Irodov, Problem 4.16

A particle of mass m is located in a unidimensional potential field where the potential energy of the particle depends on the coordinate x as U (x) = U0 (1 − cos αx); U0 and α are constants. Find the period of small oscillations that the particle performs about the equilibrium position.

Time t 0.0 s
The answer in one line

The period of small oscillations is T = 2π√(m/(U0α²)) = (2π/α)√(m/U0). With m = kg, U0 = J and α = m−1, T = s.

Problem statement

Problem 4.16. A particle of mass m is located in a unidimensional potential field where the potential energy of the particle depends on the coordinate x as U (x) = U0 (1 − cos αx); U0 and α are constants. Find the period of small oscillations that the particle performs about the equilibrium position.

Interpretation. The particle moves along the x axis only. Its potential energy U(x) is a cosine curve with many wells, and the equilibrium position asked about is the bottom of the well at x = 0. Small oscillations are those with a swing so small that the force is nearly a straight-line restoring force.

We assume m = 0.5 kg, U0 = 2 J and α = 3 m−1, because the problem gives only symbols. All three are sliders. The page also lets the real swing be large, to show where the small-oscillation answer stops being true. The swing is given as the angle αx in degrees, assumed 10 degrees.

Symbols: m is the mass, U0 and α the constants of the potential, k the spring constant of the small-oscillation model, ω0 the angular frequency and T0 = T the period of small oscillations.

The big idea in plain words

Near the bottom of any smooth well, the potential curve looks like a parabola, and a parabola is the potential of a spring. So a ball near the bottom of the well behaves like a mass on a spring. Find the spring constant from the curvature of the well, and the period follows from the spring formula.

Interactive derivation

The solution in each frame

The particle moves in the lab frame and nothing else moves, so only one frame is needed.

The solution step by step

Step 1, the force and the equilibrium. The force is F = −dU/dx = −U0α sin αx. It is zero at x = 0, and U is smallest there, so x = 0 is a stable equilibrium.

Step 2, small swings. For a small angle, sin αx is nearly αx. The error is under 1 percent for αx below about 14 degrees. So F = −(U0α²) x. This has the form F = −kx with k = U0α² = N/m.

Step 3, the equation of motion. m ẍ = −kx, or ẍ + (k/m) x = 0. This is simple harmonic motion with ω0 = √(k/m) = α√(U0/m) = s−1.

Step 4, the period. T = 2π/ω0 = 2π√(m/(U0α²)) = (2π/α)√(m/U0) = s.

Step 5, the cases. The period does not depend on the swing, as long as the swing is small. For a bigger swing the force is weaker than the spring force, so the real period is longer: the ratio T/T0 is 2K(sin(θ0/2))/π, where θ0 = αx0 is the starting angle and K is the complete elliptic integral. For the swing on screen the real period is s, a ratio of . The equation m ẍ = −U0α sin αx is the same as the equation of a pendulum, with θ = αx.

Numerical check

A separate calculation steps the full equation of motion, with the sine and no small-angle rule, in small steps of time. It times a quarter swing from a very small start, which gives a period of 2π/ω0, and also from the swing on screen, which gives the real period. It compares the two times with the formulas. The largest relative difference is .

Five methods

1. Force method

Steps 1 to 4 above: the force, the spring form, the period.

2. Energy method

Expand U near x = 0: U ≈ ½ U0α²x². Compare with the spring energy ½kx². So k = U0α², the same result. The energy graph on the page shows the potential and the kinetic energy trading places while the total stays fixed.

3. Graph method

The scene shows the cosine curve and the parabola that matches it near the bottom. Near x = 0 they overlap, and far from it they part. The second graph shows how the real period grows with the swing.

4. Calculus method

The curvature of the well, U″(0) = U0α², is the spring constant. Then ω0² = U″(0)/m.

5. Check method

Units: U0 is in joules, α² in m−2, so U0α² is in N/m, the unit of a spring constant. Then m/(U0α²) is in seconds squared. Limits: a deeper well (larger U0) or a narrower well (larger α) gives a stiffer spring and a shorter period.

Fastest: the curvature method. Most reliable: the numerical check.

What each slider changes

ControlChanges the answer?What it changes
Mass mYesω0, the period (it grows with the square root of m) and the speeds
Potential scale U0YesThe height of the potential curve, ω0, the period and the energies
Constant αYesThe width of the wells, ω0 and the period
Swing αxNoHow far the real ball swings, the real period and the gap to the grey ghost. It does not change T0
Phase ω0tNoWhere the ball and the dots are
Given-answer modeSets U0The page finds U0 for a chosen period, and warns if it needs U0 outside 0.5 to 10 J
Play and time barNoPlay runs two small-oscillation periods in about 16 s and holds 3 s after one period. The bar sets the phase

Parameters

QuantitySymbolValue used
Massm kg
Potential scaleU0 J
Constantα m−1
Swingαx0 degrees
Spring constantk N/m
Period of small oscillationsT0 s

Exam traps

  • Using the period of a pendulum formula without checking the force. Here the spring constant is U0α², not mg/L.
  • Forgetting that α has units of 1/length, so αx is a pure number. The α² in k is needed.
  • Using the answer for a large swing. The real period is longer, and the answer holds only for small swings.
  • Mixing up the period 2π/ω0 with the frequency ω0/(2π).