Irodov, Problem 1.88

A small body of mass m is located on a horizontal plane at point O. The body acquires a horizontal velocity v0. Find: (a) the mean power developed by the friction force during the whole time of motion, if the friction coefficient k = 0.27, m = 1.0 kg, and v0 = 1.5 m/s; (b) the maximum instantaneous power developed by the friction force, if the friction coefficient varies as k = αx, where α is a constant, and x is the distance from the point O.

Time fraction t/T 0.0 s
The answer in one line

(a) The mean power of friction is −kmg v₀/2 = −1.985 W. (b) The greatest power of friction has size ½ m v₀² √(αg) = 2.49 W, and it is negative because friction takes energy away.

Problem statement

Problem 1.88. A small body of mass m is located on a horizontal plane at point O. The body acquires a horizontal velocity v0. Find: (a) the mean power developed by the friction force during the whole time of motion, if the friction coefficient k = 0.27, m = 1.0 kg, and v0 = 1.5 m/s; (b) the maximum instantaneous power developed by the friction force, if the friction coefficient varies as k = αx, where α is a constant, and x is the distance from the point O.

We assume g = 9.8 m/s² and that the body slides in a straight line and stays at rest once it stops.

We assume m = 1 kg and v₀ = 1.5 m/s for both parts. Part (a) uses k = 0.27.

We assume α = 0.5 per metre in part (b), because the problem gives α only as a symbol. It is a slider. The formula for the greatest power works for any α.

Symbols: k is the friction coefficient, x the distance from O, v the speed, T the time to stop.

The big idea in plain words

Friction always points against the motion, so its power is negative: it takes energy out of the body. The body has the energy ½mv₀² at the start and none at the end, so friction removes exactly that much in both cases. What differs is how fast it does so. With a constant k the friction force is the same all the way, and the power fades steadily as the body slows. With k = αx the force starts at zero and grows, while the speed falls. Power is force times speed, so it rises, peaks, and falls back to zero.

Interactive derivation

The solution in each frame

Only the plane frame is needed. The plane is at rest in it, and friction is defined in it.

The solution step by step

Step 1, part (a), the motion. The friction force is kmg = 2.646 N, constant. The deceleration is kg, so v = v₀ − kgt. The body stops when v = 0, at T = v₀/(kg) = 0.5669 s, after a distance v₀²/(2kg) = 0.4252 m.

Step 2, part (a), the power. Friction opposes the velocity, so P = −kmg v = −kmg(v₀ − kgt). At the start it is −kmg v₀ = −3.969 W. It falls in a straight line to zero.

Step 3, part (a), the mean. The mean of a straight line is half of the start value. Mean P = −kmg v₀/2 = −1.985 W. With the numbers of the problem this is about −1.98 W.

Step 4, part (b), the speed. The friction force at distance x is mαgx. Newton's second law gives m v dv/dx = −mαgx, so v dv = −αg x dx. Adding up from x = 0, where v = v₀, gives v² = v₀² − αg x². The body stops at x = v₀/√(αg) = 0.6776 m.

Step 5, part (b), the power. P = −(mαgx) v = −mαg x √(v₀² − αg x²). It is zero at x = 0, where the force is zero, and zero at the stop, where the speed is zero.

Step 6, part (b), the greatest size. Look at x²(v₀² − αg x²). It is greatest when x² = v₀²/(2αg), so x = v₀/√(2αg) = 0.4792 m, halfway in energy terms. There v = v₀/√2. Putting these in, |P|max = mαg · v₀/√(2αg) · v₀/√2 = ½ m v₀² √(αg) = 2.49 W.

Step 7, the cases. If α is larger, the friction grows faster and the body stops sooner, but the greatest power is larger by √α. If v₀ doubles, the greatest power in (b) is four times larger.

Numerical check

A separate calculation does not use the formulas above. In (a) it slows the body in 200 000 small steps and adds up force times speed times the small time. It gets a time of 0.56689 s and a mean power of -1.9845 W, against 0.5669 s and −1.985 W from the formulas. In (b) it steps the equation of motion with a growing friction force. It gets a stop time of 0.70961 s and a greatest power of 2.4903 W, against 0.7096 s and 2.49 W. The largest relative difference is 1.5 × 10⁻¹¹.

Five methods

1. Force method

Write the friction force, multiply by the speed, and keep the sign. This is steps 1 to 6.

2. Energy method

Friction removes ½mv₀² = 1.125 J in both cases. In (a), dividing by T gives the mean power. This is the fastest way to part (a). For (b) it gives the mean power −m v₀² √(αg)/π, but not the greatest one.

3. Graph method

In (a), P against t is a straight line, so the mean is the middle value. In (b), P against t is one smooth hump, with its lowest point in the middle of the motion in time. The graphs on the page show both against the fraction of their own time.

4. Calculus method

In (a), the mean is the integral of P dt divided by T. In (b), set d/dx of x√(v₀² − αg x²) to zero. Both give the results above.

5. Check method

Units: kmg v is newtons times metres per second, which is watts. For (b), α has units of 1/m, so αg has units 1/s² and √(αg) is 1/s. Then m v₀² √(αg) is joules per second. Limits: if α goes to zero there is no friction, and the power goes to zero.

Fastest: the energy method for (a), the calculus method for (b). Most reliable: the force method with the numerical check.

What each slider changes

ControlChanges the answer?What it changes
Mass mYesEvery power and the work. Not the times or distances
Start speed v₀YesBoth cases, in the times, distances, powers and work
Friction coefficient kPart (a)The time, distance and mean power of (a) only
αPart (b)The time, distance and greatest power of (b) only
Given-answer modeSets αThe page finds α for a chosen greatest power, and warns if it is outside 0.1 to 1.5 per metre
Play and time barNoPlay runs both blocks together, each over the fraction of its own time, holds 1.2 s, then repeats

Parameters

QuantitySymbolValue used
Massm1 kg
Start speedv₀1.5 m/s
Friction coefficient in (a)k0.27
Growth rate in (b)α0.5 per metre
Time to stop in (a)v₀/(kg)0.5669 s
Time to stop in (b)π/(2√(αg))0.7096 s
Mean power in (a)−1.985 W
Greatest power in (b)2.49 W
Mean power in (b)−1.585 W

Exam traps

  • Giving the mean power of (a) as kmg v₀. The speed falls to zero, so the mean is half.
  • Giving a positive power. Friction takes energy away, so P is negative. The question about the maximum asks for the size.
  • Taking the greatest power at the start in (b). At x = 0 the friction force is zero, so P is zero there.
  • Putting the greatest power at the stop. The speed is zero there, so P is zero again.
  • Using v₀ instead of v in P = −mαgx v. The speed changes with x as v² = v₀² − αgx².