Irodov, Problem 1.78

What is the minimum acceleration with which bar A (Fig. 1.22) should be shifted horizontally to keep bodies 1 and 2 stationary relative to the bar? The masses of the bodies are equal, and the coefficient of friction between the bar and the bodies is equal to k. The masses of the pulley and the threads are negligible, the friction in the pulley is absent.

Time t 0.0 s
The answer in one line

The least acceleration of the bar that keeps both bodies at rest on it is wmin = g(1 − k)/(1 + k). With k = 0.5 and g = 9.8 m/s², wmin = 3.267 m/s². The bodies also slip if w is too large: they stay at rest only for w between wmin and wmax = g(1 + k)/(1 − k) = 29.4 m/s².

Problem statement

Problem 1.78. What is the minimum acceleration with which bar A (Fig. 1.22) should be shifted horizontally to keep bodies 1 and 2 stationary relative to the bar? The masses of the bodies are equal, and the coefficient of friction between the bar and the bodies is equal to k. The masses of the pulley and the threads are negligible, the friction in the pulley is absent.

Interpretation. What is the minimum acceleration with which bar A should be shifted horizontally to keep bodies 1 and 2 stationary relative to the bar? The masses of the bodies are equal, and the coefficient of friction between the bar and the bodies is k. The masses of the pulley and the threads are negligible, and the pulley has no friction.

We assume g = 9.8 m/s² and a mass of 1 kg for each body. The mass only sets the forces in newtons. Both are sliders.

We assume body 1 lies on the top of the bar, body 2 touches the vertical face on the right, and the thread joins them over a pulley at the corner. The bar is pushed to the right. The friction coefficient is the same for static and sliding friction.

Symbols: w is the acceleration of the bar, T the tension, f1 and f2 the friction forces on the bodies, N1 and N2 the pushes of the bar on the bodies.

The big idea in plain words

If the bodies stay still on the bar, they move with the bar, so each has acceleration w. Body 2 is pressed on the bar face only by the push N2 = mw, so a slow bar gives it little push and little friction. Body 2 also hangs on the thread, which pulls body 1 forward on the top. Both frictions have to hold this arrangement. When w is too small, body 2 pulls body 1 to the right and slides down. When w is too big, the bodies slip the other way.

Interactive derivation

The solution in each frame

Ground frame: used for the working below. Frame of the bar: the bar accelerates, so a pseudo-force mw acts on each body to the left. The result is the same, with N2 balancing that force on body 2. The ground frame needs fewer ideas, so it is used.

The solution step by step

Step 1, body 1. Take right as positive. The thread pulls right with T. Friction f1 acts to the left. It moves with the bar: T − f1 = mw. Up and down: N1 = mg.

Step 2, body 2. The bar face pushes it right: N2 = mw. It does not move up or down: T + f2 = mg, with f2 upward.

Step 3, add the frictions. From steps 1 and 2: f1 = T − mw and f2 = mg − T. Adding, f1 + f2 = m(g − w). The tension T drops out.

Step 4, the friction limit. Each friction force is at most k times its push. So f1 + f2 ≤ k(N1 + N2) = km(g + w). Hence m(g − w) ≤ km(g + w).

Step 5, the minimum. For w below g, g − w ≤ k(g + w) gives w ≥ g(1 − k)/(1 + k). So wmin = g(1 − k)/(1 + k) = 3.267 m/s². At this value both frictions are at their limit: f1 = kmg to the left and f2 = kmw upward, so T = mg − kmw = 8.167 N when w = wmin.

Step 6, the upper limit. For w above g, w − g ≤ k(g + w) gives w ≤ g(1 + k)/(1 − k) = 29.4 m/s². Above this, body 1 slides left and body 2 rises. If k is 1 or more, there is no upper limit.

Step 7, the limits and the cases.

  • No friction, k = 0: wmin = wmax = g. The bodies are still only for exactly w = g.
  • k = 1 or more: the formula is zero or negative. Friction alone holds the bodies even for w = 0, so the least acceleration is 0. Here the page sets wmin = 0.
  • Too slow, w below wmin: body 1 slides right and body 2 slides down, with relative acceleration (g(1 − k) − w(1 + k))/2.
  • Too fast, w above wmax: body 1 slides left and body 2 slides up, with relative acceleration (w(1 − k) − g(1 + k))/2.

Now w = 3.267 m/s², and the bodies' state is shown in the readings box. For the Given values, the relative acceleration when slipping is 0 m/s².

Numerical check

A separate calculation does not use the formula. It tests, for each bar acceleration w, whether friction forces that satisfy both bodies' equations and both friction limits can exist. It halves the range 200 times and finds wmin = 3.26667 m/s², against 3.267 m/s² from the formula. When the bodies slip, it also solves the two equations with sliding friction, moves the bodies in 200000 small steps and compares the slide time. The largest relative difference is 6.8 × 10⁻¹¹.

Five methods

1. Force method

Newton's law for each body and the friction limit. This is steps 1 to 6.

2. Energy method

Not suitable. The bar is pushed by an outside force and friction does no useful work when nothing slides, so there is no energy balance that gives w.

3. Graph method

The first graph plots the friction needed, |g − w|, and the friction available, k(g + w), against w. The bodies are at rest where the needed curve is below the available curve. The curves cross at wmin and wmax.

4. Calculus method

Not needed for the limit. When the bodies slip, the relative acceleration is constant, so the slide is s = ½arelt².

5. Check method

Units: g and w are in m/s², and k has no units. Limits: for k = 0 both limits equal g, which is the case when body 2 falls freely and body 1 is pulled with acceleration g. For a very rough bar, wmin tends to 0.

Fastest: the force method with the added friction. Most reliable: the same, followed by the numerical check.

What each slider changes

ControlChanges the answer?What it changes
Friction kYeswmin, wmax, the forces, the slipping acceleration and the curves
Bar acceleration wNot wminThe state of the bodies, the forces, the relative motion and the picture
Mass of each bodyNoThe forces in newtons and the block sizes
Gravity gYeswmin, wmax, the forces and the slipping acceleration
Case buttons a, b, cSet ka: 0.2. b: 0.5. c: 1.2. They put w at wmin
Given-answer modeSets kThe page finds k for a chosen wmin and warns if wmin is g or more
Play and time barNoPlay runs the motion, holds 1.2 s at the end, then repeats. The bar sets the time

Parameters

QuantitySymbolValue used
Friction coefficientk0.5
Mass of each bodym1 kg
Gravityg9.8 m/s²
Least bar accelerationwmin3.267 m/s²
Greatest bar accelerationwmax29.4 m/s²
Bar acceleration noww3.267 m/s²
Push on body 2N2 = mw3.267 N

Exam traps

  • Using f2 = kmg for body 2. The push on body 2 is N2 = mw, not mg.
  • Putting the thread tension into the final inequality. T cancels when the two friction equations are added.
  • Forgetting that friction on body 1 acts to the left at wmin, because body 2's pull tends to move body 1 to the right.
  • Giving a negative wmin for k above 1. The least acceleration cannot be negative here. It is 0.
  • Forgetting the upper limit. A bar that is too fast also makes the bodies slip.