A body of mass m is thrown at an angle α to the horizontal with the initial velocity v0. Find the mean power developed by gravity over the whole time of motion of the body, and the instantaneous power of gravity as a function of time.
The power of gravity at time t is P = mg(gt − v₀ sinα). The mean power over the whole flight is 0 W. It is zero when the body lands at the height it started from.
Problem statement
Problem 1.86. A body of mass m is thrown at an angle α to the horizontal with the initial velocity v0. Find the mean power developed by gravity over the whole time of motion of the body, and the instantaneous power of gravity as a function of time.
Interpretation. A body of mass m is thrown at an angle α to the horizontal with initial speed v₀. Find the power of gravity as a function of time, and the mean power of gravity over the whole time of flight.
We assume there is no air resistance and g = 9.8 m/s². Only gravity acts on the body.
We assume the body lands at the height it was thrown from, as the problem implies. The slider H lets you move the landing point below the start, to see the mean power stop being zero.
We assume m = 0.5 kg, v₀ = 20 m/s and α = 40° as starting values, since the problem gives only symbols. All three are sliders.
The big idea in plain words
Power is how fast a force does work. Gravity pulls straight down, so it only does work when the body moves up or down. When the body rises, gravity pulls against the motion and the power is negative. At the top the body moves sideways only, so the power is zero. When it falls, gravity helps and the power is positive. For a landing at the launch height the rise and the fall cancel exactly.
The solution in each frame
Only the ground frame is needed. Work and power are defined in it, and gravity is the only force.
The solution step by step
Step 1, the velocity. The acceleration is g downward, so the horizontal speed stays v₀ cosα = 15.32 m/s. The upward speed is v₀ sinα − gt, with v₀ sinα = 12.86 m/s.
Step 2, the power at one moment. Power is the force dotted with the velocity. The force is mg downward, so only the vertical speed counts: P = −mg(v₀ sinα − gt) = mg(gt − v₀ sinα). With the numbers, P = 4.9 × (9.8t − 12.86) W.
Step 3, the sign. P is negative until t = v₀ sinα/g = 1.31 s, the top of the flight. It is zero there and positive afterwards.
Step 4, the mean power. The mean power is the work of gravity divided by the flight time T = 2.624 s. Gravity is constant, so its work is mg dotted with the displacement. For a landing at launch height the displacement is horizontal, so the dot product is zero. The mean power is 0.
Step 5, the same from the formula. P is a straight line in t. Its mean over [0, T] is its value at the middle time T/2. For T = 2v₀ sinα/g, the middle time is v₀ sinα/g, where P = 0. The mean is 0 again.
Step 6, landing lower. If the body lands H below the start, the work is mgH and the mean power is mgH/T. With the slider values this is 0 W. The mean over the rise is −31.5 W and over the fall 31.5 W.
A separate calculation follows the flight in 20 microsecond steps. It adds up mg times the small vertical move at each step, then divides by the time. It gets a flight time of 2.6236 s and a mean power of 4.1065 × 10⁻⁴ W, against 2.624 s and 0 W from the formulas. It also gets the landing speed 20 m/s, against 20 m/s. The largest relative difference is 6.5 × 10⁻⁶.
Five methods
1. Force method
Take P = F · v with F = mg downward. This is steps 1 to 3.
2. Energy method
The work of gravity equals minus the change of potential energy. Landing at the launch height means no change, so the work and the mean power are zero. For landing H lower the work is mgH.
3. Graph method
P against t is a straight line. The negative area while rising equals the positive area while falling. The two triangles have the same size, so the total area, which is the work, is zero.
4. Calculus method
The work is ∫P dt from 0 to T = mg[gt²/2 − v₀ sinα t] from 0 to T. At T = 2v₀ sinα/g this is zero.
5. Check method
Units: mg × speed is newtons times metres per second, which is watts. Limits: at t = 0 the power is −mgv₀ sinα. At the landing it is +mgv₀ sinα. For α = 0 the body starts at its top and the power is zero at t = 0.
Fastest: the energy method. Most reliable: the force method with the numerical check.
What each slider changes
| Control | Changes the answer? | What it changes |
|---|---|---|
| Mass m | Yes | The size of the power in watts and the energies. Not the path or the time |
| Launch speed v₀ | Yes | The path, the flight time and the power line |
| Launch angle α | Yes | The path, the flight time and the power line |
| Landing depth H | Yes | The flight time and the mean power, which is zero only for H = 0 |
| Given-answer mode | Sets H | The page finds H for a chosen mean power, and warns if it is above the largest shown |
| Play and time bar | No | Play runs the flight in slow motion, holds 1.2 s, then repeats |
Parameters
| Quantity | Symbol | Value used |
|---|---|---|
| Mass | m | 0.5 kg |
| Launch speed | v₀ | 20 m/s |
| Launch angle | α | 40° |
| Landing below the start | H | 0 m |
| Time of flight | T | 2.624 s |
| Time to the top | v₀ sinα/g | 1.31 s |
| Greatest height above the start | 8.43 m | |
| Range | 40.2 m | |
| Mean power | 0 W |
Exam traps
- Writing P = mg v with the full speed. Only the part of the velocity along gravity counts.
- Getting the sign wrong. Gravity does negative work while the body rises.
- Saying the mean power is mg times the mean speed. The mean vertical velocity over the flight is zero.
- Forgetting that the answer is zero only for a landing at the launch height. A lower landing gives mgH/T.
- Confusing zero mean power with zero power. The power at each moment is not zero, only its average.