Irodov, Problem 1.82

A body of mass m was slowly hauled up the hill (Fig. 1.29) by a force F which at each point was directed along a tangent to the trajectory. Find the work performed by this force, if the height of the hill is h, the length of its base l, and the coefficient of friction k.

Position x 0.0 s
The answer in one line

The work done by the pulling force is A = mg(h + kl). With the numbers on screen, A = 5.39 kJ (5390 J). The shape of the hill does not matter.

Problem statement

Problem 1.82. A body of mass m was slowly hauled up the hill (Fig. 1.29) by a force F which at each point was directed along a tangent to the trajectory. Find the work performed by this force, if the height of the hill is h, the length of its base l, and the coefficient of friction k.

Interpretation. A body of mass m was slowly hauled up a hill by a force F which at each point was directed along a tangent to the trajectory. Find the work performed by this force, if the height of the hill is h, the length of its base is l, and the coefficient of friction is k.

We assume "slowly" means the body has no acceleration, so its speed stays tiny and its kinetic energy does not change.

We assume g = 9.8 m/s², and the same friction coefficient k on the whole hill.

We assume m = 50 kg, h = 5 m, l = 20 m and k = 0.3, because the problem gives no numbers. All four are sliders.

We assume a hill profile y = h(1 − (1 − x/l)n) to draw the hill. With n = 2 it looks like the figure: steep at the foot and flat at the top. The slider n changes the shape, and the answer does not depend on it.

Symbols: θ is the angle of the slope, N the push of the hill on the body, f the friction, F the pull, A the work.

The big idea in plain words

The pull changes from point to point, because the slope changes. So do not try to use one force and one distance. Cut the climb into tiny steps. For each step, the pull does work that splits into two parts: lifting the body, and fighting friction. The lifting part adds up to mgh. The friction part adds up to k mg l. Neither depends on the shape.

Interactive derivation

The solution in each frame

Only the ground frame is needed. The hill is at rest in it, and the body has no acceleration, so no extra forces appear.

The solution step by step

Step 1, the force at one point. The body has no acceleration. Along the tangent, the pull balances the part of the weight along the slope and the friction: F = mg sinθ + f. Perpendicular to the surface, the push of the hill balances the other part of the weight: N = mg cosθ. Friction is f = kN = k mg cosθ. So F = mg(sinθ + k cosθ).

Step 2, one small step. Move a tiny distance ds along the path. The pull is along the path, so dA = F ds = mg sinθ ds + k mg cosθ ds. On the hill, ds sinθ is the small rise dy, and ds cosθ is the small run dx. So dA = mg dy + k mg dx.

Step 3, add the steps. All the rises add up to h. All the runs add up to l. So A = mg h + k mg l = mg(h + kl) = 5.39 kJ.

Step 4, split the result. The lifting part is mgh = 2.45 kJ. The friction part is k m g l = 2.94 kJ.

Step 5, the cases. If k = 0 there is no friction and A = mgh. If h = 0 the ground is flat and A = k mg l. For a straight ramp (n = 1) and a curved hill (n = 4) with the same h and l, the work is the same.

Numerical check

A separate calculation does not use the formula. It walks along the actual curve in 200000 small steps. In each step it finds the slope, the pull mg(sinθ + k cosθ) and the step length ds, then adds up F ds. It gets 5390 J, against 5390 J from the formula. The relative difference is 1.7 × 10⁻¹⁶.

Five methods

1. Force method

Find the pull at each point, then add F ds along the path. This is steps 1 to 3.

2. Energy method

The body ends at rest, so the net work is zero: A − mgh − (friction work) = 0. The friction work is the sum of k mg cosθ ds, which is k mg l. So A = mgh + k mg l. The same result, without the pull at each point.

3. Graph method

The third graph shows the work so far. The yellow curve is the lifting part, the orange curve is the friction part, and the green curve is their sum. At the top of the hill the green curve ends at mg(h + kl).

4. Calculus method

A = ∫F · ds = ∫mg dy + ∫k mg dx. Both integrals have fixed ends, so the path between them does not matter.

5. Check method

Units: mgh is kg × m/s² × m, which is joules. k has no unit, so k mg l is joules too. Limits: k = 0 gives mgh, and h = 0 gives k mg l.

Fastest: the energy method. Most reliable: the force method with the numerical check.

What each slider changes

ControlChanges the answer?What it changes
Mass mYesThe weight, every force and the work
Height hYesThe hill, the lifting work and the answer
Base lYesThe hill, the friction work and the answer
Friction kYesThe friction force and the friction work
Shape nNoThe curve and the slope at each point, but not the total work
Given-answer modeSets hThe page finds h for a chosen work and warns if h would be below 1 m or above 10 m
Play and position barNoPlay lets the body climb, holds 1.2 s at the top, then repeats

Parameters

QuantitySymbolValue used
Massm50 kg
Weightmg490 N
Heighth5 m
Base lengthl20 m
Friction coefficientk0.3
Hill shapen2
Slope at foot and topθ26.6 and 0 degrees
WorkA5.39 kJ

Exam traps

  • Using friction = k mg on the whole path. On a slope, N = mg cosθ, not mg.
  • Using the length of the curved path in the friction term. The friction work uses the base l, because cosθ ds = dx.
  • Giving only mgh. The friction work k mg l must be added.
  • Thinking the answer needs the shape of the hill. It needs only h and l.
  • Calling l the length of the slope. It is the length of the base.