Irodov, Problem 4.17

Solve the foregoing problem if the potential energy has the form U (x) = a/x² − b/x, where a and b are positive constants.

Time t 0.0 s
The answer in one line

The equilibrium is at x0 = 2a/b. The period of small oscillations is T = 2π√(8ma³)/b². With m = kg, a = J m² and b = J m, x0 = m and T = s.

Problem statement

Problem 4.17. Solve the foregoing problem if the potential energy has the form U (x) = a/x² − b/x, where a and b are positive constants.

Interpretation. The foregoing problem asks for the period of small oscillations of a particle of mass m that moves along the x axis in a potential field U(x), about its equilibrium position. Here U(x) = a/x² − b/x, for x > 0. The first term pushes the particle away from x = 0. The second term pulls it towards x = 0 from far away. Together they make one well.

We assume m = 0.5 kg, a = 2 J m² and b = 4 J m, because the problem gives only symbols. All three are sliders. The page also lets the real swing be large, to show where the small-oscillation answer stops being true. The start point is given as a percent of x0, assumed 30 percent below it, so the forces are easy to see. All three particles start there, from rest.

Symbols: m is the mass, a and b the positive constants of the potential, x0 the equilibrium position, k the spring constant of the small-oscillation model, ω0 the angular frequency and T = T0 the period of small oscillations.

The big idea in plain words

Near the bottom of any smooth well, the potential curve looks like a parabola, and a parabola is the potential of a spring. So find the bottom of the well, measure how sharply the curve bends there, and treat that bend as a spring constant. The period then follows from the spring formula.

Interactive derivation

The solution in each frame

The particle moves in the lab frame and nothing else moves, so only one frame is needed.

The solution step by step

Step 1, the equilibrium. The force is F = −dU/dx = −(−2a/x³ + b/x²) = 2a/x³ − b/x². It is zero when 2a/x = b, so x0 = 2a/b = m. There U = −b²/(4a) = J, the lowest value, so the equilibrium is stable.

Step 2, the curvature. The second derivative is U″ = 6a/x⁴ − 2b/x³. At x0 this is (1/x0³)(6a/x0 − 2b). Since a/x0 = b/2, the bracket is 3b − 2b = b. So k = U″(x0) = b/x0³ = b⁴/(8a³) = N/m.

Step 3, the spring model. Near x0, U ≈ U(x0) + ½k(x − x0)². The force is −k(x − x0), so m times the acceleration of the displacement is −k times the displacement. This is simple harmonic motion with ω0 = √(k/m) = √(b⁴/(8a³m)) = s−1.

Step 4, the period. T = 2π/ω0 = 2π√(8ma³)/b² = s.

Step 5, the cases. The well is not symmetric: it rises steeply on the side of small x and slowly on the side of large x. So a big swing does not take the same time as a small one. For the swing on screen the real period is s, a ratio of to T0. The answer T0 is true only for small swings.

Numerical check

A separate calculation finds the equilibrium by bisection on the force, finds the curvature of U by a second difference, and steps the full equation of motion in small steps of time for a very small swing. It compares each with the formulas. The largest relative difference is .

What if the potential were not a well?

The spring model fits only because U(x) is a bowl near x0. The shape of U decides the force (F = −dU/dx) and so the model to use. The page shows all three on one plot, started from the same point.

Shape of UForceModelExamples
ConstantZero everywhereFree particle: constant velocity, x = xs + vt. A particle at rest stays at rest.A spacecraft far from all bodies. A puck on frictionless ice. A charge far from other charges.
Straight line, U = Us − F0(x − xs)Constant, F0Uniform acceleration: a = F0/m and x = xs + ½at² (the suvat equations). It never turns back.A ball near the Earth, U = mgh and F = −mg. A charge between parallel plates.
Parabola, U = ½k(x − x0)²−k(x − x0), grows with distanceSpring: simple harmonic motion, T = 2π√(m/k).A mass on a spring. A marble at the bottom of a bowl.
This well, a/x² − b/x2a/x³ − b/x², changes with x and flips sign at x0Spring only near x0. Far from it the period depends on the swing.The bond between two atoms in a molecule or crystal (Lennard-Jones type).

A straight line is the tangent of the well at the start point. A small piece of any curve looks like a straight line, so a uniform field is the right model for a very short move. A longer move needs the real curve.

Five methods

1. Force method

Steps 1 to 4 above: the zero of the force, the spring form, the period.

2. Energy method

Expand U near x0 to second order. The energy is U(x0) plus ½k(x − x0)² plus the kinetic energy ½m v². This is the energy of a spring, so ω0² = k/m. The energy graph on the page shows the potential and the kinetic energy trading places while the total stays fixed.

3. Graph method

The scene shows the curve U(x) and the parabola that matches it at the bottom. Near x0 they overlap, and far from it they part. The second graph shows the force against position for the well, the uniform field and the free particle.

4. Calculus method

Set U′ = 0 to find x0. Then ω0² = U″(x0)/m.

5. Check method

Units: m a³/b⁴ has units kg J³ m⁶ / (J⁴ m⁴) = kg m²/J = s². So T is in seconds. Limits: a larger b with fixed a makes a deeper and narrower well, a stiffer spring and a shorter period.

Fastest: the calculus method. Most reliable: the numerical check.

What each slider changes

ControlChanges the answer?What it changes
Mass mYesω0, the period (it grows with the square root of m) and the speeds. It does not change the potential curve
Constant aYesThe position of the equilibrium, the depth of the well, k, ω0 and the period
Constant bYesThe position of the equilibrium, the depth of the well, k, ω0 and the period
Start of the real motionNoHow far the real ball swings, the real period and the gap to the grey ghost. It does not change T0
Phase ω0tNoWhere the ball and the dots are
Given-answer modeSets mThe page finds m for a chosen period, and warns if it needs m outside 0.1 to 5 kg
Play and time barNoPlay runs two small-oscillation periods in about 16 s and holds 3 s after one period. The bar sets the phase

Parameters

QuantitySymbolValue used
Massm kg
Constanta J m²
Constantb J m
Start of the real motionε % of x0
Equilibriumx0 m
Spring constantk N/m
Period of small oscillationsT0 s

Exam traps

  • Taking the equilibrium from U = 0 or from the minimum of one term alone. Set the whole slope dU/dx to zero.
  • Forgetting the second derivative. The spring constant is U″ at x0, not U′ or U.
  • Putting x0 into U″ before simplifying. Use a/x0 = b/2 to keep the algebra short.
  • Using the answer for a large swing. The well is lopsided, so the real period changes with the swing.