Irodov, Problem 1.83

A disc of mass m = 50 g slides with the zero initial velocity down an inclined plane set at an angle α = 30° to the horizontal; having traversed the distance l = 50 cm along the horizontal plane, the disc stops. Find the work performed by the friction forces over the whole distance, assuming the friction coefficient k = 0.15 for both inclined and horizontal planes.

Journey 0.0 s
The answer in one line

The work done by the friction forces over the whole path is A = −kmgl/(1 − k cotα). With the numbers on screen, A = −49.65 mJ (-0.049649 J). It is negative because friction opposes the motion.

Problem statement

Problem 1.83. A disc of mass m = 50 g slides with the zero initial velocity down an inclined plane set at an angle α = 30° to the horizontal; having traversed the distance l = 50 cm along the horizontal plane, the disc stops. Find the work performed by the friction forces over the whole distance, assuming the friction coefficient k = 0.15 for both inclined and horizontal planes.

We assume the disc passes from the incline to the plane without losing speed, and that l is measured on the horizontal plane only, from the foot of the incline to the stopping point.

We assume g = 9.8 m/s². The problem values m = 50 g, α = 30°, l = 50 cm and k = 0.15 are the starting values. All four are sliders. The slider ranges keep tanα above k, so the disc always starts to slide.

Symbols: s is the distance covered on the incline, h = s sinα is the height it falls, A is the work of friction, T is the kinetic energy, U is the potential energy.

The big idea in plain words

The disc starts at rest and ends at rest. So all the potential energy it loses is turned into heat by friction. The friction work is therefore minus mgh. We do not know h, but we can find it. The stop condition tells us how far down the incline the disc must start. Then the answer follows.

Interactive derivation

The solution in each frame

Only the ground frame is needed. The incline and the plane are at rest in it, and the problem asks for the work in that frame.

The solution step by step

Step 1, the friction on each part. On the incline the push of the surface is N = mg cosα, so the friction is k mg cosα. On the plane N = mg, so the friction is k mg.

Step 2, the energy rule. The change of kinetic energy plus the change of potential energy equals the work of friction: ΔT + ΔU = A. The disc starts and stops at rest, so ΔT = 0. The potential energy falls by mgs sinα. The friction work is the sum of the two parts: A = −k mg cosα · s − k mg l.

Step 3, find s. Put ΔU = −mgs sinα into the rule: −mgs sinα = −k mg cosα · s − k mg l. Move the terms with s to one side: s(sinα − k cosα) = kl, so s = kl/(sinα − k cosα) = 20.27 cm.

Step 4, the work. A = −kmg(s cosα + l). Put in s: s cosα + l = l(sinα − k cosα + k cosα)/(sinα − k cosα) = l sinα/(sinα − k cosα) = l/(1 − k cotα). So A = −kmgl/(1 − k cotα). Here 1 − k cotα = 0.7402, and A = −49.65 mJ.

Step 5, the parts and the cases. On the incline friction does −12.9 mJ, and on the plane −36.75 mJ. Their sum is the same as −mgh = −49.65 mJ. If the incline is very steep (α near 90°), cotα is near zero, and A is close to −kmgl, the friction on the plane alone. If tanα is only just above k, the disc needs a long incline, and the work grows large.

Numerical check

A separate calculation does not use the formula. It first finds s by bisection, so that the disc stops exactly after l on the plane. It gets s = 20.265 cm, against 20.27 cm from the formula. It then steps the real motion in time, with steps of 20 microseconds, and adds up friction force times speed times step. It gets -0.0496483 J, against -0.049649 J from the formula. The stopping distance on the plane comes out as 49.9983 cm. The largest relative difference is 3.5 × 10⁻⁵.

Five methods

1. Force method

Find the acceleration on the incline, g(sinα − k cosα), and the slowing on the plane, kg. The speed at the foot is v = √(2g(sinα − k cosα)s), which is 1.212 m/s here. The stop condition v² = 2kgl gives the same s. Then add the two friction works.

2. Energy method

The method in steps 2 to 4. It needs no speeds and no times, which makes it the fastest.

3. Graph method

The first graph shows the energy shares. The yellow potential energy falls from 1 to 0. The orange friction heat rises from 0 to 1. The cyan kinetic energy rises and falls, and is zero at both ends. At the end the heat equals the starting mgh. The third graph shows |A| against l on log scales. It is a straight line with slope 1.

4. Calculus method

A = ∫f · dr along the whole path = −k mg cosα ∫ds (incline) − k mg ∫dx (plane). The two integrals are s and l.

5. Check method

Units: k mg l is joules. Limits: if k is near zero, s is near zero, and so is A. If α is near 90°, A goes to −kmgl. The energy check A = −mgh = 49.65 mJ agrees with the formula. The mass appears once in A and does not change s.

Fastest: the energy method. Most reliable: the force method with the numerical check.

What each slider changes

ControlChanges the answer?What it changes
Mass mYesThe weight, the energy and the work. Not s or the stopping point
Angle αYesThe slope, s, the start height and the work
Distance lYesThe plane, s, the height and the work
Friction kYesThe friction force, s and the work
Given-answer modeSets lThe page finds l for a chosen work and warns if l would be below 10 cm or above 100 cm
Play and journey barNoPlay shows the real motion in slow motion, holds 1.2 s at the stop, then repeats

Parameters

QuantitySymbolValue used
Massm50 g
Angleα30°
Distance on the planel50 cm
Friction coefficientk0.15
Distance on the inclines20.27 cm
Start heighth10.13 cm
Speed at the footv1.212 m/s
Real time of the motiont1.16 s
Friction workA−49.65 mJ

Exam traps

  • Giving only the friction work on the plane, −kmgl. The incline has friction too.
  • Using N = mg on the incline. There N = mg cosα.
  • Giving a positive answer. The work of friction is negative.
  • Forgetting that s is unknown. It comes from the stop condition.
  • Mixing units. Mass is 50 g = 0.05 kg and l is 50 cm = 0.5 m.