Irodov, Problem 1.79

A particle has shifted along some trajectory in the plane xy from point 1 whose radius vector r1 = i + 2j to point 2 with the radius vector r2 = 2i − 3j. During that time the particle experienced the action of certain forces, one of which being F = 3i + 4j. Find the work performed by the force F. (Here r1, r2 and F are given in SI units).

Path fraction s 0.0 s
The answer in one line

The work of a constant force is A = F · (r₂ − r₁) = FxΔx + FyΔy. With the numbers on screen, A = -17 J. For the given values, A = −17 J.

Problem statement

Problem 1.79. A particle has shifted along some trajectory in the plane xy from point 1 whose radius vector r1 = i + 2j to point 2 with the radius vector r2 = 2i − 3j. During that time the particle experienced the action of certain forces, one of which being F = 3i + 4j. Find the work performed by the force F. (Here r1, r2 and F are given in SI units).

We assume the force F stays constant during the motion, as the problem implies. It is a slider.

We assume the path between the points has no effect on the answer. The sliders "bow" and "twist" bend the path only to show this. Their starting values (0.8 and 0.6 metres) are assumed.

Symbols: r₁ and r₂ are the position vectors of points 1 and 2, Δr = r₂ − r₁ is the displacement, A is the work, and φ is the angle between F and Δr.

The big idea in plain words

Work is force times the distance moved along the force. Take a tiny step of the particle. The work in that step is F · dr. Now add up all the steps. The force is the same everywhere, so it comes out of the sum, and what is left is the sum of all the steps. That sum is simply the arrow from point 1 to point 2. So only the start and the end matter, and the wandering in between cancels out.

Interactive derivation

The solution in each frame

Only one frame is needed, the one in which r₁, r₂ and F are given. No acceleration or moving frame appears in the problem, so no other frame adds anything.

The solution step by step

Step 1, the work in a small step. In a tiny displacement dr the work is dA = F · dr.

Step 2, add up the steps. A = ∫F · dr. Since F is constant, A = F · ∫dr = F · (r₂ − r₁). The integral of dr from point 1 to point 2 is the vector r₂ − r₁, whatever the path.

Step 3, the displacement. Δr = (2 − 1) i + (-3 − 2) j = 1 i + -5 j metres.

Step 4, the dot product. Multiply the x parts and the y parts, then add: A = FxΔx + FyΔy = (3)(1) + (4)(-5) = 3 + -20 = -17 J. For the given values this is 3(1) + 4(−5) = 3 − 20 = −17 J.

Step 5, the sign of the given case. The given numbers give Δr = 1 i − 5 j, so A = 3 × 1 + 4 × (−5) = −17 J. The work is negative, because the force pushes up (+4 j) while the particle goes down (−5 j).

Step 6, the cases.

  • Case a, F = 3i + 4j: the given force. With the given points the work is −17 J, since the force has a part against the motion.
  • Case b, F = 5i + j: this force is at right angles to Δr = i − 5j, so A = 5 − 5 = 0. A force at right angles to the motion does no work.
  • Case c, F = −3i − 4j: the opposite of the given force, so the work is +17 J.

The angle between F and Δr is φ = 132°. Also A = |F||Δr| cos φ = 5 × 5.1 × cos φ.

Numerical check

A separate calculation does not use the dot product. It walks the particle along the path in 20000 small steps, and adds F · (each small step). It gets A = -17 J, against -17 J from the formula. It then repeats the walk on a very different, wavy path, and gets -17 J. The largest difference, as a fraction of |F||Δr|, is 3.3 × 10⁻¹⁵.

Five methods

1. Force method

Add F · dr along the path. This is steps 1 and 2.

2. Energy method

The work of F equals the change of kinetic energy it would cause if it were the only force. The problem gives no speeds or masses, so this method cannot be used here.

3. Graph method

The second graph shows the work done so far against the fraction of the path. It wanders on a curved path, but always ends at A. The first graph shows A against the direction of F. It is a cosine, largest when F points along Δr.

4. Calculus method

A = ∫(Fxdx + Fydy) = Fx(x₂ − x₁) + Fy(y₂ − y₁). Each part is a simple integral of a constant.

5. Check method

Units: newtons times metres give joules. Limits: if F is perpendicular to Δr, A = 0. If the two points are the same, A = 0. Reversing F reverses the sign of A.

Fastest: the dot product with the displacement. Most reliable: the dot product plus the numerical check along the real path.

What each slider changes

ControlChanges the answer?What it changes
Points 1 and 2 (x₁, y₁, x₂, y₂)YesThe displacement, the work, the picture and the curves
Force Fx, FyYesThe work, the angle, the arrow and the curves
Path bow and twistNoOnly the path drawn and the running-work curves. The total work stays the same
Case buttons a, b, cSet Fa: 3i + 4j. b: 5i + j. c: −3i − 4j
Given-answer modeSets one part of FThe page finds Fy (or Fx) for a chosen work, and warns if it is out of range
Play and time barNoPlay moves the particle along the path, holds 1.2 s at point 2, then repeats

Parameters

QuantitySymbolValue used
Point 1r₁(1, 2) m
Point 2r₂(2, -3) m
ForceF(3, 4) N
DisplacementΔr(1, -5) m
WorkA-17 J
Angle between F and Δrφ132°

Exam traps

  • Measuring the length of the path. The work of a constant force needs only the displacement.
  • Subtracting the vectors the wrong way. Δr = r₂ − r₁, end minus start.
  • Multiplying the vectors like numbers. Multiply the x parts together and the y parts together, then add.
  • Dropping the sign of a negative component. Here Δy = −5, so the y part of the work is negative.
  • Thinking the answer must be positive. Work can be negative when the force has a part against the motion.