Irodov, Problem 1.28

A small body is thrown at an angle to the horizontal with the initial velocity v0. Neglecting the air drag, find: (a) the displacement of the body as a function of time r(t); (b) the mean velocity vector ⟨v⟩ averaged over the first t seconds and over the total time of motion.

Time t 0.0 s
The answer in one line

(a) The displacement is r(t) = v0t + gt²/2. (b) The mean velocity over the first t seconds is ⟨v⟩ = v0 + gt/2. Over the whole flight it is ⟨v⟩ = v0 + gτ/2 = v0 cos α along the horizontal. With the numbers on screen: r = (, ) m at t = s, ⟨v⟩ = (, ) m/s over that time, and ⟨v⟩ = 12.86 m/s horizontal over the whole flight of 3.127 s.

Problem statement

Problem 1.28. A small body is thrown at an angle to the horizontal with the initial velocity v0. Neglecting the air drag, find: (a) the displacement of the body as a function of time r(t); (b) the mean velocity vector ⟨v⟩ averaged over the first t seconds and over the total time of motion.

Interpretation. The body is thrown from the origin and only gravity acts on it. Part (a) asks for its displacement from the origin at any time t, as a vector. Part (b) asks for two mean velocities, both vectors: one averaged over the first t seconds, and one averaged over the whole time of motion, which means from the throw until the body lands.

We assume v0 = 20 m/s and an angle of 50° above the horizontal, because the problem gives no numbers. Both are sliders. We also assume that g = 9.8 m/s² and that the body lands at the height it was thrown from. The total time of motion is then τ = 2v0 sin α/g.

Symbols: v0 is the launch velocity, α the launch angle, g the acceleration of gravity (a vector pointing down), r the displacement, ⟨v⟩ the mean velocity, τ the total time of motion.

The big idea in plain words

Gravity pulls the same way all the time, so the acceleration is constant. For constant acceleration the velocity is v0 + gt, and the displacement follows in one line. The mean velocity is the displacement divided by the time, and it equals the velocity at the middle of that time. Over the whole flight, the body goes up and comes down the same distance. So the up and down parts of the mean cancel, and only the sideways speed is left.

Interactive derivation

The solution in each frame

Only the ground frame is needed. The launch velocity is given relative to the ground, and the problem asks for the displacement and the mean velocity in that frame, so there is no second frame.

The solution step by step

Step 1, the velocity. The acceleration g is constant, so v = v0 + gt.

Step 2, the displacement (part a). Add up the velocity over time. The part from v0 gives v0t. The part from gt gives gt²/2. So r(t) = v0t + gt²/2. In parts: x = v0 cos α t = 12.86 t and y = v0 sin α t − gt²/2 = 15.32 t − 4.9t².

Step 3, the mean velocity over the first t seconds (part b). The mean velocity is the displacement divided by the time: ⟨v⟩ = r/t = v0 + gt/2. This is the velocity at the middle of the time, t/2. In parts, the horizontal part is v0 cos α and the vertical part is v0 sin α − gt/2.

Step 4, the mean velocity over the whole flight (part b). The body is back at the launch level when y = 0: v0 sin α − gτ/2 = 0 (apart from the start, t = 0). So τ = 2v0 sin α/g = 3.127 s. Put t = τ into step 3: ⟨v⟩ = v0 + gτ/2. The vertical part is v0 sin α − v0 sin α = 0. So ⟨v⟩ = v0 cos α i = 12.86 m/s, along the horizontal. In vector form, τ = −2(v0·g)/g², and the result is the same.

Step 5, the cases. The problem has one situation, so no cases are needed. At the top of the flight, t = τ/2, the mean over the first half is (v0 cos α, v0 sin α/2). The range is R = 40.2 m, and the highest point is H = 12 m.

Numerical check

A separate calculation does not use the formulas for r or ⟨v⟩. It follows the body in 200000 small steps of time under g. It adds up the position steps, and it finds the mean velocity by adding up v dt and dividing by the time, at t = 1 s, 3 s and at landing. It also checks that the body is back at y = 0 at the landing time. The largest relative difference from the formulas is 1.0 × 10⁻¹¹.

Five methods

1. Force method

The only force is gravity, mg downward, so the acceleration is g. Newton’s second law gives the starting point of the solution, and then the kinematics of constant acceleration does the rest.

2. Energy method

Energy conservation shows that the body lands with the same speed v0 it had at launch. That gives the vertical speed at landing as −v0 sin α, which is the key fact in the mean over the whole flight.

3. Graph method

The first graph shows vx flat and vy falling in a straight line. The mean of a straight line over an interval is its value in the middle. The second graph shows ⟨vy⟩ falling at half the rate and reaching 0 at landing. The third graph shows x and y against time.

4. Calculus method

Integrate the acceleration twice, then divide by the time. These are steps 1 to 3.

5. Check method

Units: gt/2 is m/s, so v0 + gt/2 is a velocity. Limits: for t going to 0, ⟨v⟩ goes to v0. For g = 0 the mean velocity is v0 at any time. Over the whole flight, R/τ = v0 cos α, which agrees with the vector answer.

Fastest: the formula ⟨v⟩ = velocity at the middle of the time. Most reliable: the calculus method with the numerical check.

What each slider changes

ControlChanges the answer?What it changes
Launch speed v0YesThe velocity parts, the flight time, range, height, both mean velocities and the picture scale
Launch angle αYesThe same quantities and the shape of the path
Moment shown tSets the first meanThe point, r, the mean velocity over the first t seconds, the dots on the graphs and the live readings. The mean over the whole flight does not depend on it
Given-answer modeSets αThe page finds the angle for a chosen mean velocity over the flight, and warns if the angle is outside 10° to 80°
Play and time barNoPlay runs from launch to landing, holds 2 s at the top and 1.5 s at landing, then repeats. The bar sets the time

Parameters

QuantitySymbolValue used
Launch speedv020 m/s
Launch angleα50°
Horizontal velocityv0 cos α12.86 m/s
Starting vertical velocityv0 sin α15.32 m/s
Total time of motionτ3.127 s
RangeR40.2 m
Greatest heightH12 m

Exam traps

  • Writing r = v0t only. Gravity adds the term gt²/2, a vector pointing down.
  • Using the mean of v0 and the final speed as numbers. The mean velocity is a vector: its parts must be averaged separately.
  • Giving the mean speed instead of the mean velocity. The mean speed over the flight is larger than v0 cos α, since the path is longer than the range.
  • Saying the mean velocity over the whole flight is zero. Only its vertical part is zero. The body does move sideways.
  • Forgetting the assumption of a level landing. The result v0 cos α is for a body that lands at the height it was thrown from.