Irodov, Problem 1.72

In the arrangement shown in Fig. 1.16 the bodies have masses m0, m1, m2, the friction is absent, the masses of the pulleys and the threads are negligible. Find the acceleration of the body m1. Look into possible cases.

Time t 0.0 s
The answer in one line

w₁ = g[4m₁m₂ + m₀(m₁ − m₂)]/[4m₁m₂ + m₀(m₁ + m₂)], taken as positive downwards. With the numbers on screen, w₁ = 6.236 m/s², so m₁ moves down.

Problem statement

Problem 1.72. In the arrangement shown in Fig. 1.16 the bodies have masses m0, m1, m2, the friction is absent, the masses of the pulleys and the threads are negligible. Find the acceleration of the body m1. Look into possible cases.

Interpretation. In the arrangement shown, the bodies have masses m₀, m₁ and m₂. Friction is absent, and the masses of the pulleys and the threads are negligible. Find the acceleration of the body m₁. Look into the possible cases.

We assume m₀ = 2 kg, m₁ = 1.5 kg and m₂ = 1 kg to start. The problem uses letters only. All three are sliders.

We assume g = 9.8 m/s². It is a slider.

We assume the threads stay tight and do not stretch, and the table block m₀ stays on the table.

Symbols: T is the tension in the thread over the moving pulley, T₁ the tension in the thread on the table block, w₀ the acceleration of the table block (and of the moving pulley), and w₁, w₂ the accelerations of m₁ and m₂ downwards.

The big idea in plain words

The moving pulley has no mass, so the forces on it must balance even while it moves. The thread over it pulls down twice with T, so the thread from the table must pull up with 2T. That thread is the same one that pulls the table block, so T₁ = 2T.

The pulley sits half-way between the two hanging bodies. Its acceleration is the average of w₁ and w₂. This is the link that ties all five equations together.

Interactive derivation

The solution in each frame

Only the ground frame is needed. It is inertial and all the forces are real. A frame fixed to the moving pulley accelerates, so it would need pseudo-forces, which adds work and nothing else.

The solution step by step

Step 1, the table block. The only horizontal force on m₀ is the tension T₁, so T₁ = m₀w₀.

Step 2, the moving pulley. It has no mass, so T₁ − 2T = 0 and T₁ = 2T.

Step 3, the hanging bodies. Take down as positive. m₁g − T = m₁w₁ and m₂g − T = m₂w₂. So w₁ = g − T/m₁ and w₂ = g − T/m₂.

Step 4, the thread length. The table block moves right by the same distance that the pulley moves down. The pulley moves down by the average of the distances of m₁ and m₂. So w₁ + w₂ = 2w₀.

Step 5, eliminate. From steps 1 and 2, w₀ = 2T/m₀. Put this and step 3 into step 4: 2g − T(1/m₁ + 1/m₂) = 4T/m₀. So T = 2g m₀m₁m₂/[4m₁m₂ + m₀(m₁ + m₂)] = 5.345 N.

Step 6, the answer. w₁ = g − T/m₁ = g[4m₁m₂ + m₀(m₁ − m₂)]/[4m₁m₂ + m₀(m₁ + m₂)] = 6.236 m/s². By the same steps, w₂ = 4.455 m/s² and w₀ = 4m₁m₂g/[4m₁m₂ + m₀(m₁ + m₂)] = 5.345 m/s².

Step 7, the cases. The sign of w₁ depends on the top line, 4m₁m₂ + m₀(m₁ − m₂).

  • Case a, m₁ > m₂: w₁ is positive and larger than w₂. m₁ goes down faster than m₂.
  • Case b, m₁ = m₂: w₁ = w₂ = w₀. Both go down together, and neither moves relative to the pulley.
  • Case c, m₂ > m₁, but m₀(m₂ − m₁) < 4m₁m₂: w₁ is still positive, but smaller than w₂.
  • Case d, m₀(m₂ − m₁) > 4m₁m₂: w₁ is negative. m₁ goes up while m₂ goes down. The moving pulley still goes down.

The tension T is never zero and w₀ is always positive, so the table block always slides towards the edge, and the threads stay tight.

Numerical check

A separate calculation solves the five equations (block, pulley, m₁, m₂ and the thread link) as one linear system. It gives w₁ = 6.23636 m/s², against 6.236 m/s² from the formula. It also steps the motion forward for one second in 20000 small time steps, using the energy form of the equations of motion, and finds that m₁ moves 6.23668 m (written as twice that distance, to compare with w₁). The largest relative difference, including T, w₀ and w₂, is 3.2 × 10⁻⁵.

Five methods

1. Force method

Newton's second law for each body, plus the pulley rules and the thread link. This is steps 1 to 6.

2. Energy method

The block m₀ moves with the average speed of m₁ and m₂, so the kinetic energy is ½m₁v₁² + ½m₂v₂² + ½m₀((v₁ + v₂)/2)². The power of gravity is m₁gv₁ + m₂gv₂. Setting the rate of change of energy equal to the power for each body gives two linear equations in w₁ and w₂. The answer is the same, with no tensions needed.

3. Graph method

Plot w₁/g against m₀. It starts at 1 for a light table block and levels off at (m₁ − m₂)/(m₁ + m₂) for a heavy one. The first graph shows this and the dot is the current case.

4. Calculus method

Because the accelerations are constant, integrate twice: v = wt and distance = ½wt². The speeds graph shows straight lines, and the pulley line is always the average of the other two.

5. Check method

Units: g is in m/s² and the mass ratios have no units. Limits: if m₀ is very large, the table block does not move and the pulley is fixed, so w₁ = g(m₁ − m₂)/(m₁ + m₂), the ordinary two-body pulley result. If m₀ is almost zero, there is nothing to pull back on the pulley, so both bodies fall freely and w₁ = g. If m₁ = m₂, w₁ = 2g m₁/(2m₁ + m₀).

Fastest: the energy method, because it skips the tensions. Most reliable: the force method followed by the numerical check, because it also gives T and T₁.

What each slider changes

ControlChanges the answer?What it changes
Mass m₀Yesw₀, w₁, w₂, both tensions, how far the block slides and every curve
Mass m₁YesThe same, and the size of m₁ in the picture
Mass m₂YesThe same, and the size of m₂ in the picture
Gravity gYesEvery acceleration and force
Case buttons a to dSet the massesOne example for each case
Run a to dNoPlays the four cases in order
Given-answer modeSets m₀The page finds m₀ for a chosen w₁, and warns if it is out of range
Play and time barNoPlay runs the motion at half speed, holds 1.2 s at the end, then repeats. The bar sets the time

Parameters

QuantitySymbolValue used
Table blockm₀2 kg
Left hanging bodym₁1.5 kg
Right hanging bodym₂1 kg
Gravityg9.8 m/s²
Accelerations of m₁, m₂, blockw₁, w₂, w₀6.236, 4.455, 5.345 m/s²
TensionsT, T₁ = 2T5.345 N, 10.69 N
Result for a very heavy blockg(m₁ − m₂)/(m₁ + m₂)1.96 m/s²

Exam traps

  • Treating the moving pulley as fixed and writing w₁ = g(m₁ − m₂)/(m₁ + m₂). That is only the limit of a very heavy table block.
  • Using T₁ = T. The moving pulley has two threads pulling down, so T₁ = 2T.
  • Writing w₀ = w₁ or w₀ = w₂. The pulley moves with the average of the two.
  • Assuming m₁ goes down because it is the one asked about. In case d it goes up.
  • Forgetting that the table block slides by the same distance that the pulley falls, so w₀ is both the block's acceleration and the pulley's.