A thin straight rod of length 2a carrying a uniformly distributed charge q is located in a vacuum. Find the magnitude of the electric field strength as a function of the distance r from the rod's centre along the straight line (a) perpendicular to the rod and passing through its centre; (b) coinciding with the rod's direction (at the points lying outside the rod). Investigate the obtained expressions at r >> a.
(a) On the perpendicular through the centre, E = q/(4πε0 r √(r² + a²)). (b) Along the rod, outside it, E = q/(4πε0(r² − a²)). For r much larger than a both become q/(4πε0r²), the field of a point charge. With q = nC and a = cm, at r = 2a = cm: (a) gives kV/m and (b) gives kV/m.
Problem statement
Problem 3.13. A thin straight rod of length 2a carrying a uniformly distributed charge q is located in a vacuum. Find the magnitude of the electric field strength as a function of the distance r from the rod's centre along the straight line (a) perpendicular to the rod and passing through its centre; (b) coinciding with the rod's direction (at the points lying outside the rod). Investigate the obtained expressions at r >> a.
Interpretation. The rod has length 2a and its centre is the origin. Part (a) is the field at a point P on the line that crosses the rod at right angles at its centre, at distance r from the centre. Part (b) is the field at a point P on the line of the rod, beyond its end, again at distance r from the centre, so r is larger than a. Both parts are drawn in one picture.
We assume q = 10 nC and a = 10 cm, because the problem gives no numbers. Both are sliders. The constant 1/(4πε0) is 8.988 × 109 N m²/C².
Symbols: q is the total charge, 2a the length of the rod, λ = q/2a the charge per length, r the distance of P from the centre, s the position of a small piece of the rod measured from the centre.
The big idea in plain words
Cut the rod into many small pieces. Each piece makes a small field at P, like a tiny point charge. Add them all up. On the perpendicular, the sideways parts of the two halves cancel and the parts along r add. Along the rod, every piece pushes the same way, so the fields simply add. Far away the rod looks like a dot.
The solution in each frame
The rod is at rest and nothing moves, so only one frame is needed.
The solution step by step
Step 1, one piece. The charge per length is λ = q/2a. A piece of length ds at position s carries dq = λ ds. Its field at P has size dq/(4πε0r′²), where r′ is the distance from the piece to P.
Step 2, the perpendicular (part a). The piece is at distance r′ = √(r² + s²) from P. The piece at +s and the piece at −s have fields whose parts along the rod cancel. The part along r is dE cos θ with cos θ = r/r′. So E = (λ/4πε0) ∫ r ds/(r² + s²)3/2, from −a to +a. The integral of ds/(r² + s²)3/2 is s/(r²√(r² + s²)), which gives 2a/(r²√(r² + a²)) between the limits. Multiplying by r and by λ = q/2a: E = q/(4πε0 r √(r² + a²)). It points away from the rod when q is positive. In terms of the angle α0 in the picture, sin α0 = a/√(a² + r²), so this is also E = (λ/(4πε0r)) × 2 sin α0, the field of a line charge cut short.
Step 3, along the rod (part b). Now P is on the line of the rod at distance r > a, and the piece at s is at distance r′ = r − s. All pieces push P the same way. E = (λ/4πε0) ∫ ds/(r − s)² from −a to +a = (λ/4πε0)[1/(r − a) − 1/(r + a)] = (λ/4πε0)(2a)/(r² − a²). With λ = q/2a: E = q/(4πε0(r² − a²)). It points away from the rod when q is positive. It grows without limit as r comes down to a, because P then touches the end of the rod.
Step 4, far away (r much larger than a). Then r² + a² is about r² in (a), so E = q/(4πε0r²). In (b), r² − a² is about r², so E = q/(4πε0r²) again. Both are the field of a point charge q. The more exact statement: (a) is smaller than the point-charge field by about a²/(2r²) and (b) is larger by about a²/r².
Step 5, the cases. The two parts are two lines through the same rod. On the perpendicular the formula holds for every r above zero. Along the rod it holds only for r > a. Inside the rod the field along the line is not asked for.
A separate calculation adds the Coulomb fields of 4000 small pieces of the rod. It does this on the perpendicular at r = 0.2a, 1.5a, 3a and 10a, and along the rod at r = 1.5a, 3a and 10a, and compares each result with the formulas. The largest relative difference is .
Five methods
1. Force method
The field is added up piece by piece, as above.
2. Energy method
The potential of the rod could be found first, and the field got from its slope. This is easy along the rod line, where V = (q/(8πε0a)) ln((r + a)/(r − a)) and −dV/dr gives the result of (b). On the perpendicular it is harder, because the slope across the line is needed.
3. Graph method
The first graph shows the field on the perpendicular (a) against r, and the second shows the field along the rod line (b), which only exists for r > a and rises steeply at the rod end. Both have the point-charge field as a violet dashed curve. The third graph divides each field by the point-charge field. The green curve (a) stays below 1 and rises to it. The orange curve (b) starts high and falls to 1. Beyond r = 5a, (a) differs from a point charge by about 2 percent and (b) by about 4 percent.
4. Calculus method
The two integrals in steps 2 and 3. For (a) the integral of ds/(r² + s²)3/2, for (b) the integral of ds/(r − s)².
5. Check method
Units: q/(ε0r²) is C/((C²/(N m²)) m²) = N/C. Limit a → 0: both formulas become q/(4πε0r²). Limit r → a in (b): the field rises without limit, as it should.
Fastest: the two integrals above. Most reliable: the numerical check.
What each slider changes
| Control | Changes the answer? | What it changes |
|---|---|---|
| Charge q | Yes | Both fields, both arrows, the colour of the rod and every graph curve |
| Half-length a | Yes | The rod size, both fields, the angle at P and where part (b) starts |
| Distance r | No | Both points P, the arrows, the dots on the graphs and the live readings |
| Given-answer mode | Sets q | The page finds q for a chosen field at a chosen distance on the perpendicular, and warns if it needs more than 20 nC |
| Play and distance bar | No | Play moves P out from 1 cm to 60 cm, holds 3 s at r = 2a and 3 s at r = 5a (when they fit), then repeats. The bar sets r |
Parameters
| Quantity | Symbol | Value used |
|---|---|---|
| Charge | q | nC |
| Half-length | a | cm |
| Field at r = 2a, perpendicular | E | kV/m |
| Field at r = 2a, along the rod | E | kV/m |
Exam traps
- Using the point-charge formula too close to the rod. It is only good for r much larger than a.
- Using r − a or r + a as if the charge sat at one end. The correct factor is r² − a².
- Forgetting that the rod has length 2a, not a, so λ = q/2a.
- Adding the sideways parts on the perpendicular. They cancel by symmetry.
- Using the formula of part (b) for r < a. It is valid only outside the rod.