Irodov, Problem 1.29

A body is thrown from the surface of the Earth at an angle α to the horizontal with the initial velocity v0. Assuming the air drag to be negligible, find: (a) the time of motion; (b) the maximum height of ascent and the horizontal range; at what value of the angle α they will be equal to each other; (c) the equation of trajectory y(x), where y and x are displacements of the body along the vertical and the horizontal respectively; (d) the curvature radii of trajectory at its initial point and at its peak.

Time t 0.0 s
The answer in one line

(a) The time of motion is τ = 2v0 sin α/g. (b) The greatest height is H = v0² sin²α/(2g) and the range is R = v0² sin 2α/g. They are equal when tan α = 4, that is α = 75.96°. (c) The trajectory is y = x tan α − gx²/(2v0² cos²α). (d) The radius of curvature is v0²/(g cos α) at the start and v0² cos²α/g at the top. With the numbers on screen: τ = 3.535 s, H = 15.31 m, R = 35.35 m, and the radii are 81.63 m and 10.2 m.

Problem statement

Problem 1.29. A body is thrown from the surface of the Earth at an angle α to the horizontal with the initial velocity v0. Assuming the air drag to be negligible, find: (a) the time of motion; (b) the maximum height of ascent and the horizontal range; at what value of the angle α they will be equal to each other; (c) the equation of trajectory y(x), where y and x are displacements of the body along the vertical and the horizontal respectively; (d) the curvature radii of trajectory at its initial point and at its peak.

Interpretation. The body is thrown from the ground and lands on level ground again. Part (a) is the total time in the air. Part (b) asks for the highest point and the distance along the ground at landing, and for the angle at which these two lengths are the same. Part (c) asks for y as a function of x, which means removing the time. Part (d) asks how sharply the path bends at two places: where the body starts and where it is highest. The radius of curvature is the radius of the circle that fits the path best at that place.

We assume v0 = 20 m/s and α = 60°, because the problem gives no numbers, and g = 9.8 m/s². The speed and the angle are sliders. The answer for the angle where H = R does not depend on v0 or g.

Symbols: v0 is the launch speed, α the launch angle, τ the time of motion, H the greatest height, R the range, ρ the radius of curvature, an the acceleration across the path.

The big idea in plain words

Sideways, the body moves at a steady speed. Up and down, it is slowed by gravity and then pulled back, like a ball thrown straight up. Put the two together and the path is a parabola. How sharply a path bends depends on two things: how fast the body goes, and how much of gravity pushes across the path. Fast and little push means a gentle bend (a big radius). At the top, gravity pushes fully across the path, and the speed is lowest, so the bend is sharpest there.

Interactive derivation

The solution in each frame

Only the ground frame is needed. The launch velocity is given relative to the ground, and all the questions are about the path seen from the ground, so there is no second frame.

The solution step by step

Step 1, the motion. Take the launch point as the origin. Then x = v0 cos α t and y = v0 sin α t − gt²/2. For the numbers on screen: x = 10 t.

Step 2, the time of motion (part a). The body is back on the ground when y = 0: v0 sin α τ − gτ²/2 = 0. Apart from τ = 0, this gives τ = 2v0 sin α/g = 3.535 s.

Step 3, the height and the range (part b). At the top vy = 0, and vy² = (v0 sin α)² − 2gy gives H = v0² sin²α/(2g) = 15.31 m. The range is the sideways speed times the time: R = v0 cos α τ = 2v0² sin α cos α/g = v0² sin 2α/g = 35.35 m. For H = R: v0² sin²α/(2g) = 2v0² sin α cos α/g. Divide by v0² sin α/g: sin α/2 = 2 cos α, so tan α = 4 and α = 75.96°.

Step 4, the trajectory (part c). From x = v0 cos α t we get t = x/(v0 cos α). Put this into y: y = x tan α − gx²/(2v0² cos²α). For the numbers on screen, y = 1.732 x − 0.049 x².

Step 5, the curvature radii (part d). When a body moves on a curve with speed v and radius of curvature ρ, the acceleration across the path is an = v²/ρ. Here the only acceleration is g, pointing down. At the start the velocity makes the angle α with the horizontal, so g makes the angle α with the line across the path. The part of g across the path is an = g cos α. With v = v0: ρ0 = v0²/(g cos α) = 81.63 m. At the top, the velocity is horizontal, so all of g is across the path: an = g. The speed is v0 cos α. So ρ = v0² cos²α/g = 10.2 m.

Step 6, the cases. The problem has one situation, so no cases are needed. Two checks: for α = 90° (straight up) the range is zero and the start radius goes to infinity, because the path is a straight line. For a small α the top radius is nearly v0²/g, the largest possible, because the body then moves almost sideways at full speed.

Numerical check

A separate calculation does not use the formulas. It follows the body in 200000 small steps of time under g, and it reads off the landing time, the landing place and the highest point from the steps. It finds the radius of curvature from the velocity and acceleration at the start and at the top, as v³ divided by the size of v × a. It also finds the angle where H = R by repeated halving of an angle interval, using short runs of the motion at 20 m/s. The largest relative difference from the formulas is 3.5 × 10⁻⁹.

Five methods

1. Force method

The only force is gravity, so the acceleration is g downward. The curvature radii come from splitting g into the part along the path and the part across it.

2. Energy method

Energy conservation gives the speed at height y: v² = v0² − 2gy. At the top this gives the speed v0 cos α and the height H again. It also shows that the body lands with speed v0.

3. Graph method

The second graph shows the radius of curvature along the flight. It is largest at the start and landing and smallest at the top. The third graph shows H and R against the angle: they cross at tan α = 4.

4. Calculus method

The radius of curvature of a curve y(x) is ρ = [1 + (dy/dx)²]3/2/|d²y/dx²|. For this parabola, d²y/dx² = −g/(v0² cos²α). At x = 0, dy/dx = tan α, so ρ = (1/cos³α) v0² cos²α/g = v0²/(g cos α). At the top dy/dx = 0, so ρ = v0² cos²α/g. Both agree with step 5.

5. Check method

Units: v0²/g is (m/s)² divided by m/s², which is metres. The angle 45° gives the largest range v0²/g. For α = 0 the top radius is v0²/g and so is the start radius, as expected for a body thrown sideways. The top radius is never larger than the start radius, since cos²α ≤ 1/cos α.

Fastest: the force method for the radii, and the formulas for time, height and range. Most reliable: the calculus method with the numerical check.

What each slider changes

ControlChanges the answer?What it changes
Launch speed v0YesThe time, height, range, both radii, every graph and the picture scale
Launch angle αYesThe time, height, range, both radii, the path and the graphs
Moment shown tNoThe moving point, its arrows, the dots on the graphs and the live readings. The answers do not depend on it
Given-answer modeSets αThe page finds the angle for a chosen range (the smaller of the two angles), and warns if the range is too large for this speed or the angle is below 10°
Play and time barNoPlay holds 2 s at the start (curvature there), runs to the top and holds 2 s (curvature there), runs to the landing and holds 1.5 s, then repeats. The bar sets the time

Parameters

QuantitySymbolValue used
Launch speedv020 m/s
Launch angleα60°
Time of motionτ3.535 s
Greatest heightH15.31 m
RangeR35.35 m
Radius of curvature at the startρ081.63 m
Radius of curvature at the topρ10.2 m
Angle where H = Rarctan 475.96°

Exam traps

  • Using the full g as the acceleration across the path at the start. Only the part across the path counts: g cos α.
  • Using v0 as the speed at the top. There the speed is only the sideways part, v0 cos α.
  • Saying H = R at 45°. The range is largest at 45°, but H is only a quarter of R there. They are equal at tan α = 4.
  • Writing tan α = 1/4. From sin α/2 = 2 cos α we get tan α = 4.
  • Forgetting that these results need a level landing. If the ground is higher or lower, the time and the range change.