Irodov, Problem 4.12

The superposition of two harmonic oscillations of the same direction results in the oscillation of a point according to the law x = a cos 2.1t cos 50.0t, where t is expressed in seconds. Find the angular frequencies of the constituent oscillations and the period with which they beat.

Time t 0.0 s
The answer in one line

The constituent oscillations have angular frequencies ω1 = ω + Ω = s−1 and ω2 = ω − Ω = s−1. They beat with period T = π/Ω = s, about 1.5 s for the given numbers.

Problem statement

Problem 4.12. The superposition of two harmonic oscillations of the same direction results in the oscillation of a point according to the law x = a cos 2.1t cos 50.0t, where t is expressed in seconds. Find the angular frequencies of the constituent oscillations and the period with which they beat.

Interpretation. The point moves along one line, so x is its position. The law has a slow factor cos Ωt with Ω = 2.1 s−1 and a fast factor cos ωt with ω = 50.0 s−1. The two constituent oscillations are the two harmonic oscillations that add up to this motion. The beat period is the time between two successive times when the swing of the point is largest.

We assume a = 5 cm, because the problem gives no value for a. It is a slider, and it does not change the frequencies or the beat period. The values Ω = 2.1 s−1 and ω = 50.0 s−1 are the ones in the problem, and they are sliders too.

Symbols: a is the amplitude factor, ω the fast angular frequency, Ω the slow one, ω1 and ω2 the angular frequencies of the constituents, T the beat period.

The big idea in plain words

When two oscillations of nearly the same frequency are added, they sometimes push together and sometimes pull apart. The swing of the sum grows and shrinks again and again. That slow rise and fall is called beating. A product of a slow cosine and a fast cosine is the same thing as a sum of two close frequencies.

Interactive derivation

The solution in each frame

The point moves in one frame and nothing else moves, so only one frame is needed.

The solution step by step

Step 1, split the product. The rule is cos A cos B = ½[cos(A + B) + cos(A − B)]. It follows from adding cos(A + B) = cos A cos B − sin A sin B and cos(A − B) = cos A cos B + sin A sin B. With A = ωt and B = Ωt:

x = a cos Ωt cos ωt = (a/2) cos((ω + Ω)t) + (a/2) cos((ω − Ω)t).

Step 2, read off the frequencies. These are two harmonic oscillations of the same direction, each of amplitude a/2. Their angular frequencies are ω1 = ω + Ω = 50.0 + 2.1 = s−1 and ω2 = ω − Ω = 50.0 − 2.1 = s−1. With the sliders as they are now, the numbers shown are the ones for the sliders.

Step 3, the beat period. Written as x = [a cos Ωt] cos ωt, the point oscillates at the fast frequency ω with a slowly changing swing a|cos Ωt|. The swing is largest when Ωt = nπ. The gap between two such times is T = π/Ω = π/2.1 = s.

Step 4, check with the frequencies. The beat frequency is the difference of the two frequencies, (ω1 − ω2)/(2π) = 2Ω/(2π) = Hz. So the beat period is 2π/(ω1 − ω2) = π/Ω. Both ways give the same number.

Step 5, the cases. The problem has one situation. The fast oscillation itself has period 2π/ω = s, much shorter than the beat period, so the beats are slow and clear. If Ω were not much smaller than ω, the beats would no longer be slow, but the two frequencies would still be ω + Ω and ω − Ω.

Numerical check

A separate calculation takes the motion x(t) over 20 slow periods, 40000 small steps, and measures how much of it oscillates at ω1 and at ω2. Both come out as a/2. The relative difference from a/2 is .

Five methods

1. Force method

Not suited: no force or mass is given. The problem is about adding oscillations.

2. Energy method

Not suited, for the same reason.

3. Graph method

The time graph shows the fast wave inside a slow envelope a|cos Ωt|. The envelope reaches its maxima one beat period apart. The frequency graph shows two bars, at ω + Ω and ω − Ω, each of height a/2.

4. Calculus method

The product to sum rule in step 1, and the condition Ωt = nπ for the maxima of the envelope.

5. Check method

Units: ω and Ω are in s−1, so the periods are in seconds. Limit: when Ω goes to zero the two frequencies join, the beat period becomes very long and the point oscillates at ω with constant swing a.

Fastest: the product to sum rule. Most reliable: the numerical check.

What each slider changes

ControlChanges the answer?What it changes
Amplitude factor aNoThe size of the oscillation, the envelope and the heights of the two frequency bars
Slow factor ΩYesBoth constituent frequencies, the beat period and the shape of the envelope
Fast factor ωYesBoth constituent frequencies and how fast the point really oscillates. It does not change the beat period
Time shownNoWhere the point and the dots are
Given-answer modeSets ΩThe page finds Ω for a chosen beat period, and warns if Ω falls outside 0.5 to 10 s−1
Play and time barNoPlay moves the time from 0 to 4 s at a quarter of real speed and holds 3 s at the first point where the swing is zero. The bar sets the time

Parameters

QuantitySymbolValue used
Amplitude factora cm
Slow factorΩ s−1
Fast factorω s−1
Constituent frequenciesω1, ω2 and s−1
Beat periodT s

Exam traps

  • Giving 2.1 and 50.0 as the two frequencies. They are the slow and fast factors, not the constituents.
  • Forgetting that each constituent has amplitude a/2, not a.
  • Using 2π/Ω as the beat period. The swing a|cos Ωt| repeats every π/Ω, because the cosine changes sign but the swing does not.
  • Confusing the beat period with the period of the fast oscillation, 2π/ω.