Irodov, Problem 1.77

In the arrangement shown in Fig. 1.21 the masses of the wedge M and the body m are known. The appreciable friction exists only between the wedge and the body m, the friction coefficient being equal to k. The masses of the pulley and the thread are negligible. Find the acceleration of the body m relative to the horizontal surface on which the wedge slides.

Time t 0.0 s
The answer in one line

The wedge accelerates to the right with w = mg/(km + 2m + M). The block falls on the wedge with the same w, so over the floor its acceleration is wm = √2 mg/(km + 2m + M), at 45° below the horizontal. With k = 0.5, M = 3 kg and m = 1 kg, wm = 2.52 m/s².

Problem statement

Problem 1.77. In the arrangement shown in Fig. 1.21 the masses of the wedge M and the body m are known. The appreciable friction exists only between the wedge and the body m, the friction coefficient being equal to k. The masses of the pulley and the thread are negligible. Find the acceleration of the body m relative to the horizontal surface on which the wedge slides.

Interpretation. In the arrangement shown, the masses of the wedge M and of the body m are known. There is appreciable friction only between the wedge and the body m, with coefficient k. The masses of the pulley and the thread are negligible. Find the acceleration of the body m relative to the horizontal surface on which the wedge slides.

We assume g = 9.8 m/s², M = 3 kg and m = 1 kg. The case buttons are k = 0, 0.5 and 1.5. All of these are sliders.

We assume the block slides on the wedge face, so the friction is the sliding kind, f = kN. The slope angle of the wedge does not matter, so it is drawn at 40° only for the picture.

Symbols: w is the acceleration of the wedge, wm the acceleration of the block over the floor, N the push of the wedge on the block, T the tension in the thread, f the friction force.

The big idea in plain words

The thread ties the block to the wedge. When the wedge moves a distance to the right, the thread between the foot pulley and the post gets shorter by that distance. So the thread from the block to the top pulley must get longer by the same distance, which means the block drops that distance on the wedge. The block and wedge therefore always have the same acceleration w, one down on the wedge and one to the right. The block moves with the wedge to the right, and falls down on it, so over the floor it moves at 45° below the horizontal.

Interactive derivation

The solution in each frame

Only the ground frame is needed. It is inertial. A frame fixed to the wedge accelerates and would need a pseudo-force on the block, which makes the working longer.

The solution step by step

Step 1, the thread length. The wedge moves x to the right. The thread from the foot pulley to the post is shorter by x. The rest of the thread has a fixed length, so the block drops x on the wedge. So the speed and the acceleration of the block on the wedge equal those of the wedge: both are w.

Step 2, the wedge. Take right as positive. The thread pulls the foot pulley to the right with T. The block pushes the wedge to the left with N. The other thread forces on the wedge are vertical. So T − N = Mw.

Step 3, the block, sideways. The block moves right with the wedge, so the push of the wedge is the only horizontal force: N = mw.

Step 4, the block, up and down. Take down as positive. The weight pulls down. The thread and the friction pull up, with friction f = kN. So mg − T − kN = mw.

Step 5, solve. From steps 2 and 3, T = (M + m)w and N = mw. Put them in step 4: mg = (M + m)w + kmw + mw. So w = mg/(km + 2m + M) = 1.782 m/s². Then N = 1.782 N, T = 7.127 N and f = 0.8909 N.

Step 6, the acceleration over the floor. The block's acceleration is the sum of its acceleration on the wedge (w down) and the wedge's acceleration (w right). They are at right angles and equal, so wm = √(w² + w²) = √2 w = 2.52 m/s², directed 45° below the horizontal, towards the wedge's side of motion.

Step 7, the limits.

  • No friction, k = 0: w = mg/(2m + M). This is the fastest case for given masses.
  • Very heavy wedge, M large: w tends to 0. The wedge will not move, so the block does not either.
  • Very heavy block, m large: w tends to g/(k + 2). Even then the block cannot fall freely, because it has to drag the wedge.

The block slides a distance d = 0.3 m in t = √(2d/w) = 0.58 s.

Numerical check

A separate calculation solves the three equations (wedge, block sideways and block up and down) as one linear system. It gets w = 1.78182 m/s², N = 1.7818 N and T = 7.1273 N, against 1.782, 1.782 and 7.127 from the formulas. It then slides the block the distance d in 400000 small steps and finds 0.58029 s, against 0.58 s. The largest relative difference is 1.0 × 10⁻⁶.

Five methods

1. Force method

Newton's law for the wedge and the block, with the thread rule. This is steps 1 to 6.

2. Energy method

While the wedge moves x, the block drops x on it. Gravity does work mgx. Friction does work −kN x = −kmwx. The kinetic energy is ½Mv² + ½m(√2v)² = (M/2 + m)v², with v² = 2wx. So mgx − kmwx = (M + 2m)wx, which gives the same w. This uses the friction force, which needs N = mw first.

3. Graph method

The first graph shows wm/g against k. It falls as k rises and is largest at k = 0. The third graph shows both speeds rising in a straight line, with the block always √2 times as fast.

4. Calculus method

Because w is constant, integrate twice for both the wedge and the block's drop: x = ½wt².

5. Check method

Units: mg is in newtons and the bottom is in kilograms, so w is in m/s². Limits: see step 7. For k = 0 and M = 0, w = g/2.

Fastest: the energy method. Most reliable: the force method with the numerical check, because it also gives N, T and f.

What each slider changes

ControlChanges the answer?What it changes
Friction kYesw, wm, N, T, f, the times and the curves
Wedge mass MYesw, wm, T, the times and the curves
Block mass mYesw, wm, the forces and the times
Sliding distance dNoThe picture and the time only
Gravity gYesBoth accelerations, the times and the forces
Case buttons a, b, cSet ka: 0. b: 0.5. c: 1.5
Given-answer modeSets kThe page finds k for a chosen wm and warns if k would be below 0 or above 2
Play and time barNoPlay runs the motion, holds 1.2 s at the end, then repeats. The bar sets the time

Parameters

QuantitySymbolValue used
Friction coefficientk0.5
Wedge massM3 kg
Block massm1 kg
Gravityg9.8 m/s²
Denominatorkm + 2m + M5.5 kg
Wedge accelerationw1.782 m/s²
Block acceleration over the floorwm2.52 m/s²
Push, tension, frictionN, T, f1.782, 7.127, 0.8909 N

Exam traps

  • Giving the answer as w. The question asks for the block's acceleration over the floor, which is √2 w.
  • Forgetting that N = mw. The wedge pushes the block sideways only because both accelerate right.
  • Taking N = mg. N is tiny here, since there is no sideways force except the one that accelerates the block.
  • Leaving the friction out of the up and down equation, or putting it in the wedge equation as well.
  • Giving the thread tension on the wedge as 2T. Only the pull at the foot pulley is horizontal.