Irodov, Problem 1.23

A point moves rectilinearly with deceleration whose modulus depends on the velocity v of the particle as w = a√v, where a is a positive constant. At the initial moment the velocity of the point is equal to v0. What distance will it traverse before it stops? What time will it take to cover that distance?

Time t 0.0 s
The answer in one line

The point travels s = 2v0√v0/(3a) before it stops, and the stop takes t = 2√v0/a. With the numbers on screen: s = 12 m and t = 4 s.

Problem statement

Problem 1.23. A point moves rectilinearly with deceleration whose modulus depends on the velocity v of the particle as w = a√v, where a is a positive constant. At the initial moment the velocity of the point is equal to v0. What distance will it traverse before it stops? What time will it take to cover that distance?

Interpretation. The point moves along a straight line in one direction and slows down until its speed is zero. The size of the deceleration is a√v, so it is large when the point is fast and small when it is slow. The distance asked for is the distance from the start to the place where the point stops, and the time is the time to reach that place.

We assume v0 = 9 m/s and a = 1.5 m½/(s√s), because the problem gives no numbers. The unit of a is chosen so that a√v is an acceleration: (m/s²) divided by (m/s)½. Both are sliders.

Symbols: v is the speed, v0 the starting speed, w the size of the deceleration, s the distance to the stop, t the time to the stop.

The big idea in plain words

The harder the point is moving, the harder it is braked. As the speed falls, the braking weakens, so the final part of the stop is very gentle. Even so, the point comes to rest in a finite time, because the square root falls to zero fast enough. If the deceleration were proportional to v instead, the point would creep on for ever and never stop. Two small integrals give the time and the distance.

Interactive derivation

The solution in each frame

Only the ground frame is needed. The point moves along one line and the problem gives its speed in that frame, so there is no second frame in the problem.

The solution step by step

Step 1, the equation. The point slows down, so dv/dt is negative. The size of the deceleration is a√v, so dv/dt = −a√v.

Step 2, the time to stop. Separate the variables: dv/√v = −a dt. Integrate from v0 at t = 0 to v at time t: 2√v − 2√v0 = −at. So √v = √v0 − at/2, which gives v = (√v0 − at/2)². The speed is zero when √v0 = at/2, that is t = 2√v0/a = 4 s.

Step 3, the distance. Write the acceleration as dv/dt = (dv/ds)(ds/dt) = v dv/ds. Then v dv/ds = −a√v, so √v dv = −a ds. Integrate from v0 at s = 0 down to 0 at s: (2/3)v0√v0 = a s. So s = 2v0√v0/(3a) = 12 m.

Step 4, the cases. The problem has one situation, so no cases are needed. One useful result follows from step 2. Halfway through the stopping time, √v is exactly half of √v0, so v = v0/4 = 2.25 m/s. By then the point has covered 7/8 of the distance, 10.5 m. The last half of the time covers only the last eighth of the distance.

Numerical check

A separate calculation does not use the formulas. It solves dv/dt = −a√v on the computer in 200000 small steps and adds up v dt as it goes, until the speed is below 10−10 m/s. It finds that the point stops after t = 4 s and s = 12 m, against 4 s and 12 m from the formulas. At half the stopping time it has covered 10.5 m, against 10.5 m (7/8 of s) from the formula. The largest relative difference is 1.2 × 10⁻¹¹.

Five methods

1. Force method

No mass or force is given, so this method does not apply. The deceleration is given directly as a function of the speed, and the problem is a calculus problem.

2. Energy method

Energy does not help here, since no mass is given.

3. Graph method

The first graph shows v against t. It is a parabola that touches the axis at the stopping time, so the speed goes to zero smoothly. The area under it is the distance. The third graph shows w against t. It is a straight line that falls to zero at the stop, because w = a√v = a(√v0 − at/2).

4. Calculus method

Separate the variables twice, once with t and once with s. These are steps 2 and 3.

5. Check method

Units: a√v must be m/s², so a has the unit m½/(s√s). Then 2√v0/a is in seconds and 2v0√v0/(3a) is in metres. Limits: for a stronger braking constant a, both the time and the distance are smaller. For v0 = 0 there is nothing to stop. Also, the mean speed over the run is s/t = v0/3, which is less than the half of v0 that you would get with constant deceleration.

Fastest: the calculus method with separated variables. Most reliable: the calculus method with the numerical check.

What each slider changes

ControlChanges the answer?What it changes
Initial speed v0YesThe distance, the time, the starting deceleration and every curve
Constant aYesThe distance, the time, the deceleration and every curve
Moment shown tNoThe particle, the arrows, the dots on the graphs and the live readings
Given-answer modeSets aThe page finds a for a chosen stopping distance and warns if a would be outside 0.5 to 3
Play and time barNoPlay runs the motion until it stops, holds 2 s at half the stopping time and 1.5 s at the stop, then repeats. The bar sets the time

Parameters

QuantitySymbolValue used
Initial speedv09 m/s
Constant in w = a√va1.5 m½/(s√s)
Starting decelerationa√v04.5 m/s²
Distance to stops12 m
Time to stopt4 s
Mean speed over the runs/t3 m/s

Exam traps

  • Using the formulas for constant deceleration. The deceleration here falls as the speed falls, so the stop is slower and longer.
  • Forgetting the minus sign. The deceleration makes v smaller, so dv/dt = −a√v. A plus sign gives a point that speeds up.
  • Integrating dv/dt = −a√v with respect to s without using v dv/ds. The distance needs the chain rule step.
  • Mixing up the two integrals: ∫dv/√v gives the time, ∫√v dv gives the distance.
  • Thinking the point never stops, as it would for w proportional to v. With the square root, the stop is reached after a finite time.