Irodov, Problem 1.27

A particle moves in the plane xy with constant acceleration w directed along the negative y axis. The equation of motion of the particle has the form y = ax − bx2, where a and b are positive constants. Find the velocity of the particle at the origin of coordinates.

Time t 0.0 s
The answer in one line

At the origin the velocity has the parts vx = √(w/(2b)) and vy = a√(w/(2b)), so its size is v = √(w(1 + a²)/(2b)). With the numbers on screen: vx = 10 m/s, vy = 10 m/s and v = 14.14 m/s, at 45° above the x axis.

Problem statement

Problem 1.27. A particle moves in the plane xy with constant acceleration w directed along the negative y axis. The equation of motion of the particle has the form y = ax − bx2, where a and b are positive constants. Find the velocity of the particle at the origin of coordinates.

Interpretation. The particle follows the curve y = ax − bx² and the only acceleration it has is a constant w pointing down. Nothing is said about how fast it goes, so that is the unknown. The curve passes through the origin, and the problem asks for the velocity there: its size and its direction.

We assume a = 1 (a number with no unit, the slope of the path at the origin), b = 0.05 1/m and w = 10 m/s², because the problem gives no numbers. The unit of b is 1/m so that bx² is a length. All three are sliders. The particle is shown starting at the origin and moving along the path until it is back at y = 0.

Symbols: w is the constant downward acceleration, vx and vy the velocity parts, v the speed.

The big idea in plain words

The particle moves like a thrown stone: nothing pulls it sideways, and a steady pull acts downward. So its sideways speed vx stays the same. The path is a parabola, and how sharply it bends depends on how fast the particle goes sideways. A fast sideways speed gives a wide, shallow bend. A slow sideways speed gives a tight bend. So the bend b tells us the sideways speed: vx² = w/(2b). Then the slope a at the origin gives the up speed.

Interactive derivation

The solution in each frame

Only the ground frame is needed. The path and the acceleration are given in one frame, and the velocity is asked for in that frame, so there is no second frame.

The solution step by step

Step 1, the x speed is constant. The acceleration points along −y, so it has no x part: dvx/dt = 0 and dvy/dt = −w.

Step 2, differentiate the path once. From y = ax − bx² and dx/dt = vx: vy = dy/dt = a vx − 2bx vx = (a − 2bx)vx.

Step 3, differentiate again. dvy/dt = −2b vx² + (a − 2bx) dvx/dt. The last term is zero because vx is constant. So dvy/dt = −2b vx².

Step 4, find vx. Compare with step 1: −w = −2b vx². So vx² = w/(2b) and vx = √(w/(2b)) = 10 m/s. This is the same at every point of the path.

Step 5, the velocity at the origin. At x = 0 step 2 gives vy = a vx = 10 m/s. The speed is v = √(vx² + vy²) = vx√(1 + a²) = √(w(1 + a²)/(2b)) = 14.14 m/s. The direction is tan φ = vy/vx = a, so φ = 45° above the x axis.

Step 6, the cases. The problem has one situation, so no cases are needed. A useful result follows: the particle comes back to y = 0 at x = a/b = 20 m after t = 2vy/w = 2 s, with the same speed it had at the origin and with vy reversed.

Numerical check

A separate calculation does not use the formula for vx. It launches the particle from the origin with a trial vx and vy = a vx, lets the constant acceleration w act, and looks for the vx that puts the particle on the curve y = ax − bx² at the top of the path. It finds this value by repeated halving of an interval. Then it checks 2000 points along the flight against the curve. The largest relative difference from the formulas is 7.1 × 10⁻¹⁶.

Five methods

1. Force method

No mass or force is given, so this method does not apply. The acceleration w is given directly. The method used is kinematics.

2. Energy method

Energy does not help here, since no mass is given.

3. Graph method

The first graph shows vx as a flat line and vy as a straight line that falls with slope −w. The yellow dot at t = 0 is the answer. The path graph shows the parabola. The third graph shows the height against time, which is also a parabola.

4. Calculus method

Differentiate the path twice and use that vx is constant. These are steps 2 to 4.

5. Check method

Units: w/b is (m/s²)/(1/m) = m²/s², so the square root is in m/s. Another route: write the motion as a thrown stone with x = vxt and y = vyt − wt²/2. Remove t: y = (vy/vx)x − (w/(2vx²))x². Matching with ax − bx² gives a = vy/vx and b = w/(2vx²), the same results.

Fastest: the thrown-stone comparison. Most reliable: the calculus method with the numerical check.

What each slider changes

ControlChanges the answer?What it changes
Constant aYesThe slope at the origin, the path, vy and the speed at the origin. vx does not change
Constant bYesThe bend and size of the path, vx, the speed and the flight time
Acceleration wYesvx, the speed, how fast vy falls and the flight time
Moment shown tNoThe moving point, its arrow, the dots on the graphs and the live readings. The answer at the origin does not change
Given-answer modeSets bThe page finds b for a chosen speed at the origin, and warns if b is outside 0.04 to 0.2
Play and time barNoPlay holds 2 s at the origin showing the answer, then runs the flight, holds 1.5 s at the end and repeats. The bar sets the time

Parameters

QuantitySymbolValue used
Slope at the origina1
Bend of the pathb0.05 1/m
Downward accelerationw10 m/s²
x speedvx10 m/s
y speed at the originvy10 m/s
Speed at the originv14.14 m/s
Flight time2vy/w2 s

Exam traps

  • Treating dx/dt as unknown at every point. It is constant, because there is no force along x. That is what lets us solve for it.
  • Forgetting the second differentiation. The first one gives only vy in terms of vx. The acceleration w enters at the second.
  • Dropping the factor 2 in 2b. The second derivative of bx² gives 2b, so vx² = w/(2b), not w/b.
  • Giving only vx as the answer. The velocity at the origin has both parts, so the speed is vx√(1 + a²).
  • Reading a as an angle. It is the slope tan φ, a plain number.