Irodov, Problem 1.89

A small body of mass m = 0.10 kg moves in the reference frame rotating about a stationary axis with a constant angular velocity ω = 5.0 rad/s. What work does the centrifugal force of inertia perform during the transfer of this body along an arbitrary path from point 1 to point 2 which are located at the distances r1 = 30 cm and r2 = 50 cm from the rotation axis?

Path progress 0.0 s
The answer in one line

The work of the centrifugal force is A = ½ mω²(r₂² − r₁²). With the numbers on screen, A = 0.2 J. It is the same for every path from point 1 to point 2.

Problem statement

Problem 1.89. A small body of mass m = 0.10 kg moves in the reference frame rotating about a stationary axis with a constant angular velocity ω = 5.0 rad/s. What work does the centrifugal force of inertia perform during the transfer of this body along an arbitrary path from point 1 to point 2 which are located at the distances r1 = 30 cm and r2 = 50 cm from the rotation axis?

We assume the frame turns at a steady rate, so ω does not change. The work is found in the turning frame, where the centrifugal force exists.

We assume the body is moved slowly, so that only the centrifugal force is considered. Other forces, such as the push that moves it, are not part of the question.

We assume m = 0.1 kg, ω = 5 rad/s, r₁ = 0.3 m and r₂ = 0.5 m, which are the problem values. All four are sliders. The shape of the path is not given, so the page draws one that turns round the axis by 90° and wanders in and out by 0.04 m. Both are sliders.

Symbols: r is the distance from the axis, F the centrifugal force, A the work.

The big idea in plain words

In a turning frame, a body seems to be pushed straight away from the axis. This push is the centrifugal force, and it gets stronger the farther out the body is. Work is force times the move along the force. When the body moves outward, the force does positive work. When it moves inward, the force does negative work. When it moves round the axis, at right angles to the force, there is no work. So only the change in distance from the axis counts, and the path between the two points does not matter.

Interactive derivation

The solution in each frame

Only the turning frame is used. The centrifugal force of inertia belongs to this frame. In the ground frame there is no such force, and the body would simply move in a straight line unless other forces act.

The solution step by step

Step 1, the force. In the turning frame the centrifugal force on a body at distance r is F = mω²r. It points straight out from the axis. With the numbers, F = 2.5 × r N. At point 1 it is 0.75 N. At point 2 it is 1.25 N.

Step 2, a small move. The body moves a tiny step dr. The work is F dotted with dr. Split the step into a part along the radius, dr, and a part round the axis. The part round the axis is at right angles to F and gives zero. So dA = F dr = mω²r dr.

Step 3, add them up. The distance changes from r₁ to r₂. The sum of r dr is ½(r₂² − r₁²). So A = ½ mω²(r₂² − r₁²).

Step 4, the numbers. A = ½ × 0.1 × 5² × (0.5² − 0.3²) = 0.2 J. For the values of the problem this is 0.20 J.

Step 5, the path. The result has no path in it. A path that goes out too far and comes back adds work on the way out and takes the same back on the way in. The drawn path is 0.704 m long, while a straight path would be 0.2 m. The work is the same.

Numerical check

A separate calculation does not use the formula for A. It takes the path drawn on the screen, cuts it into 100 000 tiny steps, and at each step finds the force as a pair of numbers (x and y parts) and multiplies it by the step in the same way. It adds up all the results and gets 0.2 J, against 0.2 J from the formula. The relative difference is 4.2 × 10⁻¹⁶. Change the turn or the wanderings and the check still agrees.

Five methods

1. Force method

Write the force, take its part along each small move, and add. This is steps 1 to 4.

2. Energy method

The centrifugal force has a potential energy, U = −½mω²r². The work is minus the change of U, which is ½mω²(r₂² − r₁²). This also shows why the path does not matter.

3. Graph method

F against r is a straight line through zero. The work is the area under it from r₁ to r₂, a trapezoid. Its area is the mean force, 1 N, times the change in distance, 0.2 m. The first graph on the page shades this area.

4. Calculus method

A = ∫ mω²r dr from r₁ to r₂. This is step 3.

5. Check method

Units: kg × (1/s)² × m² is kg m²/s², which is joules. Limits: if r₂ = r₁ the work is zero. If ω = 0 there is no force and no work.

Fastest: the energy method. Most reliable: the force method with the numerical check.

What each slider changes

ControlChanges the answer?What it changes
Mass mYesThe force and the work
Angular speed ωYesThe force and the work, as ω²
Distance r₁YesWhere the path starts, the force there and the work
Distance r₂YesWhere the path ends, the force there and the work
Turn of the pathNoThe shape and length of the path only. The work stays the same
Wiggle of the pathNoThe shape and length of the path only. The work stays the same
Given-answer modeSets ωThe page finds ω for a chosen work, and warns if it is outside 2 to 6 rad/s
Play and progress barNoPlay moves the body along the path over 6 s, holds 1.2 s, then repeats

Parameters

QuantitySymbolValue used
Massm0.1 kg
Angular speedω5 rad/s
Distance of point 1r₁0.3 m
Distance of point 2r₂0.5 m
Force at point 1mω²r₁0.75 N
Force at point 2mω²r₂1.25 N
Length of the drawn path0.704 m
WorkA0.2 J

Exam traps

  • Using the force at one point times the distance. The force grows with r, so use the mean force or the area.
  • Using the path length. Only the change in distance from the axis, r₂ − r₁, matters.
  • Forgetting the square. The work is ½mω²(r₂² − r₁²), not ½mω²(r₂ − r₁)².
  • Mixing centimetres and metres. Change 30 cm and 50 cm to 0.30 m and 0.50 m first.
  • Using this force in the ground frame. The centrifugal force of inertia exists only in the turning frame.