Irodov, Problem 2.25

Making use of the result obtained in the foregoing problem, find at what temperature the isothermal compressibility κ of a Van der Waals gas is greater than that of an ideal gas. Examine the case when the molar volume is much greater than the parameter b.

Time t 0.0 s
The answer in one line

The Van der Waals gas is more compressible than the ideal gas when T < 2a(V − b)²/(R b V (2V − b)). When V is much larger than b this becomes T < a/(bR). With the numbers on screen (V = l, a = , b = ): the exact limit is K and a/(bR) = K.

Problem statement

Problem 2.25. Making use of the result obtained in the foregoing problem, find at what temperature the isothermal compressibility κ of a Van der Waals gas is greater than that of an ideal gas. Examine the case when the molar volume is much greater than the parameter b.

Interpretation. Use the compressibility from the last problem and compare it with the ideal-gas value V/(RT) at the same V and T. Find the temperatures where the Van der Waals value is the larger one. Then simplify the answer for a thin gas, where the molar volume is much larger than the constant b.

Interpretation, what the molecules do as T rises. Squeeze the gas and it pushes back. For an ideal gas the push-back (the stiffness) is RT/V, and κ is its inverse. A real gas changes this in two ways. The molecules have size, so the free room is V − b and the gas becomes stiffer. This extra stiffness grows in proportion to T, because faster molecules hit harder. The molecules also pull on each other, and the pull grows as they come closer. This helps the squeeze, so the gas becomes softer by 2a/V². Speed does not change this pull, so it is the same at every T. At low T the pull is the bigger effect, so κ is above the ideal value. At high T the size effect takes over, so κ is below it. The change over is the temperature asked for. For V much larger than b it is a/(bR).

We assume R = 0.08206 l atm/(mol K), V = 1 l, and the nitrogen constants a = 1.35 l² atm/mol² and b = 0.039 l/mol, only to draw numbers. The result holds for any gas. V, a and b are sliders.

Symbols: κ is the compressibility of the Van der Waals gas, κ0 = V/(RT) that of the ideal gas, V the molar volume, a and b the Van der Waals constants.

The big idea in plain words

The attraction between molecules (a) makes the gas easier to squeeze. The size of the molecules (b) makes it harder. At low temperature the molecules move slowly, and the attraction wins, so the gas is more compressible than an ideal one. At high temperature the molecules move fast, the attraction matters little, and the size wins, so the gas is less compressible. The question is where the two effects cancel.

Interactive derivation

What the molecules do as the temperature rises

TemperatureWhat the molecules doWhat it does to κ
Low TSlow molecules spend time near each other, and the pull helps the squeezeSofter gas. κ is above the ideal value
At the limitExtra stiffness from size equals the softening from pullκ equals the ideal value V/(RT)
High TFast molecules hit hard, and the free room V − b makes each hit count for more. The pull is the same as beforeStiffer gas. κ is below the ideal value

Equating the two effects gives the limit: RT[V/(V−b)² − 1/V] = 2a/V². For V much larger than b the bracket becomes about b/V² × 2, which gives T = a/(bR).

The solution in each frame

The gas is at rest, so only one frame is needed.

The solution step by step

Step 1, the ratio. From the last problem, κ = V²(V − b)²/[RTV³ − 2a(V − b)²]. For the ideal gas, p = RT/V gives κ0 = V/(RT). Dividing: κ/κ0 = (1 − b/V)² / [1 − 2a(V − b)²/(RTV³)].

Step 2, the condition. The bottom bracket must be positive, otherwise the gas is unstable and has no compressibility. Then κ > κ0 means (1 − b/V)² > 1 − 2a(V − b)²/(RTV³). The left side is 1 − 2b/V + b²/V². Move 1 across: 2a(V − b)²/(RTV³) > 2b/V − b²/V² = b(2V − b)/V².

Step 3, solve for T. T < 2a(V − b)²/(R b V (2V − b)) = K for the numbers on screen.

Step 4, the thin gas, V much larger than b. Then (V − b)² is about V² and 2V − b is about 2V, so T < 2aV²/(R b V × 2V) = a/(bR) = K. Above this temperature the size of the molecules wins and the gas is less compressible than an ideal one.

Step 5, the cases. Two cases are asked for. The exact condition holds at any V above b. The simple condition T < a/(bR) holds when V is much larger than b. The exact limit is always below a/(bR) in this case, and approaches it as V grows. Also, T must exceed 2a(V − b)²/(RV³) for the gas to be stable. Between these two limits the gas is stable and more compressible than ideal.

Numerical check

A separate calculation does not use the formula for the limit. It halves a temperature interval repeatedly until the compressibility from the last problem equals V/(RT). The relative difference from the exact limit is .

Five methods

1. Force method

Attraction pulls molecules together, so less push is needed to squeeze the gas. The size of molecules makes them resist crowding. The first effect falls with temperature (as 1/T), the second does not, so there is one crossing point.

2. Energy method

The attraction energy a/V is fixed. The thermal energy RT grows with T. When RT is large, the attraction is a small correction and the size effect decides.

3. Graph method

The first graph shows the ratio κ/κ0 against T. It is above 1 for temperatures below the upper limit and falls below 1 above it. The second graph shows the limits against V.

4. Calculus method

For small a and b, κ/κ0 is about 1 − 2b/V + 2a/(RTV). It is above 1 when a/(RT) > b, which is T < a/(bR).

5. Check method

Units: a/(bR) is (l² atm/mol²)/((l/mol)(l atm/(mol K))) = K. The limit a/(bR) is the same as the Boyle temperature, where the gas behaves ideally over a range of pressures. As a → 0 the limit goes to 0, so a gas with no attraction is never more compressible than an ideal gas.

Fastest: the expansion for small a and b. Most reliable: the exact condition with the numerical check.

What each slider changes

ControlChanges the answer?What it changes
Molar volume VYesBoth temperature limits, the ratio curve, the piston and every graph
Constant aYesBoth limits, a/(bR), the ratio curve and every graph
Constant bYesBoth limits, a/(bR), the ratio curve, the molecule size and every graph
Temperature shown TNoThe thermometer, the dots on the graphs, the verdict and the live readings. The limits do not depend on it
Given-answer modeSets bThe page finds the constant b that gives a chosen a/(bR), and warns if b falls outside 0.025 to 0.06
Play and time barNoPlay raises T from 50 K, holds 3 s at the upper limit where κ = κ0, then runs to 800 K and repeats. The bar sets T

Parameters

QuantitySymbolValue used
Molar volumeV l
Constant aa l² atm/mol²
Constant bb l/mol
Exact upper limitT K
Lower limit (stability)T K
Thin gas limita/(bR) K

Exam traps

  • Writing T > a/(bR). The gas is more compressible at low temperature, so T < a/(bR).
  • Comparing at different volumes. Both gases must be at the same V and T.
  • Forgetting the stability condition. Below the lower limit the formula gives a nonsense negative value.
  • Dropping b too early. The step from (V − b)² to V² is allowed only at the end, for V much larger than b.
  • Reading the limit as sharp for every V. The exact limit moves with V and approaches a/(bR) only for a thin gas.