where body 1 falls freely).
  • Case b, η = 2: w₁ = 0. The bodies balance and nothing moves.
  • Case c, η < 2: body 2 is heavier than the pull it gets. Nothing moves, since the floor holds body 2 down. H = 0.
Numerical check

A separate calculation solves the four equations as one linear system and gets w₁ = m/s², against m/s² from the formula. It then steps body 1 down h in 400000 small steps, and flies body 2 up in 200000 small steps. It finds H = m, against m from the formula. The largest relative difference is .

Five methods

1. Force method

Newton's law for each body, the pulley rule and the thread length, then projectile motion. This is steps 1 to 6.

2. Energy method

In phase 1, body 1 loses m₁gh. Body 2 gains m₂g(2h). The rest is kinetic: ½m₁v₁² + ½m₂(2v₁)² = (m₁ − 2m₂)gh. Then body 2 turns its energy ½m₂v₂² into height v₂²/(2g). This gives the same H and skips the tensions.

3. Graph method

The third graph shows both heights against time. Body 2 climbs steadily, then follows a falling parabola to the peak. The first graph shows H/h against η, which levels off at 6.

4. Algebraic method (suvat)

Use the suvat equations with the constant w₁ for phase 1, then with −g from the landing speed for phase 2 (v² = u² − 2gs).

5. Check method

Units: h is in metres, so H is in metres. Limits: as η tends to 2, w₁ tends to 0 and H tends to 2h. For a very large η, body 1 falls freely with g, body 2 gets 2g up, v₂² = 4gh, and H = 2h + 4h = 6h. The formula gives 6h as well.

Fastest: the energy method. Most reliable: the force method with the numerical check.

What each slider changes

ControlChanges the answer?What it changes
Mass ratio ηYesw₁, w₂, the tensions, H and every curve
Height hYesThe picture, the landing time and H
Mass of body 2NoOnly the forces in newtons and the box sizes
Gravity gNot Hw₁, w₂, the times and the forces
Case buttons a, b, cSet ηa: η = 4. b: η = 2. c: η = 1
Given-answer modeSets ηThe page finds η for a chosen H and warns if H is below 2h or above 6h
Play and time barNoPlay runs the motion, holds 1.2 s at the top, then repeats. The bar sets the time

Parameters

QuantitySymbolValue used
Mass ratioη
Height of body 1h m
Mass of body 2m₂ kg
Mass of body 1m₁ = ηm₂ kg
Gravityg m/s²
Accelerationsw₁, w₂, m/s²
Speed of body 2 at landingv₂ m/s
Maximum heightH m

Exam traps

  • Stopping at 2h. Body 2 keeps rising after body 1 lands, as a free projectile.
  • Using w₂ = w₁. The moving pulley makes body 2 move twice as far, so w₂ = 2w₁.
  • Using T₁ = T₂. The pulley has two threads pulling on it, so T₁ = 2T₂.
  • Keeping the tension after the landing. The thread is slack, so body 2 has acceleration g down.
  • Forgetting that the 2h climb includes the height body 2 already has when the thread goes slack.