Irodov, Problem 3.20

Two point charges q and −q are separated by the distance 2l (Figure). Find the flux of the electric field strength vector across a circle of radius R.

Radius r of the ring being counted 0.0 s
The answer in one line

The flux of E through the circle is Φ = (q/ε0)(1 − l/√(l² + R²)). With q = nC, l = cm and R = cm, Φ = V m, in the direction from the +q side to the −q side.

Problem statement

Problem 3.20. Two point charges q and −q are separated by the distance 2l (Figure). Find the flux of the electric field strength vector across a circle of radius R.

Interpretation. The two charges lie on one straight line, which is the axis of the circle. The circle is flat, perpendicular to that line, and its centre is exactly halfway between the charges. So each charge is a distance l from the plane of the circle. The flux is that of E through the flat disc bounded by the circle.

We assume q = 5 nC, l = 5 cm and R = 10 cm, because the problem gives no numbers. All three are sliders. The constant ε0 is 8.854 × 10−12 F/m. The unit of flux is N m²/C, which equals V m.

Symbols: q is the size of each charge, 2l the distance between them, R the radius of the circle, r the distance of a point of the disc from its centre, d the distance from that point to a charge, Φ the flux.

The big idea in plain words

Each charge sends field lines through the disc, and both push the field the same way, from the +q side to the −q side. At every point the sideways parts cancel and the parts along the axis add. Add up the flux of thin rings of the disc, from the centre to the edge.

Interactive derivation

The solution in each frame

The charges and the circle are at rest, so only one frame is needed.

The solution step by step

Step 1, the field at a point of the disc. The circle is only an imaginary surface, with no charge on it. The only charges are the two point charges on its axis. A point at distance r from the centre is at distance d = √(r² + l²) from each charge. Each charge gives a field of size q/(4πε0d²). That field makes an angle φ with the axis, and cos φ = l/d.

Step 2, add the two fields. The +q charge pushes P away from it, so its field points along the line from +q to P, down and outward. The −q charge pulls P toward it, so its field points along the line from P to −q, down and inward. Both fields have the same size and make the same angle φ with the axis. The parts across the axis are equal and opposite, so they cancel. The parts along the axis both point from the +q side to the −q side, so they add. The normal field is En = 2 (q/(4πε0d²)) (l/d) = q l/(2πε0(r² + l²)3/2). Only this part goes through the circle, because the circle is perpendicular to the axis.

Step 3, one ring. A thin ring between r and r + dr has area 2πr dr. Its flux is dΦ = En 2πr dr = (q l/ε0) r dr/(r² + l²)3/2.

Step 4, add the rings. The integral of r dr/(r² + l²)3/2 from 0 to R is 1/l − 1/√(l² + R²). So Φ = (q/ε0)(1 − l/√(l² + R²)). With the numbers on screen, Φ = V m. One charge alone gives half of this, V m.

Step 5, the cases. If R is much larger than l, the flux tends to q/ε0 = V m: the whole flux of one charge, doubled by the other, spread over an infinite plane, gives q/ε0. If l is much larger than R, the flux is small, about q R²/(2ε0l²). If the area vector is taken the other way, the sign of the flux changes and its size stays the same.

Numerical check

A separate calculation adds the normal fields of both charges on 4000 thin rings of the disc, then adds the flux through the rings. It compares the total with the formula. The relative difference is .

Five methods

1. Force method

Find the field of both charges on the disc, then add the flux through the rings, as above.

2. Energy method

Not suited: flux is a surface integral of the field, not an energy.

3. Graph method

The first graph shows the normal field against r, highest at the centre. The second shows the flux of each ring per cm, which rises, peaks near r = l/√2 and falls. The third shows the flux up to r, which climbs and levels off.

4. Calculus method

The single integral in step 4. It can also be done with the solid angle: one charge at distance l sees the disc under a cone of half angle α, with cos α = l/√(l² + R²), and the flux through it is (q/(2ε0))(1 − cos α).

5. Check method

Units: q/ε0 is C/(C²/(N m²)) = N m²/C. Limits: l → 0 and R → ∞ both give q/ε0; R → 0 gives zero.

Fastest: the solid angle method. Most reliable: the numerical check.

What each slider changes

ControlChanges the answer?What it changes
Charge qYesThe field, the flux, the arrow directions and every curve
Distance lYesThe positions of the charges, the field on the disc, the flux and every curve
Radius RYesThe size of the disc, the flux and the range of every curve
Ring radius rNoThe highlighted ring, the field there, the flux so far and the dots on the graphs
Given-answer modeSets qThe page finds q for a chosen flux, and warns if it needs more than 10 nC
Play and time barNoPlay grows the highlighted ring from the centre to the edge and holds 3 s at r = l (or at R/2 if l is not smaller than R), then repeats. The bar sets r

Parameters

QuantitySymbolValue used
Chargeq nC
Distance of each charge from the circlel cm
RadiusR cm
Total fluxΦ V m

Exam traps

  • Subtracting the two fluxes because the charges have opposite signs. The fields point the same way on the disc, so the fluxes add.
  • Using the full size of E. Only the part along the axis goes through the disc.
  • Taking the distance between the charges as l. It is 2l, and each charge is l from the circle.
  • Forgetting that the flux of one charge through a disc is less than half of q/ε0 unless R is very large.